• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Why does my 258 whistle?

jak inc

I H8 RUST!
Lifetime Member
City
Merton
State
WI
I need some suggestions for solving a problem on my automatic CJ-7 with a 258. Once it warms up and is being driven, there is a whistling noise under the hood. The whistling noise usually starts immediately upon deceleration after the jeep has been driven at a sustained speed (ie 45mph). The whistling noise changes pitch as the throttle is increased or decreased. It usually stops whistling when it drops to idle so it is very hard for me to pin point because I am driving it while it is whistling. The couple times it did it while idling and I was able to open the hood, it sounded like it was coming from the air diverter valve (as shown by white arrow in photo). I replaced the air diverter valve (same part number and was pulled from another running 258) and it still whistles. I have checked all over for vacuum leaks and have found nothing. Hopefully someone has heard of this or had this problem and could make some suggestions. I have run out of ideas… THANK YOU!

Jeff

attachment.php
 
I chased a whistling sound in my scrambler for months.
whenever i stopped and raised the hood the noise would
stop. i changed all vacuum hoses and carb gaskets and vacuum
plugs. thought i might have a cracked head. changed the
water pump, etc..

guess what it was...

heater core was stopped up. the whistling was the water
restriction at the heater core.

no more whistling here with new heater core.

good luck.
 
Thanks for replying. I will try driving it after I bypass the heater core.

At this point I will try anything.... this whistling is driving me batty! Please keep the suggestions coming.

Thanks again!

Jeff
 
I had a whistling coming from under the hood at low rpms...got higher pitched when revved up. Turns out there was a leak at the base of the Weber carb, kind of between the carb and the restrictor plate. Note that the carb was not loose and there were no irregularities in the mounting surfaces. Someone on a trail ride said they knew what the problem was, and from their tool box pulled out a brush-on clear sealer that was made for stopping little air leaks like that. It took about one minute to fix something that had almost driven me crazy for two years!!

I don't remember the name of the sealer, but I'm sure you could find something similar at an auto parts store. Just brush it around all the gasket areas near your carb.

Good luck and let us know what you find out!

-Mike
 
Thanks for the suggestion. I did not have a chance to stop at Napa for the brush on sealant, but I did snug up the bolts on the carbuerator. They were a little loose, but not much. I drove it and it still is whistling. My next step is to by pass the heater core and if that doesn't work, I will track down the clear brush on sealant.

On a side note, this jeep had been sitting for 20 years when I bought it. I replaced all the old hoses when I purchased it. Upon replacing the thermostat, I found a wire sticking out of the thermostat cavity. I pulled it out with a long needle nose pliers from way down in the block. I should have taken a picture of it. I am figuring it was part of the lower radiator hose spring. It was completely straightened out from being sucked into the motor. This is making me believe the heater core could be clogged up with something. I will soon see.

Thanks again. Please keep the ideas coming!
 
Easy way to check for a vacuum leak and whistle from that would be starting fluid. Put a straw in the nozzle and then with engine running, spray around suspected areas. If there is a vacum leak then it will suck it into the engine and the RPM's will increase. Fix that one and move on.

If all vacuum and gaskets leaks are fixed then maybe look at the heater coil and hoses.



Carl
 
Carl,

Thanks for the suggestion. A mechanic friend actually suggested the starting fluid trick a while ago and I did it. I found a few cracked hoses and replaced them. I also replaced the intake gasket a while ago. I will go through and spray everything again in case there is some new leaks. Thanks again.

Jeff
 
Update!

I sprayed some areas yesterday with starting fluid and did not find any new vacumn leaks. Today I disconnected the hose from the compressor to the diverter valve, the hose from the diverter valve to the manifold, and plugged the vacumn hose to the diverter valve. Tomorrow I will test drive it and we'll see. I was able to catch it whistling yesterday and started wiggling hoses and such to try and find where it was coming from. When I wiggled the diverter the whistling stopped. That is why I decided to pull the whole system out of the equation.

Jeff
 
Last edited:
Well it still was whistling this morning. So I removed the belt from the air pump, in case it was coming from that. It still whistled. Then I removed and plugged the vacumn line from the brake booster. I drove it and it still whistled. Next I bypassed the heater core with a flushing T and it still was whistling.

I have a few more things I will try this evening before I drive it tomorrow.
 
I have a whistling coming right from my carb. It runs great and there are no leaks so far as I can tell, so I ignore it and assume it's just some weird air flow thing. It's an MC2100, so probably not relevant to your issue, but the solution is the same.
 
Uh...

Maybe its just happy to be working? You know what the gnomes sang about...Whistle while you...uh, sorry. Couldn't resist. Heehee
 
I think it has to be a manifold vacuum leak. Ported vacuum increases as you gain RPMs/increase speed. When you decelerate, lifting your foot off the gas pedal closes the throttle plates and maximum manifold vacuum is reached. Both your initial post and post #4 whistle upon deceleration. After saying all that, I'd suspect you whistle is coming from below the throttle plates. You might check the following:
a) carburetor mounting gasket. Even if it is new, it has to be installed correctly-right side up.
b) egr valve - emissions systems can have ported or manifold vacuum - I didn't take the time to look up a vacuum line diagram for your Jeep. A leaking EGR can whistle. Bypass the EGR and take a test drive.
c) check to see if the throttle plates pivot shaft fits snug in the bore of the carb body. If you can wiggle the throttle plates, the bore is worn out and can cause a vacuum leak.
d) did you spray carb cleaner on the intake manifold gasket area? It could also be leaking from the bottom side. Note: (in this area especially) instead of carb cleaner, you can spray clean water and listen for a miss - it is safer than carb cleaner, (avoid the flash up). Just use a clean spray bottle that shoots a stream. It doesn't take alot to create a miss if you have a leak.
e) when you disconnected the vacuum line to the brake booster, did you spray carb cleaner around the fitting at the manifold and where hose connects to that fitting?


That's all I can think of - may be a stretch, but all are easy enough to check out. Good luck!
 
Thanks R&R!

I am printing out your suggestions and taking them out to the shop to try. I will post up my results when complete.
 
Found the problem!

As suggested from R&R, we sprayed the intake manifold area and found the leak. We removed, washered (grade 5 split, I didn't have grade 8 in stock), and re-torqued bolts #6, #7, and #11 to spec. The drawing is from the Jeep Technical Service Manual. No more whistling.:woot: Thanks R&R.

attachment.php


It was almost a year to date that we replaced the intake manifold gasket, so I don't know why these would loosen up, but they did. A mechanic friend said that these bolts tend to loosen up on these AMC sixes if the intake is a little warped. I will see come spring when I start driving her again. As for now, they have started shooting salt on our streets again. :(

Thanks again for everyone's help.
 
Excellent! Mine still whistles from the carb bowl. I've noticed now that when I can hear it, it's a good time to close the choke down a little, then it goes away. Sorta like a built in warning for having the choke open too much.

I did some intake/exhaust work right when I brought the CJ home in April. Come late June, it started bogging down and I traced it back to loose manifold bolts. I think with the heat/cool cycling, retorquing after some mileage is to be expected once or twice.
 
That's great news! You are certainly welcome - I'm glad you were fix it.

Now I'm thinkin' I'll check/re-torque my manifold bolts before spring rolls around.
 
Almost another year to date...

Well, I have been driving the 7 almost another year again and the whistle has come back today.:shrug: Looks like I will have retorq the manifold again tomorrow.
 
Retorqued manifold bolts to spec tonight.... whistling is gone once again.:fingerscrossed:

Maybe I will get another year out of it?
 
Back
Top