Wow! I'm impressed. I don't know what gears I have and I don't know what Weber either. I can say it's a fat thing that can't use the stock air cleaner. I haven't torn into the guts yet....but will shortly. I just got this jeep on Thanksgiving. I just did the back road from Lake Pleasent to Crown King then up to Prescott on the Senator Hwy and then into Flag last weekend. Mine spitted and sputtered the whole way up and most the way down. I've only put about 3 to 5000 miles on the jeep since I bought it and haven't gone over 11mpg yet. I'd love to hear your fix, because I want to stay as stock on the engine as I can. I'm sure Grantshire would too.
Any carb will need to be jetted and tuned. You just need to decide where the majority of your wheeling is going to take place....and set it up accordingly. First and foremost pick up a Weber jet kit (usually under 45 bucks from all the majors..summit etc). Well actually first decide which carb you have!!! The 32/36 will have an obvious difference inthe size of the hole in each carb bore. The 38/38 has identical bore size.
If I can jet a 38/38 to run right up here in flag...you should have no problems in the valley! Also the Weber tuning manual ( amazon etc) is a must. Wayyyyyy too much info for me to convey on tuning. Usually can be had for 10 bucks used.
I personally have found that the 4.2 has a serious compromise. If you run a 31" or smaller, you can get good milage because the they are alot lighter than any 33 inch tire.. With 33"s...it really cant be done, The engine dosent have enough rotational inertia (power/torque) to maintain a tire that heavy at a good speed( ie 2300-2700 RPM) I was running 4.10's with 33" TSL's. I could not get above 10 MPG...and 5th was useless...4th was too.... unless the road was deal level. On the other hand my CJ7 had a 360, 727 auto and 4.10's.....I got about 12-15on the highway...not bad for a v-8 and no overdrive!. The 360 has a higher rotational inertia and more torque!
Just my $.02...but as a daily driver...a 31 should be good enough to get you where you need to go....affordablely. Put a little more money into skidplates/lockers/winch (which you can do over time...unlike when you spin an axle in your M20 and have to pay to have it replaced...then 2 months later you have to pay again to have your new gears installed!)and you wont have to upgrade axels/brakes etc with a 31...with 33's and rock crawling...its a ticking time bomb...and have a more bulletproof rig.
Keep an eye out for a 4cyl CJ being parted out....should be atleast 3.54 gears....maybe even 4.10's. you can get a used axle set much cheaper that setting up new gears...and with a 31 inch...no further upgrade needed! Thats over 1000 saved that you can spend on other toys!!
The stock brakes are basicly worthless with a 33 also. I have installed disk brake kits on all of my CJ's since the late 90's. TSM makes a nice kit. And with the 31's....I can out brake my Grand Cherokee which has ABS! With 33's...it is close to the braking performance of a stock CJ with 235/75/15's.
OK I am off my soap box now.
As far as the head...havent done one yet....seriously considering it though!
I am just trying to steer you away from all the pitfalls I have experienced in 20+ years of playing with CJ's!!