• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Tire's 15" or 17"

Grey Fox

SOA Member
Lifetime Member
City
Bountiful
State
UT
My project is progressing slowly with the 81 scrambler. Axles will be in shortly. Dana 60 in the rear, 44 up front with Eaton e-lockers on both. Making this primarily an off road-er. I'm starting to think about tires. Was planning all along to get 15" x 35's however the last tire shop I visited the salesman who was a 4 wheeler enthusiast said the new trend is 17" and I would be sorry if I bought 15". He did admit it is purely a cosmetic thing and that the 15" actually perform better on the trail. You guys and Konac are a great source of information so whats your thoughts? Kim
 
The first consideration is getting a size that will clear your brakes. Some 60 rears have brakes on them that will not fit in a 15" wheel. Talk to whoever built your axles about what will fit before you buy.
 
what john said..plus...17 inch will be better on the highway and mud...15's are better on the trails and rocks...17's are more expensive...its a personal choice
 
Ditto JohnN- get what clears the brakes, whether it's 15, 16, 16.5, or 17. I personally wouldn't go any larger than that, because more sidewall = more sidewall flex when aired down. Can't flex a rubber band! :D
Oh, as for the salesman who said you'd be 'sorry' if you got 15" rims- bear in mind he's a SALESman, a man looking to make a sale. 17" rims cost more (at least for now), so his cut is bigger- it makes sense that he'd want to steer you toward the more expensive setup! One thing to consider to rebut his statement- look in the ads and catalogs at how many brands, sizes, and tread patterns are available for 15" rims, then look to see how many are available for 17" rims. I'd go with the greater variety, personally.
 
John N said:
The first consideration is getting a size that will clear your brakes. Some 60 rears have brakes on them that will not fit in a 15" wheel. Talk to whoever built your axles about what will fit before you buy.
John is correct, to a point. The rest of you guys:rolleyes: Don't even consider a 16.5" wheel.
I think more info is needed to help with a recommendation. What kind of wheelin do you want to do? What bolt pattern are the axles? Do you want to go bigger in the future? Will the D44 be replaced with a 60? Things like this are important considerations when properly selecting a wheel/tire combo. If you plan accordingly now you may not have to swap out wheels if you go to larger axles and tires in the future. I didn't practice what I preach and ended up buying new wheels when I up sized my axles. If I had thought it out far enough I could have saved money by getting wheels which would work well past the initial set of tires. This assumes you would be staying with the same bolt pattern.

I run 17" rims on 40" IRoKs. I think they are the perfect combination of wheel size versus sidewall height. All these tires ever see is rock. 15s" are too short, IMHO, for the larger tires. I wheel with people on this board who run 44" tires on 15" rims. You should these fold over when aired down. Way too much sidewall.

Now, if you plan to stay with 5 on 5.5" and 35's then 15" wheels are fine. :p
That being said, wanna buy some NIB 15" beadlocks?
 
mike...i am gettin ready to buy 41's for my 8...i was gonna buy 16's...but if i read ur post right..u would recommend 18's....if so who sells cheap 18 inch wheels?
 
Good info Thanks Guys
This will be a Moab wheeler primarily. Moderate to hard stuff. Probably not the extreme or body damage stuff, not at first any way, but who knows?? I got into this sport last year when I was invited to go with a group of well rigged guys to Moab so I rented a Rubicon. 1 time and Hooked. This will be I'm sure a hobby of evolution. So your question about will I be upgrading is a good one, I'm already starting to think 37's might be a better choice. Bolt pattern is 5 on 5 1/2 and that can't change because I've got a set of Mattracks (Snow tracks) that I'm bolting up to this thing to get into our cabin in the winter. Ha Ha, You guys are now thinking I'm nuts. As far as upgrading the front to a D60, well I probably should have done that rather than a 44 but I guess I got a little tired of throwing money at this thing. So yes a D60 could be in the future.
Here's question #2 Should I be considering Bead locks?
 
Kaiser8 said:
15s" are too short, IMHO, for the larger tires. I wheel with people on this board who run 44" tires on 15" rims. You should these fold over when aired down. Way too much sidewall.

Yup, i ruined a 44 when it got too low. :mad:
 
scott anderson said:
mike...i am gettin ready to buy 41's for my 8...i was gonna buy 16's...but if i read ur post right..u would recommend 18's....if so who sells cheap 18 inch wheels?


so phil...would you recommend the 18's over the 16's ...?
 
scott anderson said:
so phil...would you recommend the 18's over the 16's ...?

I have no experience with anything but 15's but i would strongly consider something taller. I guess i'd have to go thru the process of asking the guys running them but i think Mike is on to something, (as much as we'd all hate to admit it), :D i've seen his rig up close.
 
dadscj8 said:
I have no experience with anything but 15's but i would strongly consider something taller. I guess i'd have to go thru the process of asking the guys running them but i think Mike is on to something, (as much as we'd all hate to admit it), :D i've seen his rig up close.


i prodded Mike for a response...but i aint seen it yet
 
scott anderson said:
mike...i am gettin ready to buy 41's for my 8...i was gonna buy 16's...but if i read ur post right..u would recommend 18's....if so who sells cheap 18 inch wheels?
Scott, which tires are you looking at? I think alot of your decision depends on what type/kind/brand of tire you want. I tend to look at this two ways. First, what size tire do I want to run, lets say we're talking about my tires, 39.5 IROKs. I knew I wanted IROKs because of cost, size and compound. Interco offers these in 15", 16", 16.5", 17", and 20" rim sizes. 15' is out, too small. 16.5 is out, crappy bead design, 20" don't need the bling and not alot available in tires for this size right now. So that left me with either 16" or 17". Now, the second way I look at this is this; I have narrowed it down to two size wheels. What is going to work for me long term. I knew when I got the 39.5s I would be beating on them pretty good. If I liked them enough I may want to step up to the 42s or even the 44's. Thats the beauty of one ton running gear = options.
I chose 17s because they fit my current tire size well and would work great with the larger size tires, and there are a ton of tires available for them. 17s are as popular today as 15s were back in the 80's. Also, look at the marketplace. Larger wheels are showing up on everything from the oems.
Does this make sense, I seem to be babbling today.:o
 
One more thing, when I was searching for my wheel options I got real interested in the H2 wheels because of their strength, size and price. i basically got them for free and then added the beadlocks. These are comparable to Walkers wheels but I saved a boatload of money by going the route i did.
upperhelldo-1.jpg
 
scott anderson said:
i am looking at 41 irok radials....i do so much street driving it will definately radials
I run bias ply and can't speak directly to the radials, but, with a lot of street driving IRoKs may not be the best choice. The compound is very soft in the bias, I suspect the radials to be a bit better, but from my experience I would be lucky to get 10K street miles out of my tires.
Why not someting like a 40" MTR?
 
dadscj8 said:
but i think Mike is on to something, (as much as we'd all hate to admit it)
Come on Phil, it only hurts the first time.:D :p
 
Kaiser8 said:
I run bias ply and can't speak directly to the radials, but, with a lot of street driving IRoKs may not be the best choice. The compound is very soft in the bias, I suspect the radials to be a bit better, but from my experience I would be lucky to get 10K street miles out of my tires.
Why not someting like a 40" MTR?

Mike...i have settled on the tires...they are sold in 16 17 18 and 20...of course the larger the wheels the higher the cost...just trying to minimize the cost of wheels...what do u think would be the best wheel for 41's?
 
Back
Top