• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Insurance on your Scrambler

I have to pay $500+/year for full coverage...

Wow, at those prices, my 24 years of Scrambler driving with minimum coverage would have netted me about $12K per vehicle, not including interest. Technically, not always a second vehicle with $1 premiums, my number is certainly skewed.
 
Michigan can be expensive for insurance. The 81 only costs half as much for just liability.
 
I really think you should check out American Collectors Insurance. I have mine insured for a stated value of $15k and it's only a $280 annual premium for full coverage and towing. Probably not best for daily drivers as I have a 7,500 mile annual mileage cap but I only average about 1,000 miles a year. They were also really good about handling a recent claim I had for $8,500. Might be worth a call to them at least.
 
I really think you should check out American Collectors Insurance. I have mine insured for a stated value of $15k and it's only a $280 annual premium for full coverage and towing. Probably not best for daily drivers as I have a 7,500 mile annual mileage cap but I only average about 1,000 miles a year. They were also really good about handling a recent claim I had for $8,500. Might be worth a call to them at least.

Mose all of the collector insurance places say you must have 10 years driving before you can drive one and that wont work for me, becouse my son could not drive it then.
I just got insurance to put full coverage on it with it not listed as a antique. I would say if anything happes this is what they may use....
http://www.nadaguides.com/Classic-Cars/1983/Jeep-Corporation-AMC/CJ-Scrambler/Jeep-4X4/Values
 
Last edited:
I am an independent insurance agent. I've recently bought a Scrambler that's in very good condition so I've been working to find a good place to insure it. Hagerty specializes in this kind of insurance, but they're very particular in how it's used. I want to drive mine and therefore Hagerty wasn't the best option. You have to be very careful with what you're being told vs. how a claim will be handled. I've been a claims adjuster prior to being an agent and what agent's tell you vs. how things are handled are often very different. So just some heads up, just because you get a "stated value" policy does not mean you will get that amount if/when you have a claim. In fact, with most companies, the "stated value" is used to get the premium adjusted to the proper amount, but if/when you have a claim, "Actual Cash Value" will be used to pay you. ACV is simply the Replacement Cost of your vehicle minus depreciation. It's possible that some value will be given for condition, mileage, etc., but essentially it's no different than any other policy other than the company is getting more premium than they would otherwise becuase of the stated value. The company, which I'll end up going with is probably going to be SafeCo. From what I've been able to gather, their "classic vehicle" insurance in as close to a real "stated Value" as I can find - outside of a Hagerty or some specialty company like that.

If you want help, I am licensed in a bunch of states across the country and would be happy to dig around your state for some answers. Call my office if you want 801.763.5400 Ext. 101. My name is Darron.
 
I am an independent insurance agent. I've recently bought a Scrambler that's in very good condition so I've been working to find a good place to insure it. Hagerty specializes in this kind of insurance, but they're very particular in how it's used. I want to drive mine and therefore Hagerty wasn't the best option. You have to be very careful with what you're being told vs. how a claim will be handled. I've been a claims adjuster prior to being an agent and what agent's tell you vs. how things are handled are often very different. So just some heads up, just because you get a "stated value" policy does not mean you will get that amount if/when you have a claim. In fact, with most companies, the "stated value" is used to get the premium adjusted to the proper amount, but if/when you have a claim, "Actual Cash Value" will be used to pay you. ACV is simply the Replacement Cost of your vehicle minus depreciation. It's possible that some value will be given for condition, mileage, etc., but essentially it's no different than any other policy other than the company is getting more premium than they would otherwise becuase of the stated value. The company, which I'll end up going with is probably going to be SafeCo. From what I've been able to gather, their "classic vehicle" insurance in as close to a real "stated Value" as I can find - outside of a Hagerty or some specialty company like that.

If you want help, I am licensed in a bunch of states across the country and would be happy to dig around your state for some answers. Call my office if you want 801.763.5400 Ext. 101. My name is Darron.

I may take you up on this. I have a stated value policy for $30k, but apparently I should review the details of that a bit more with my agent (Farmers). He handles all of our vehicles as well as some other policies, but in retrospect I don't think we spent as much time discussing this one as we probably should have.
In CA.
 
Fortunately, American Collectors goes off of stated value. They were going to total my scrambler if the repair cost was 80% of my stated value. So, my repair was about $4k shy of it getting totaled. Those are Collins Bros prices and they did a great job.
 
I am an independent insurance agent. I've recently bought a Scrambler that's in very good condition so I've been working to find a good place to insure it. Hagerty specializes in this kind of insurance, but they're very particular in how it's used. I want to drive mine and therefore Hagerty wasn't the best option. You have to be very careful with what you're being told vs. how a claim will be handled. I've been a claims adjuster prior to being an agent and what agent's tell you vs. how things are handled are often very different. So just some heads up, just because you get a "stated value" policy does not mean you will get that amount if/when you have a claim. In fact, with most companies, the "stated value" is used to get the premium adjusted to the proper amount, but if/when you have a claim, "Actual Cash Value" will be used to pay you. ACV is simply the Replacement Cost of your vehicle minus depreciation. It's possible that some value will be given for condition, mileage, etc., but essentially it's no different than any other policy other than the company is getting more premium than they would otherwise becuase of the stated value.

This is fantastic explanation of one of my biggest concerns when it comes to insuring our Jeeps, from someone directly involved. Thank you for this! Too many folks accept what they hear/read about these stated/collector policies without getting into the details and can find themselves left out in the cold, having paid more thinking that they'll get the stated amount.

I also worry about neglecting/overlooking the limitations on offroad use/mileage/etc. that the insurance company doesn't bother confirming with you when you sign up because the burden is on you to buy the right policy, not them to sell it to you. Don't know if you have any first-hand experience with that type of issue you could also share?

Thanks for your informative post! :cheers:
 
Fortunately, American Collectors goes off of stated value. They were going to total my scrambler if the repair cost was 80% of my stated value. So, my repair was about $4k shy of it getting totaled. Those are Collins Bros prices and they did a great job.

Love your story of a company that did it right, assuming of course that any limitations/caveats work for the buyer (like the mileage cap you mentioned).
 
X2! Thanks for enlightening us! Have to talk with my agent soon...
 
My 94 Chevy pickup had about $7K worth of street mods on it when some jacka$$ totaled it for me. The stock truck was valued at $8K (in 2000) by the insurance co. Once my addons were depricated I got an additional $3500. The moral of the story is SAVE YOUR RECIEPTS! You will need them to prove actual cash value.
 
My 94 Chevy pickup had about $7K worth of street mods on it when some jacka$$ totaled it for me. The stock truck was valued at $8K (in 2000) by the insurance co. Once my addons were depricated I got an additional $3500. The moral of the story is SAVE YOUR RECIEPTS! You will need them to prove actual cash value.

A lot of companies have endorsements you can add, which will help to reflect the modifications and after-market stuff you've done.
 
Back
Top