I got this right out of my May 2011 Jeep magazine (but copied it off of the JP Mag web site). Might be usefull. Jeff
Hava Seat
Every year I see a comparison article on tires. Last year I read one on tire carriers. And there have been other comparison articles that I can't think of off the top of my head. However, I have never seen an article on seats for your heap.
I am looking at MasterCraft, Beard, PRP, Corbeau, and other manufactures, but I don't know what's the best for my back. What will hold me in the seat the best in order to give me the ability to drive by the seat of my pants? What dries off the quickest? What holds up to mud? What lets me easily get in and out of my lifted Jeep, etc.?
Additionally, why would I want a fixed over a reclining seat? Why do I want suspension over foam? Why do I want cloth over vinyl/cloth combo or waterproof neoprene, why, why, why?
So, any help that you can provide would be great, and if you could write an article, that would be grand.
Chip Justice
Lovejoy, CT
It may be a story we'd consider doing in the future, but for now I've had enough aftermarket seats and I think I can help you out.
MasterCraft-Just about the best out there. The color stays put, they're comfortable, provide good support, and have nice side bolsters without being too difficult on ingress/egress. They bolt to YJ/late CJ seat frames. Rubicons are a bit wider and slightly larger on the outside, while the Sports are slightly more snug and a little more compact. I have thousands of miles in Rubicons, and I've run the Sports in my Flattie for years. The reclining Baja RS buckets are also really good. I ran them in my TJ, but unless you do a lot of long trips where the passenger needs to lie back, I'd say the money isn't worth it and the regular Sports or Rubicons are more comfortable.
Beard-A very, very close second to MasterCraft and same quality as far as fading goes. Most models seem geared more towards off road performance, so they hug more snugly and have larger side-bolsters. The mounting tabs are vertical, not horizontal, so you'll need the adapters if you're mounting in a YJ or late CJ.
Corbeau-The old fabric faded really fast. The black ones I put in my M-715 already looked purple after a couple trips off-road and the material isn't as durable as the Beard or MasterCraft. The new replacement fabrics seem more resistant to fading, but the wear patterns still showed up more quickly than more expensive seats. They are more affordable, though, and really comfy and supportive-so if you have a top or go with the vinyl instead of fabric they can be a good choice. The mounting tabs are vertical like the Beards.
Smittybilt-I've had the Sport-style reclining buckets, not the suspension seats. They were firm but not uncomfortable at all. The side bolsters are sort of big, but you can still get in and out easily. They had good overall quality and I was pleasantly surprised considering the very attractive price. They have YJ/CJ-type mounts.
Bestop Trailmax-Very comfy and good material quality. I remember the Black Denim fabric fading to a light purple on the ones in my '95 YJ, so I'd say the vinyl ones would probably be better if you're putting them in an open-top Jeep. They fit well, the mechanisms worked nicely, and they were good for long hauls. They have YJ/CJ-style mounts.
Bestop Low Backs-Had these in our Project Hatari! CJ-6 as early CJ replacement seats. They were a big, big improvement over the original ones, but the top of the seat frame would dig into my back. The bottom cushion was nice, supportive, and comfortable. The material (full vinyl) did very well in the sun with no fading or staining. They have YJ/CJ-type mounts.
Corbeau Sport type seats-I had these (type like the Bestop Trail Max or Smittybilt Sports) in my '85 4Runner. They were horrible. The material was fine (full vinyl), but the seats were rock hard and uncomfortable as hell. They had CJ/YJ-style mounts.
PRP Daily-Driver-While I haven't actually owned a pair of these, a lot of my friends run them and I've spent a good deal of time sitting in them. The fabric wears well and has good resistance to fading over the long-haul. They're also very comfortable and offer good support. Like the MasterCraft Rubicon seats, the side bolsters are doable for a daily-driven vehicle and they seem to offer a bit more room when seated like a Rubicon-model seat. The price-point is an attractive feature.
Write Us!
Got a tech question you're just itching to get answered? Send it on in to Jp magazine, Your Jeep, 831 S. Douglas St., El Segundo, CA 90245, or e-mail
christian.hazel@jpmagazine.com.
Read more:
http://www.jpmagazine.com/techarticles/154_1105_may_2011_your_jeep/viewall.html#ixzz1dpFwIFiA