• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Keep the 304?

jmiller81

Legacy Registered User
City
State Line
State
MS
I have just started a restoration on an 81 scrambler with the amc 304. I want to fix the jeep back as near original as i can.. All i will be using it for is cruising the highway and going hunting. I am faced with a decision of whether to rebuild the 304 or buy a remanufactured 258. I wanna take the cheapest route. The 304 was running when I parked it but had a bad miss in it but really didnt run terrible. Anyway I would like to hear from anybody that kept and restored the 304 if they were satisfied with it..
 
wish I had more to offer but the reality of it is the 304 is just a "little" more powerful than the 258.
You mentioned the word "restore" which brings correctness to mind..so 4.2. You can resto-mod anything into there.....even a 6.0 powerstroke if time and money allow.

If your content with the power available from the 304..then keep it. If your itching for change then do it. It boils down to you being happy with it. That is one of the greatest things about the Jeeps in general...if your find a weak spot...you can generally swap something better in place of the weak part and have a bulletproof machine..

Best of luck!:twocents:
 
Cheapest route is almost alwasy to fix what is in there unless it has major obivous problems. Changing to a new power-plant adds a list of little things that add up in terms of time/money that are hard to figure up front exactly.
But your description, "a bad miss" is kind of vague.... That could be a bad plug or a swallowed valve and hole in a piston.

Did it go bang! and then miss? Or just kind of start missing on one cylinder sometimes ad it got worse and worse? Lots of checks can be done to diagnose that for free/very cheap.

The 304 is a good motor. It got weak in stock form towards the end, but lots of stuff out there reasonably priced to bring it back to life. Unless you found the 258 on the side of the road, at night, with no one around.... I bet you could swap the carb, intake and ignition on the 304 for the same or less money; not have to deal with motor mounts, clutch swaps, exhaust, etc... and you would certainly have a more powerful motor.
 
The 304 is a good motor. It got weak in stock form towards the end, but lots of stuff out there reasonably priced to bring it back to life. Unless you found the 258 on the side of the road, at night, with no one around.... I bet you could swap the carb, intake and ignition on the 304 for the same or less money; not have to deal with motor mounts, clutch swaps, exhaust, etc... and you would certainly have a more powerful motor.

Agreed,
and FWIW...6 and 8 Cyl clutches are usually interchangable...in CJ's its usually a 10.5 or 11, 1 1/8th 10 spline:thumbsup:
 
My Scrambler a 304 and 3 speed transmission that came from a 71 cj5. The previous owner swapped out the original 4 cyl and auto trans. The previous owner also added an aftermarket cam, edelbrock intake and 4 bbl carb to the 304. I have added hedman headers and a powerflow exhaust system. I don't know what the horsepower is, but it has plenty of power. I had a new 1977 cj7 with the same engine and transmission back in the day, and this engine is much more powerful.
 
I gotta side with cbford- unless it has a big problem work with what you have. Yes the stock 304 does not have much more power ut the mods mentioned and kick it up quite a bit. As usuall, it is all about the money. :evil:
My buddy & I just bought & picked up Saturday an 81 with a 304 & got it running yesterday. It already has dual exhaust and a modded distributor (breakerless module). It ran smooth once we got the gas to the carb (feeding from a jug not the old garbage gas in the tank). It needs an accellerator pump but that is an easy remedy. Good luck & post some pics! :drool:
 
I'd say keep the 304. Give it tune-up, rebuild the carb and see how it does. It may be fine.
 
Okay made up my mind im keepin the 304.. new intake and carb and distributor were in the plans already.. The holley 2bbl on it presently is junk.. Not sure if i should sent it off to be rebuilt or just try the new intake and carb and see what that does for it.. Ill be getting pics on here soon as i can.. Thanks men i'm gonna need lots of advice as I start this rebuild because i dont know much about it! hope i can do it:fingerscrossed:
 
and to answer your question cbford no it didnt pop and then miss it just consistantly missed on one cylinder from the sound of it.. Im not much of a mechanic so i guess it could be a simple fix and i definitely hope so..
 
Throw new plugs and wires into it too. Have you run a compression test? That's your quickest way to tell the viability of what you've got there. If you've got good compression, I'd do the upgrades mentioned and keep the 304. It's a good solid V8 that is fairly light weight.

I also echo the motorcraft carb sentiment. That's a nice carb and puts out a lot of power, and are cheap to pick up and rebuilt.
 
Back
Top