• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Diesel vs Gas? What's your opinion?

rstickley

SOA Member
Gold Member
SOA Member
City
Branch
State
La
I am starting a small business where I will be pulling a trailer weighting around 4,000 lbs plus up to 2000 lbs in the bed. I am having trouble deciding between a duramax or a 6.0lt gas. I will be on a very tight budget and the cost of maintenance and repairs on the diesel are a lot more but the gas would get less fuel mileage. What is your opinion?
 
Diesel would be my choice.

A recent study by a MI automotive institute indicated that many/most/almost-all diesel vehicles offer a lower total cost of ownership than its gasoline counterpart in as little as 3 years and generally about 5 years. If I remember the article correctly, only one of the ten diesels studied did not achieve these TCO results within at least 5 years and it was due to an engine reliability issue that became widely known and negatively impacted the resale value of the vehicle. Thus, buying a diesel powered vehicle would be a wiser choice than its gasoline sibling, based upon that study.

If your business will require driving the vehicle many more miles than what is considered average per year for vehicle ownership (15K?), a diesel powered vehicle will provide a much greater long-term value resulting in easier trade-in or private-sale with high mileage than that of a gasoline powered vehicle.

General maintenance costs are a more expessive obligation with diesel engines, simply due to the much greater volume of motor oil and the commonality of replacing it every 5K miles. Also, air and fuel filter changes generally occur at 30K and 10-15K in a diesel to keep it running efficiently, although I'm not sure how these costs compare to maintenance on modern gasoline engines. Another potentially costlier issue with truck offerings is due to the diesel availability found only in the heavier segment. Thus, heavier vehicles require more frequent tire purchases. However, your payload and towing requirements could be met with a lighter 1/2-ton truck, so this would be classified as a greater expense in your situation. The caveat to the last point is the upcoming availability of the new Ram 1500 Ecodiesel and the Nissan Cummins, which are lighter 1/2-ton diesel-powered trucks.

Overall, it is my opinion that a diesel engine work truck is the best choice for durability, efficiency and reliability. If I were starting a new business with a limited budget, I might opt for a used diesel truck. Good used diesel trucks are readily available, and high mileage isn't such a concern in a diesel like that of a gasser.
 
Thanks for a very informative response. I am looking a used trucks and I am leaning toward the diesel.
 
Deisel all the way. If you go used do your homework on the common issues of what you are getting and buy one that had all those issues already fixed. We did that when we bought my wife a 6.0 Excursion. Receipts and records are King.
 
Very hard to find diesel excursions anymore.. there all being used and rebuilt. Diesel for use and resale my vote..

Sent from my SPH-L900
 
Deisel all the way. If you go used do your homework on the common issues of what you are getting and buy one that had all those issues already fixed. We did that when we bought my wife a 6.0 Excursion. Receipts and records are King.

Coincidently, I believe it was that 6.0L Navistar diesel found in '03-'06(?) Ford F250 trucks that didn't meet the TCO data like the other diesels tested. Amazingly, a Mercedes Benz MB(?) diesel SUV had a total cost of ownership in 3 or 5 years that was something like $12-15K less than the gasoline version; this model was the highest TCO difference on the comparative list.

I also recently read a 2012 publication that listed the ten best used diesel vehicles. The following years and models were included, but not in any particular order. The article also seemed to place some weight on how much power could be "turned-up" in each truck engine, but mostly it was in regards to oil flow, cast iron components, etc. for durability performance.

Chevy/GMC: '06-'07 Duramax

Dodge: '91 1/2-'93, '96-'98 and '03-'04 1/2 Cummins

Ford: '99 1/2-'00 7.3L and '08-'10 6.4L Navistar

The 1996-98 Cummins was mentioned as likely being the most reliable diesel engine in history. Lastly and as a side note, the 2005-06 Jeep Liberty CRD made the list for fuel efficiency in an SUV, although it didn't really have much competition in the USA.
 
When I got my 05 8.1 Chevy the duramax was 10k more. It has 79k miles on it now. If I sold it now would a comparable diesel sell for 10k more? Still not convinced diesel is better. In 09 I picked up a salvage title 06 4x4 Tundra with 50k miles on it. I have 99k miles on it now. So for the price of a diesel I have a dd and a tow rig that sits in the garage until I need it. Nothing but regular maintenance on both rigs. And the diesel pumps are nasty.:rotfl:
 
When I got my 05 8.1 Chevy the duramax was 10k more.

Wow, a $10K premium for the Duramax upgrade alone! Are you certain that premium didn't also account for some additional amenities/luxuries like 4x4, leather, navigation, power options, etc.? The most recent diesel I've purchased was less than a $4,000 upgrade over the gasser, so the $10K upgrade noted in the quote above seems surprising. Let's do a little research to try and dispel the "diesel myth".

According to KBB's OEM documentation, the diesel option upgrade in 2005 was $5,310.00. This premium was the extra cost as compared to the 6.0L gasser. The 8.1L gasser premium over the 6.0L was $950.00. Thus, the premium of the Duramax diesel option, as compared to the 8.1L gasser option in model year 2005, was $4,360.00 ($5,310 - 950 = $4,360).

Currently, KBB used vehicle guide data indicates the private sale value of a Duramax with 75K miles (15K x 5years = 75K) at a little over $25,000.00. The KKB value for the 8.1L, with all other specs unchanged, is a little over $20,000.00. Therefore, the Total Cost of Ownership study that indicates diesel-optioned vehicles offer a lower TCO appears to hold true with this Chevy comparison, as the diesel option was a $4,360.00 premium and now holds a $5,000.00 greater resale value. Of course, this simple scenario doesn't also calculate other factors that may or may not enhance the myth that diesel-optioned vehicles offer a lower total cost of ownership in as little as 3-to-5 years than its gasoline counterparts.

Link: http://www.cars.com/chevrolet/silverado-2500/2005/standard-equipment/

One caveat to the TCO study may be found in the cost upgrade of modern diesel vehicles, since new government emission standards for diesel vehicles currently requires very expensive exhaust system components. However, even the 2013 Chevy Silverado diesel option remains only a $7,195.00 upgrade, while Ram diesel is $7,795.00 and the Ford diesel upgrade is $8,095.00 -the Ford diesel premium has more than doubled since my last purchase.
 
...I got my 05 8.1 Chevy the duramax... ...In 09 I picked up a salvage title 06 4x4 Tundra with 50k miles on it. ...I have a dd and a tow rig that sits in the garage until I need it.

My position on this point is that I only need one diesel vehicle to serve as both a DD and a tow rig. The best way to view this, based upon your example, is to consider the two gassers you operate. One achieves a combined fuel economy of 10mpg (at best), while the DD achieves an average of 16mpg. Based upon the actual market value of the Silverado diesel model in 2005, had you paid the approximate $5K price premium, you'd currently have both a DD and a tow rig in one package that achieves an average 15-16mpg.

As a couple additional bonuses to further convince you, there'd be an extra $5,000.00 in your pocket (the $10K spent on the DD, minus the $5K diesel premium) and more free space in your garage. There would also be cost savings found in lower vehicle registration taxes, insurance, etc., by owning one vehicle to perform both tasks. You currently own two trucks that serve two purposes when a single truck is available that serves both purposes just as, if not more, efficiently.

So, sell those gassers and go buy the diesel truck. Then use those TCO savings to buy some gloves for the fuel pump, and an efficient DD like a diesel car that achieves 35mpg combined fuel economy.
:)
 
My position on this point is that I only need one diesel vehicle to serve as both a DD and a tow rig. The best way to view this, based upon your example, is to consider the two gassers you operate. One achieves a combined fuel economy of 10mpg (at best), while the DD achieves an average of 16mpg. Based upon the actual market value of the Silverado diesel model in 2005, had you paid the approximate $5K price premium, you'd currently have both a DD and a tow rig in one package that achieves an average 15-16mpg.

As a couple additional bonuses to further convince you, there'd be an extra $5,000.00 in your pocket (the $10K spent on the DD, minus the $5K diesel premium) and more free space in your garage. There would also be cost savings found in lower vehicle registration taxes, insurance, etc., by owning one vehicle to perform both tasks. You currently own two trucks that serve two purposes when a single truck is available that serves both purposes just as, if not more, efficiently.

So, sell those gassers and go buy the diesel truck. Then use those TCO savings to buy some gloves for the fuel pump, and an efficient DD like a diesel car that achieves 35mpg combined fuel economy.
:)

Huh. ?


Sent from my iPhone
 
Well I guess my 2001 Dodge gasser that I was trading in was worth less on a diesel trade. Every thing fits in the garage with an empty spot where the 8 used to sit.:confused: I am pretty sure the tool boxes will not fit on a 35 mpg diesel.(Does it have an 8 foot bed?) I am thinking of getting rid of both trucks and the twenty foot steel flat bed. If I get a smaller aluminum trailer a new Tundra will haul my LJ just fine. And then I would have 2 empty garage spaces to fill.:D Back on topic, for the op's4 to 6k loads either will work. Long distance over hill and dale get the diesel, local short haul or if not hauling all the time gas all the way.
 
If I get a smaller aluminum trailer a new Tundra will haul my LJ just fine. And then I would have 2 empty garage spaces to fill.:D

Would you still purchase that new Tundra to pull an aluminum trailer, if you could spend a little more and buy a new Ram Ecodiesel instead of the gasser Tundra (or how about the Nissan Cummins)? Just the fuel economy difference alone, with an approximate 40% increase in fuel efficiency, should easily sell the Ram Ecodiesel over gasser half-ton trucks.

Why is diesel desirable to some folks for long haul, but not short haul? Diesel achieves better fuel economy in both city and highway driving. Diesel pulls weight with less effort than a gasser in both long-n-steady driving and stop-n-go traffic. Diesel is a more efficient time-saver through requiring fewer stops at the fuel station. Are the negative aspects of smelly raw fuel and oily pump handles that much of a turn-off?
 
Just the fuel economy difference alone, with an approximate 40% increase in fuel efficiency, should easily sell the Ram Ecodiesel over gasser half-ton trucks.

Too bad the higher cost of diesel fuel negates that increase in fuel efficiency.
 
Myth: Higher diesel fuel prices negate greater fuel efficiency

Too bad the higher cost of diesel fuel negates that increase in fuel efficiency.

I've witnessed diesel fuel priced less than regular unleaded gasoline as early as last summer. The average price difference between highway-use diesel and regular gasoline, over an historical timeline, is recorded at approximately $0.13.

(Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration)

Time frame / Avg price reg. gas / Avg price diesel

1995-1999 / $1.135 / $1.141

2000-2009 / $2.0899 / $2.1792

2010-2012 / $3.307 / $3.60

18 year avg.(rounded) / $2.18 / $2.31

Avg. price difference: / <$0.13> / $0.13

Currently, I see the average price difference in Annapolis, MD is $0.40 per gallon, which is less than a 12% price difference. The U.S. average is similar at $0.39 per gallon. So, how does a 40% increase in fuel efficiency become negated by a 12% higher fuel price?


There are many excuses and myths used to define a reason for not using a more efficient fuel like diesel, but I have yet to read a compelling argument.
 
I ran into this problem a year ago. I had a 3500 gmc gas 1 ton 6.0l 4x4 with 4.10 gears (36 gallon tank). the truck was great. but I needed more cab room. My 2005 Mpg mixed driving/ terrian got 12-16 in the city and 14-18 freeway unloaded. it pulled pretty much anything I could hook behind it without any problems. But when I decided to go with a crew cab truck (gmc 2005-2007 classic body style) the gas 6.0l got at best 8-12 in the city and 10-14 freeway mpg. I have three friends with this set up (crewcab, gas, short bed). The one has his motor all tricked out: tuner, air intake, exhaust... and at best on the freeway he was getting 14 mpg. So I started looking into the diesels. and the numbers are all over. Every forum I was reading shows the Duramax getting these amazing numbers. So I bought a LBZ duramax in a 2007 gmc 2500hd 4x4. And I love it! The lbz is the model you want: its a nonemissions motor, no computer problems, no wiring harnress problems, no injector problems, no pump problems, no over heating problems (all found in ealier model duramax motors).

The diesel fuel is more, oil changes are more, and you have to replace a fuel filter here and there. My current truck gets 14-18 in the city, 16-22 on the freeway. I'm running a 3" lift and 285/75/18 tires. Trucks aren't ment to get good MPG. Atleast the ones that are ment to do actual work and hold up... Personally I wish I would have bought my diesel from the get go.

Ps. stay away from ford diesels unless you buy one that has a 7.3. and stay away from dodge trucks and or chrysler auto transmission; I have nothing negative to say about any intercooled turbo diesel cummins. Stay away from emission motors (delete kits are expensive).

7jeeps7kings
 
Ram ecodi or nissan cummins? I will never buy first year production again, just too many chances of problems. And, well, one of them is a Ram.:(
 
My wife is in love with the Beetle. We drive the 2.0 Turbo and the TDI. She preferred the TDI as it has a much smoother power delivery. I was surprised that she noticed that much of a difference that quickly. Going to start doing pricing to see what I can get out the door as a comparison.
 
...when I decided to go with a crew cab truck (gmc 2005-2007 classic body style), the gas 6.0L got at best 8-12 in the city and 10-14 freeway mpg.
...So I bought a LBZ duramax in a 2007 gmc 2500hd 4x4. And I love it! ...truck gets 14-18 in the city, 16-22 on the freeway.
...Trucks aren't meant to get good MPG.

This was an excellent post, and it included a nifty comment regarding all trucks achieving poor fuel economy -in relation to automobiles. However, when one considers the fuel economy numbers used in the post above, it is simple to state that full size gas trucks get poor fuel economy while diesel trucks get excellent fuel economy -when compared to its market segment.

Using the fuel economy numbers in the above quote, a diesel engine can achieve 50-75% greater fuel economy in the city and approximately 60% greater efficiency in highway driving. The percentage increases in fuel economy for diesel engines in trucks -that generally achieve poor fuel economy- is exceptionally higher than the difference between gasser and diesel automobiles; diesel cars probably average 25-30% more efficiency than the gasser counterparts. Thus, it is my opinion that diesel engines in trucks should be a "given"...and I can't believe the federal government hasn't yet banned inefficient gassers in the heavier class of vehicles! :)

Another interesting comment was made regarding computers and related emissions controls found on more modern diesels. Personally, I think the EPA/U.S. Government regulations will eventually make diesel products either too expensive compared to gassers, or too restricted of its full potential as an extremely economical and efficient form of transportation.
 
Back
Top