• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

The infamous door cracks: ideas?

jscherb

CJ-8 Member
City
Elmira
State
NY
I'm in the process of refinishing a pair of 94 Wrangler doors to replace the originals on my Scrambler. While doing this I want to fix two major design flaws.

First, the joint where the vertical window frame joins the door panel sheet metal. In TJ Wranglers, Jeep wised up and welded this joint, but for CJ's and YJ's, the metal was free to rub if the door flexed and this is a common cause of rust on the door frame. I've welded these joints and have sculpted the weld to make nice fillets.

The second thing I want to fix/prevent are the stress cracks that develop by the vent window frame. One of my Wrangler doors is not cracked, the other has a crack that's short enough that it doesn't show because it is hidden by the weatherstriping. I've welded the one crack, but I know that's not enough to prevent it from happening again some years from now.

Has anyone repaired their doors and reinforced this area? What have you done? Ideas please...
 
The aproach I had was to place some 1/2 inch strap that ran the full length of the window on the inside of the door. I then drilled several holes in the door inorder to spot weld the strap to the door. The thought being that this will reinforce and stop the flex, thus preventing the cracks.

I have not completed this process on both of my doors as of this date. Thus I cannot say beyond a shadow of a doubt that they will not come back. I do however feel very confident that this problem will not happen again.

Good Luck SC
 
That sounds like it would likely work... what I'm wondering right now is if it would be sufficient to reinforce say 2"-3" near the crack area or if you'd need to reinforce the whole length of the door.
 
I chose to enforce as much of the door as possible. The reason being I did not want to re-visit this latter. The thought I have is if you only re-inforce 3-4 inches you may only move the crack problem 3-4 inches.

I would do a minium 10 inches, the longer the support the better stability and less flex.

Good luck
SC
 
The reinforcement is exactly what I plan on doing when I get around to doing my doors. May be a little work, but will be worth it.
 
Make sure your fix addresses future rust concerns, too. Just a thought.

Think about why the door cracks in that particular spot. It's fatigue that causes the crack and to fix it, you have to figure what stresses are applied to cause it. I don't have the issue on my Jeep, but have seen it and it seems related to vibration or motion in the area near the vent post. I'm pretty sure it's caused because the down flange that accepts the outer glass wiper/seal doesn't run uninterupted from the back of the door to the front. In other words the structure isn't boxed front to rear. I have a NOS bare shell. I'll take a look and see if I can come up with some ideas.

Paul
 
Here's my fix

Attached photos and drawings should be self-explanatory. Basically a piece of 1/2" angle iron plug welded up inside the inner door panel. Really improves the strength and won't let the sheet metal stretch at the point where the crack normally occurs. An added plus is that it is an invisible fix.
attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • doorfix.jpg
    doorfix.jpg
    233.3 KB · Views: 773
Last edited:
Makes sense that it's from pulling the door shut with the strap, considering the vent pillar is the last place where the door is reinforced (on the inside). I like that angle steel idea, may do that to mine, if there's anything left of them when I get to it!
I have a different issue- the upper hoops rotted clean thru, front and rear. When they were first starting to go, I made some reinforcing straps with 1 x 1/8" and 3/4 x 1/8" steel stock. I laid the 1" over the weak spot, and cut a piece about 6" long. Then I cut a piece of the 3/4" about 5" long, and put that over the 1" piece that went over the hole. I drilled thru em both and into the frame, and attached them with sheetmetal screws. For the front, since the rusted spot was right near the sill of the door, I used one piece of 1 x 1/8" stock and drilled four holes- two in the door, two in the hoop, and again affixed them with sheetmetal screws.
Well, now those straps are the only things holding the hoops to the doors! The rot has gotten so bad you can see down into the door. Does anyone know how I can either repair or replace the upper hoops?
 
I'm pretty sure the hoops rust where they join the door panels because they are not welded there and can rub against the sheet metal outer door skins. When the paint gets rubbed through rust starts. If you look closely at the photos I've posted you can see how I welded this joint and sculpted a nice fillet there. As I mentioned in my first post on this topic, TJ's are welded there, so that's what I did when refinishing my doors. Luckily I only had a little surface rust there. I wish I had some advice on fixing ones that are rusted through, but I didn't have that problem. Probably I'd make replacement panels and weld them on that would be a bit of fabrication and welding work...
 
Just got the doors back from the paint shop, thought I'd share some photos. Don't mind the dust on the photos, haven't cleaned all the buffing residue off yet...

crackfix.jpg shows where the internal reinforcement is welded into the door skin, I haven't reinstalled the window and seals yet but you can see the reinforcement won't ever be visible. You'll probably have to refer back to earlier photos in this thread to see where the reinforcement actually is. :-)

fillets.jpg shows before and after shots of the joints where the vertical window frame joins the outer door skin. The "before" is my current set of doors, which aren't in bad shape at these joints, although you can see some slight surface rust in these spots; the "after" is the new set of doors with these joints welded up as they are on TJ doors. These doors were quite rusted in these spots before I cleaned them up and welded the fillets. These will never rust in this spot again.

I'm really happy with the way the doors turned out. Now just have to find time to reinstall the windows and seals, stick the new doors on and sell the old ones...

attachment.php


attachment.php
 
Last edited:
Looks great! You did a great job on those. Maybe I'll finish mine one of these days. Sinnce I bought Half doors & fiber glass uppers I have not not worked on mine any more. The real reason has probabaly been the heat as well.

Take Care
SC
 
Where did the photos go?

Hi. New here and I was sent a link to see the fix for my cracking doors. When I arrive the photos are MIA. MUst be a very old thread but this kind of info needs to be available for those of us in need.

If someone has the original photos, I would love to look at all of the solutions for the cracking. Thanks.
 
weapon said:
Where did the photos go?

Hi. New here and I was sent a link to see the fix for my cracking doors. When I arrive the photos are MIA. MUst be a very old thread but this kind of info needs to be available for those of us in need.

If someone has the original photos, I would love to look at all of the solutions for the cracking. Thanks.

All three of the photos I posted in this thread still seem to be here, just accessed them all. Not sure what the problem is that you're having...

These photos (and more) turned into an article in jRations magazine, in issue 5, if you can put your hands on a copy of the magazine (or PM me your email address).
 
Last edited:
All three of the photos I posted in this thread still seem to be here, just accessed them all. Not sure what the problem is that you're having...

These photos (and more) turned into an article in jRations magazine, in issue 5, if you can put your hands on a copy of the magazine (or PM me your email address).
I know this is older post but photo also didn't show up. Could you send me the photos also if you still have them. Not sure how to Pm you either kinda new at this.
 
I know this is older post but photo also didn't show up. Could you send me the photos also if you still have them. Not sure how to Pm you either kinda new at this.
There is a thread somewhere of the step by step process of fixing the cracks in the doors that jscherb posted at one time. I am not sure if the pictures survived that thread, but they were there a few years ago.

It might take a few more searches through the forum to find it.
 
I know this is older post but photo also didn't show up. Could you send me the photos also if you still have them. Not sure how to Pm you either kinda new at this.
 
Back
Top