• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Diesel vs Gas? What's your opinion?

I recently compared the Grand Cherokee diesel with a friend and came up with the following numbers. Now there is a comparison with the Pentastar V6 included but the comparison between the Diesel and the Hemi is more in line with what a typical full size truck comparison would look like.

**Note: cost figures do not account for maintenance items, strictly fuel economy and purchase cost**

GC Overland 3.0 V6 Gas: $49,185
GC Overland 4x4 Hemi: $52,380 (+3,195)
GC Overland 4x4 Ecodiesel: $53,685 (+1,305 / +4,500)
Fuel economy 3.0L V6 Gas: 17/24
Fuel economy Hemi Gas: 14/20
Fuel economy Diesel: 21/28
NJ Avg Fuel Costs(Jeep Website): 3.46 Gas / 3.94 Diesel

Driving 15,300 miles per year all highway they will cost you _____ in fuel:

V6: $2,205
Hemi: $2,646 (+$441 over V6)
Diesel: $2,152 (-$494 below Hemi/ -$53 below V6)

Compare the price differential from Diesel to the V6 and it would take 85 years to make up the $4500 price difference.
Compare the price differential from Diesel to the Hemi and it would take 2.6 years to make up the $1305 price difference!!

So in summary, if capability is not a concern and fuel economy is then the V6 Gas is the way to go.
If capability is a concern then go with the Diesel over the Hemi immediately!
 
Also not everyone sells diesel fuel. . So you might have to drive more to find it.. I went yesterday to buy some and had to drive 10 more miles to get a gas station that had it and passed 3 up that didnt.. 60 cents a gallon difference from gas to diesel. .
I remember when I was younger diesel was cheeper then gas.. what happen...
Sent from my SPH-L900
 
Although I had thought I had my mind made up on a diesel, yesterday I found a well maintained 05 with the 6.0lt. It drove great and it was exactly what I would need. But the owner told me that it got 11 mpg without pulling anything, I started thinking again. Being that I will be towing a trailer all the time for the business, I think it is a no brainier to stick with diesel. Not to mention the excellent information that I have read hear. I love this site!
 
My buddy has a 4x4 suburban with a 6.0, He just got it over the summer, We have been going to La duck hunting in my 03 power stroke for the last 4 years, We know how many miles it is to the tee and we know which fuel stops we are going to make, Well he said lets take mine this year because gas is cheaper it wont cost as much.

That darn suburban was SUCKING the gas down to the tune of 9mpg most of the way, We had to alter our fuel stops because we never made it to any of them. Doing the math on that last trip it was clear diesel was the better choice, Not to mention half way there the check trans light came on and we lost an hour trying to figure out what was wrong with it.

Diesel all the way, My jeep is diesel, My truck is diesel, My lawn mower is diesel, my tractor is diesel, I even built a Yamaha golfcart with a diesel motor.
 
Back
Top