• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Mpg

Alamo CJ8

Alamo CJ8
City
Atlanta
State
GA
OK, don't kill me here just hear me out.

I have a new position with my company that has moved me from working from my home to working in a office that is a 50 mile round trip every day. I am driving my 1985 Scrambler with 78K original miles daily. I love my Jeep and want to keep it. My problem, the Jeep gets around 9 mpg and it burns almost as much oil as gas. I have factory auto and air and want to keep both though not necessarily factory but the factory look. With me so far? What I need is a new motor and if necessary transmission that will significantly improve my gas milage. My goal is mid 20's and if necessary I am willing to even give up my 4wd capability to keep the Jeep. I hope that isn't necessary but again, I don't want to loose my Jeep but I want my house more.:) Thoughts, diesel, 4cyl, hy-bryd, electric? Go crazy, no idea is off the table...

Thanks for the help,

Tom
 
I put in a 5.7 liter vortec v8 with a 4l60e trans...I got 20mpg with 37 inch tires...with stockish tires i think you could get even better

Note...when i went to 42's mileage dropped into the crapper
 
Latest generation LS motor with an overdrive and keep the tires at 31 inches or less. That motor will have the multi cylinder displacement so it will drop out four cylinders on the highway. Do not lift it. I would bet you get 22mpg plus but heh swap cost will be 10k easily. I have been researching this allot lately. Not cheep.

On the cheep go with the old four banger and stock sized tires with the T5 tranny and 3.31 or high gears. That would get you low 20s on the highway and the parts and swap would be simple.
 
Go buy old beater accord/camry/civic/carolla. A friend of mine drives about 120 miles/day and he has a TJ and an F150. I told him to get an old beater and he got a 91 accord for $2K. He's not running all those miles up on his Jeep and truck, the cars almost already paid for itself. Cheaper than a drivetrain swap will be.
 
My powertrain is modeled after a another similar build. 5.3 Vortec with a stock tune, 4L60E overdrive trans, 4.56 gears and 35" tires. Supposedly getting mid 20s at 65mph, flat road, sea level.

A lot depends on your driving style...with the stock tires, 4 cyl 4 speed I couldn't get over 14 mpg. But, I keep up with the flow of traffic, ect. Someone who drives with an egg under their foot would doubtless do better.

Another thing to think about is the lack of aerodynamics our Scramblers have. It takes a lot of juice to overcome the wind resistance. A low power engine will be using a bulk of it's oomph just to keep the thing rolling. Any hills, extra load, passing, ect put the accelerator to the floor and there goes your mileage. I have always believed the best attainable mileage is achieved when there is an excess of efficient useable power, without huge displacement.

2 examples- Look at the new JK's. They have a supposedly fuel efficient engine, yet in the JK it manages 20 highway on a good day, driving like a little old lady. But put a small hemi in there, and reports of mid 20's with power to spare are common. Or, look at the new Ford Ecotec engines. A smaller displacement engine optimized for maximum torque and horsepower, getting phenomenal fuel economy. Both prime examples where more horsepower and torque equal better mileage. Of course, it has to be an efficient engine...
 
Last edited:
Do you guys think that I could swap in a 4.0 from a mid 2000's Jeep and get 20's? I have 31's on her now with a full soft top but would go back to stock size tires and a half top if it would help.

Tom
 
Go buy old beater accord/camry/civic/carolla. A friend of mine drives about 120 miles/day and he has a TJ and an F150. I told him to get an old beater and he got a 91 accord for $2K. He's not running all those miles up on his Jeep and truck, the cars almost already paid for itself. Cheaper than a drivetrain swap will be.

Seconded. Less miles on the jeep and better fuel economy for what will eventually be a lot less $$

What engine, tranny, carb do you have in there now? 9mpg is pretty cruddy - I get 15+ with 31" tires, T4 tranny, 258 I6, MC2150 and TR upgrade, don't lose a drop of oil, either.

Not trying to rub it in, but you can potentially do better with what you already have in there.
 
Go buy old beater accord/camry/civic/carolla. A friend of mine drives about 120 miles/day and he has a TJ and an F150. I told him to get an old beater and he got a 91 accord for $2K. He's not running all those miles up on his Jeep and truck, the cars almost already paid for itself. Cheaper than a drivetrain swap will be.

actually i third this idea...since becoming older...i would not relish 50 mile commute in a jeep ..mileage is much better in a car..and actually more comfortable ...u can hear the radio and be comfy
 
I get low 20's in my stock '83 Scrambler on the highway at 65mph (258, computer controlled carter carb, T5, 3.31 gears, 30" tires, 118,000+/- miles):shrug:

To me, my green Scrambler is almost as comfortable as my 05 TJ Rubicon, and it it rides smoother:thumbsup:
 
I just don't like the idea of running the Jeep to death everyday commuting in it.....save the Jeep, put all those miles on some soulless vehicle like a coralla
 
I have a 4.0L out of a 92 xj in mine... got 17mpg averaging 75mph with 35" tires (manual transmission though)

get a beater car.
 
Do you guys think that I could swap in a 4.0 from a mid 2000's Jeep and get 20's? I have 31's on her now with a full soft top but would go back to stock size tires and a half top if it would help.

Tom

Should be able too.

Getting a beater is probably the best advice, but I tried that and just can't do it. If I have to spend that much time in the seat of a vehicle, it better be one I love. And, then there's insurance on a second vehicle, and parking, and possibly repairs...
 
If I have to spend that much time in the seat of a vehicle, it better be one I love.

To me, that hits the nail on the head. I doubt if there are many Scrambler owners for whom the Scrambler is the absolute, most practical vehicle. I have one because it does something for me that goes beyond the practical. If I were stuck with a long commute, I would be doing everything in my power to make that commute bearable, and a beater Corrolla or Civic simply would not fit the bill. It might be the most practical, but I'd hate it.
 
Give that thing a checkup!!
Back when my 8 was new to me with the automatic, 2.73 gears, TF999, 31" tires, and A/C....I was getting about 17+.
 
Ok what i'm about to sugest might get me band from this cite.

What I have been looking at is 6.6 durmax. I think it will fit no biger than a big block chevy.
But it's going to weigh a lot more and a custom fuel cell will be spendy. I found a 2005 2wd chevy with a durmax for $5000. Just pull the motor and trans get a adaptor for the D300 new drive shafts. Dont know how the D30 up front would hold up.
 
Do you guys think that I could swap in a 4.0 from a mid 2000's Jeep and get 20's? I have 31's on her now with a full soft top but would go back to stock size tires and a half top if it would help.

Tom

I have a 4.0 from a '98 and a NV3550 from a '02. I have 31x10.50x15's. I was getting about 16 mpg's with the T176 that was in it and about 17 mpg's with the NV3550. I think my gearing is 3:54. I also think I might sqeak out an extra mpg with a tune up.

My CJ7 has a 4.0 from a '00 and a T4 transmission. It has 3:31 (?) gears, 32x11.50x15 tires. It gets about 15. It also got about 15 with the original T5.
 
If you are looking diesel, try the 4BT conversion route, From my research there's tons of torque and great mileage. Just not a speedster...
 
To me, that hits the nail on the head. I doubt if there are many Scrambler owners for whom the Scrambler is the absolute, most practical vehicle. I have one because it does something for me that goes beyond the practical. If I were stuck with a long commute, I would be doing everything in my power to make that commute bearable, and a beater Corrolla or Civic simply would not fit the bill. It might be the most practical, but I'd hate it.

I think you get me. I know I am going to be killing a rare and great Scrambler. To all of those our there who would love to have it I am sorry but I bought it so I could enjoy it and honestly there isn't another vehicle I would rather spend the hours a day in than this. I understand that I should be doing much better than I am but let's not forget that this motor is beat. I burn so much oil that when I change it I only change the last months oil as I have replaced a quart or more a week. I appreciate everyone's advice here and think I am going to try to find either a fuel injected 4.0 or possibly a new 4.2 and put injection on it. I will then take my current 4.2, teach my son how to rebuild it in the garage and save it on the off chance I ever decide to sell it I can swap it back and it will be back to 100% original. You guys are great as always, thanks!

Tom
 
I think you get me. I know I am going to be killing a rare and great Scrambler. To all of those our there who would love to have it I am sorry but I bought it so I could enjoy it and honestly there isn't another vehicle I would rather spend the hours a day in than this. I understand that I should be doing much better than I am but let's not forget that this motor is beat. I burn so much oil that when I change it I only change the last months oil as I have replaced a quart or more a week. I appreciate everyone's advice here and think I am going to try to find either a fuel injected 4.0 or possibly a new 4.2 and put injection on it. I will then take my current 4.2, teach my son how to rebuild it in the garage and save it on the off chance I ever decide to sell it I can swap it back and it will be back to 100% original. You guys are great as always, thanks!

Tom

Amen! Once mine is on the road, it's going to be my daily driver, my wheeler, and if I can convince the wife, the vacation vehicle too!
 
my 93 corolla still gets 40 mpg hwy and 30 city with 371,000 miles on it. yeah it's boring to drive, but all the money saved in gas milage can go towards the toys to make them better. 50 miles round trip every day in a vehicle that even gets just 23 mpg is goin to get expensive really fast! do yourself a favor and get that $500 corolla.
 
Back
Top