I agree with you. On the rare occasions I have dealt with them, they have excellent customer service. And I understand the value of oem parts. Each year that goes by there are a few less cj's on the road.
What I don't like about them is their attitude towards the jeep hobby. They buy the junked out jeeps for a few hundred bucks a piece and expect to make 4 to 5k off the parts. Here about 15 or 20 years ago collins bros went to almost every junkyard around Texas picking up wrecked cj's (Their big field of parts didn't appear overnight) and hauling them back to their own yard. That's why there's not any junkyard cj's in Texas anymore. I understand the value of these parts and know that all the hard to find stuff is no longer produced and if I made a business strictly based on jeeps I would expect a little monetary return also, but not to the point to where I rip people off just to make a buck. Over the last 6 months I have bought or received FREE from local jeepers just about every oem part I need to restore my jeep. And for those of you who have seen the pics, my jeep needs a LOT of parts. All the pics Ive posted so far are only a sample of what I bought. All have been more than generous and I have made a great deal of friends from this experience.
By jacking up the prices of all their used parts collins brothers destroys the hobby for regular people like me who can't afford to pay 1k for a wrecked frame and a scrambler bed. this both ruins the thrill of hunting for parts and ruins the value of my jeep. Lots of people who may want it in the future would turn it away because of the money I have invested and the resluting price. When I'm done with my jeep, I want it to be something I can drive and enjoy. NOT a vehicle that I roll out once a month to put in car shows. I believe parts should be bought and sold to help out other people in the hobby, not for personal gain. I've also learned that when a part is bought by collins bros for, lets say $5, and they sell it for $40, then the person that sells that part in the future will also expect to get $40 or very close to it. Very rarely does a part drop substantially enough in value to become a good deal again. If you look at it this way, Collins bros is slowly and singlehandedly destroying the cj hobby for people like me. This type of business means that people who can't afford the parts can't afford to have the jeep that they want, hence less people in the hobby.
The used parts won't last forever, that's a fact. Once they're gone, they're gone. But if you look at them for what they are, they're just parts. That $900 AMC cb radio on ebay is nothing more than a used 30 year old radio. Those perfect-condition highback seats are just a steel frame, some foam and cheap vinyl from the 80's. That AMC emblem is a piece of plastic, and that spare tire carrier is 2 pieces of square tubing and some bent flat-stock. Now if all these parts were treated for what they were, we wouldn't have any left since they would basically have no value and get trashed, so I'm not trying to do that by any means. But I often question the sanity of people who pay 1k for a used radio on ebay. I guess if they can afford it it's a no-brainer for them, but its just crazy to me.
Sorry, I tend to get a little carried away but I would love to see the jeep hobby made affordable for everyone so they can enjoy it regardless of their budget. And with the effect of collins brothers being felt in places like ebay, craigslist, and even here on the forums I just don't see it happening any time soon.
I tend to ramble a bit but that's my 2 cent opinion of collin's brothers jeeps.