• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Tranny Options?

sggpenderco

Legacy Registered User
City
Rocky Point
State
NC
So I've got my Scrambler back on the road and finally enjoying the fruits of my labor......but after regearing to 4:10s, I'm not sure that the SR4 tranny is going to be the best option. I don't plan to do any serious off-roading so it will mostly see highway miles with some "mild" off-roading when I go camping. Are there any suggestions/better options on transmission alternatives? The SR4 is currently mated with a Dana 300 and it sits behind a straight 6. I don't want to break the bank on anything but is there anything out there that will give me better highway performance while minimizing the amount of components I'll have to change out. Any input would be greatly appreciated.
 
A T5, while not the strongest transmission, should work well for you:thumbsup:

It will bolt in, but it will still require new drive shafts, maybe a different bell housing, and depending on how "bolt in" you want it, maybe a new floor plate, transfercase shifter, and reverse light harness. I had to change all of the above when going from a T176 to a T5, I am not familiar at all with the SR4 transmission:shrug:

It will be the simplest/bolt in swap:thumbsup:

AX15/NV3500 require much more work/adaptation, but they are also a bit stronger:twocents:
 
t5 weakest but bolt in

ax15 good but need to convert to hydraulic clutch and clock the transfercase with a ring since the output shaft sticks out about 1/2"

nv3550 best but need to convert to hydraulic clutch and re-drill the transfercase mount....don't use a clocking ring as the outpushaft is not long enough

t176 very strong bolt it but NO overdrive for hwy
 
Based on what you're looking for, my suggestion is the T5 is the easiest swap - you can find them fairly readily on Craigslist (at least out here in Jeep country) for pretty cheap - I bought one with 15K miles for $250, new clutch for $150, transmission jack for $100, and swapped it in over the course of a weekend. Well, that's not entirely true, I had to do it a couple of times as my clutch plate was misaligned, but it was easy enough.

My driving style is very similar to yours. I'm geared a little lower, so don't see 5th gear as much as you would with the 4.10s. What size tires are you running?
 
jeep rebuild 81 scrambler 016.jpgjeep rebuild 81 scrambler 017.jpgjeep rebuild 81 scrambler 018.jpgHi these photos are of my sbc motor hooked to your sr-4 and dana 300 tc
my jeep a 1981 scrambler had the 4-cy iron duke motor and about 10 years ago did this motor swap,,, i do like you no rock climbing or rough off roading by do use on trails and pull
behind my motor home and take to state parks and use when we go camping to get around and have fun with.... the sr-4 if not beat on is not that bad,,,, when i did this swap i had
to change the clutch to a 10 1/2 in and i only have 3.55 gears and just 32x10.5 tires but have had no problems with it...... now with that being said i have purchased a 5 speed t-5 and
plan on putting it in sometime down the road ,,,, i just want the extra gear over drive for hiway ... i have checked into this and it is a direct swap,,, should not have to change drive
shaft or anything else hope this helps you
d
 
^^ B-b-but everything I've read says the SR4 will be destroyed behind a V8!! ^^ ;)
 
I've owned a number of T5 equipped Jeeps and knock on wood never had a failure--good transmissions. I think the knock against them is coming primarily from hard core off roaders who beat the snot out of them. I vote T-5.....
 
An AX15 doesn't require much more work, is significantly stronger (than a T5) and is very easy to drive...

What about drive shafts, shifters, floor plate, floor board mods, transmission mount stuff?

I have been thinking of swapping to either a NV3500 or AX15, but it is all the "minor issues" that add up, bolting the transmission to the bellhousing/transfercase is the easy part:twocents::shrug:
 
I've owned a number of T5 equipped Jeeps and knock on wood never had a failure--good transmissions. I think the knock against them is coming primarily from hard core off roaders who beat the snot out of them. I vote T-5.....

My stock green '83 Scrambler (30's/3.31's/all stock) has the factory T5, 120,000+ miles, it is still good:fingerscrossed::thumbsup:

My red '83 Scrambler (33's/4.10's/MPI/4:1 Dana 300/Ox lockers front and rear) is on its third T5 in less then 15,000 miles:eek::crazy:

I don't really "abuse" it, but I do "drive" it. The first one made it to Moab, wheeled a week there, made it back home, went to Michigan, started making noise on the way home. The machined surface that the cluster gear front bearing rides on chipped off, made noise. The second T5 blew up on the way to Louisiana, after surviving a trip to Missouri and back. Input shaft/front cluster gear completely exploded. I am on my third T5 now. It made it to Kentucky and back, but I now keep my complete "T176 swap kit" with me:shrug::rotfl:

In my limited experience, a T5 with a stock Jeep, driven reasonably with no more then a stock 6 cylinder, will hold up. I thought a T5 would last with my slightly built/moderately driven red Scrambler, but so far, they are not holding up:confused::shrug:
 
I'm running 33's for now but would love to maybe move up to 35s when these run out. Thanks for all the input so far.
 
Well may be i just have a good strong one but mine has been in their since i put the chevy in with no problems,,, here are the photos of it now,,, just finsihed putting in the amc 20
build up to a full floater disk with warn hub locks on the rear,,, another item that everyone overlooks as being weak when it is really just as strong as a dana 44 maybe stronger ,being
the ring and pinion are larger,,, just needed to be teaked at little,,, my motor puts out 300 hp and can smoke the tire in 1st and get rubber in the other 3.... yes i have gotten on it a few
times but on reg driving i do not ..... take a look 100_5880.JPG100_5887.JPG100_5890.JPG
 
If I went with a T5, I could basically just do a direct swap with the SR4 if I'm reading everything correctly? Everything just bolts right up with no special mods?
 
direct swap....even the same length....probably your best bet.
 
I've lost two T-5s, one behind a 304, one behind a SBC 350. The one behind the 304 had a history that I was unfamiliar with, but a 304 in stock trim doesn't produce much more power than a 258. It barely saw any offroad (all very mild) driving, and it failed on me in a parking lot.

The second came in the '85 CJ-7 that my father bought new. I knew its complete history, with servicing. It saw a little more offroading in its life, but the 350 I put in front of it was a mild engine, and I was careful with it. It also died on me on the street, while driving through a round-about.

The first T-5 I replaced with a wide-ratio T-18 from a Ford. I do miss fifth gear, but not enough to bother with upgrading to an NV4500.

The second T-5 I replaced with a World Class T-5. I got lucky and found this one on eBay being sold by the purchaser of a former transmission shop, already rebuilt (and apparently shelved for several years) with a Dana 300 adapter on the back.
 
I had a SM 465 in my Scrambler with 4.10 gears, 35" (really 34") tires, dana 300 and a 304. I could cruise at 70 MPH pretty easily. The PO had swapped in the drive train, so I don't know how hard it was to do. I do know that there was a novak adapter in there.
 
I'm going to stay with the t5 at first , but have a t176 and and freshly rebuilt sm420 (7:1 first and 3.6:1 second gear)

Also have two spare t5's
 
I twisted the tailshaft off of a T176 with a mild 350SBC. I'd advice to do it once, do it right. My research for an easy shifting (non HD truck) 5 speed came up with the NV3550 as the best choice.
 
I twisted the tailshaft off of a T176 with a mild 350SBC. I'd advice to do it once, do it right. My research for an easy shifting (non HD truck) 5 speed came up with the NV3550 as the best choice.

I did the same thing in my cj7,
304,2.73 gears , 33's
 
What about drive shafts, shifters, floor plate, floor board mods, transmission mount stuff?

I have been thinking of swapping to either a NV3500 or AX15, but it is all the "minor issues" that add up, bolting the transmission to the bellhousing/transfercase is the easy part:twocents::shrug:

There are no floor plate or floor board mods to get an AX15 in, because the shifter is in the same hole. This is a stock t5 plate without any mods (a SR4's plate should be the same), an AX15, and a twin stick 300:



If you use the AX15, you want 96 and newer for the external slave cylinder. I would guesstimate a AX15 swap is going to cost you $300-$400 more (adapter, driveshafts, etc.) compared to the t5.
 
Back
Top