• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Eggy's got a leak! But what is it?

atldinan3

Basic User
City
Athens
State
GA
Ok so I'll start by saying that I'm not very technically. I "understand stuff", but can't turn a wrench enough to change a light bulb. Thus, I need your input...

I think Eggy's got herself a leak. Ok, there is definitely a leak, per the garage spots over the last few weeks. I think it may be coming from the transmission. Or maybe where the transmission meets the engine (whatever that gap is called...

It seems to increase when its driven, so I've let her sit for three days, and went underneath and rubbed the area clean on days 1 and 2. Today is day three and here is what I found (see pics). Thoughts?

If that IS the leak, then my next questions will be along the lines of "how big a deal is this?" and "what should I expect in time and cost to repair?".

I'm surprised and disappointed because she got a new clutch about 18mos/10k miles ago. Hasnt leaked since. Until I brought her home from the shop that did the 4.0 head swap. I assume its unrelated...
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1228.jpg
    IMG_1228.jpg
    116.5 KB · Views: 110
  • IMG_1229.jpg
    IMG_1229.jpg
    148.1 KB · Views: 111
First try to figure out if its gear oil or motor oil. Gear oil has acrid smell and motor oil has a gassy smell usually.

If its gear oil, might be the front seal on the tranny.

If it is motor oil, first check the simplest thing (given a head swap) might be as simple as the valve cover is not tightened down enough, especially in back. Look for oil coming down from around the valve cover.

Next, look around where the head meets the block.

If everything is clean up there it could be the rear main seal.

Good luck

HWB3


Sent from my iPad
 
Seems to be a gassy smell.

I drove her a bit today and then came back to the garage and let her sit and cool down. I just went out and snapped the following pics. (looking up, engine in black on top/right, silver trans on bottom/left). I highlighted in red where it appears to me that the leak is originating. What does this mean to ya'll?

IMG_1a.jpgIMG_2a.jpg
 
I was hoping for you that it was the simple valve cover gasket. NOT. Rear main seal!




Sent from my iPad
 
Ok so I understand what the Rear Main Seal is (more or less), but what does this effectively mean for me? Do I really have to have the entire engine & trans removed to change it? Is that as complex and expensive as it sounds? (I assume my local 2bays-in-the-chevron mechanic cant do it...?) Other options? Can I just ignore it and add oil regularly?
 
From the pics you may want to do this sooner than later. I have not done a main seal in 20 years, so correct me if I'm wrong but, drop the tranny, pull the oil pan, drop the crank, replace the seal, replace the rod bearings, put it all back together.

I guess it depends on how much you drive it and if you can live with the leak. Check the oil frequently. It will only get worse.

How old is the motor?


Sent from my iPad
 
Just getting back on the board after an extended vacation, but did you ever get this problem tackled?

You do not have to remove the transmission to replace the RMS. The only things you have to remove are the passenger side engine mount and the oil pan. Total cost of this project: about $50-75, more if you need a tool set and other ancillaries. Total time: about a weekend, working slowly and taking lots of breaks. There is a good write-up for this project on line, it was the first mechanical thing I did when I got my CJ, the only thing I had ever done before was rebuild a carburetor. It's a fairly easy project for a beginner when you follow the directions: http://www.neow.net/rms1.html

If you're an able-bodied person with the right tools, you can definitely tackle this on your own!!
 
Tough job. Not a lot of $$$ involved, but lots of time, and it's FILTHY. In my case, I got in a hurry getting the top 1/2 the seal in, messed it up, and it leaked again AFTER I spent all those hours covered in oil and grit.

If it were me, and it wasn't leaking much, I'd let it drip. Mine leaked for years and I never even had to add oil between changes. It was just the Jeep marking its territory. If you're OCD and can't stand it leaking, go by the writeup, TAKE YOUR TIME, and replace it.

Just remember, on a Jeep if you fix a leak, another one starts somewhere else. :D
 
Thanks everyone for the feedback. The guys in my shop also say its "relatively easy, but a long and dirty job". Respectfully Walkerhounddvm, there is absolutely no way I would tackle this job - I can't imagine that being my first ever hands-on experience! Maybe I'll change her oil one day or something first... lol

So far the leak is minimal. I added a quart a few weeks ago and have taken her on a few weekend afternoon jaunts since then - it appears to be leaking like a stuck pig (a small bit actually comes up through the passenger side floorboard drain hole - looks like soda) - however the oil level hasn't budged from full. Once it eventually drops down a bit, I'm going to put some Lucas RMS additive in it. The shop guys said I could also use some heavier weight oil (currently 10w40).

Overall it looks like a "crisis averted" situation. Whew.

Attached is a pic of her in her summertime glory!

IMG_0874.jpg
 
Back
Top