• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Low budget engine/drivetrain swap

Kim Dawson

CJ-8 Member
Member
City
Molalla
State
Or
I've got three Scrambler projects without engine trans TC and some without differentials. I'm working on
other projects right now, but keeping an eye out for a donor car for a drivetrain. Cherokees in the 80s. 90s.
and early 2000s can be had from $350 to $1500 all the time. Ones with running V8s are plentiful for cheap.
I like the 4.0 six but I don't know too much on doing a V8 swap or if it is worthwhile. If I use the Cherokee
engine/trans/tc what front and back axles will work with them. I think about 1991 the engines came with Multi port FI.
Most Cherokees have automatics in them. What years are easy to use? I believe some have computor or electronic
controls that might be a problem. Anyone done a swap from a Cherokee or any other swap from a low cost donor car
that they recomend?
 
If you like the straight six 4.0 (I do), you are correct about finding used engines somewhat plentiful. However, the big problem here is the driver's side drop transfer case. Your CJ-8 has a passenger side drop.

If you are really shooting for low budget, find a CJ-5/7 and pull the drive train from that. It will be the easiest/cheapest (but maybe not the best).

If you are willing to spend a little more money, I'd suggest looking for a '91 to to 2000 cherokee with straight six and transmission and adapting to a Dana 300. Setting yourself up for fuel injection will take some effort, but in my opinion, that combination will give you the best bang for your buck with the least amount of work/money.

As with all things in life, you're gonna' get what you pay for.
 
2000and 2001 xjs have coil packs and CA emissions(4 O2 sensors, almost all 2000's anway). I would stick to 1999 as the newest. Pretty sure a Dana 300 will bolt to a aw4 from an XJ. Guys install them in YJ,TJ,XJ with flip kit rings.
 
The Cherokee with AX-15 5 speed can be adapted to teh Dana 300 with a clocking ring and spacer. So that gets you back into cheep costs, especially if you have a Dana 300.

I think that the 4 speed auto can work too, but there can be issues with Tranny Pan clearance on the 4 speed.

There Cherokee's are getting up there in age and finding a good engine can be tough at this point.

If you are looking at a V-8 the 4.8 and 5.3 chevy engines are very popular easy to convert have the same bolt pattern as early SBC's and if you have an iron duke bell-housing will bolt right up. You need to use the T-176 transmission as the T4/5 are a little light for them. Also the Gen 3 Chevys tend to last a very long time.


Carl
 
Thanks for the replys guys. Sounds like keeping the Dana 300 will keep the conversion issues easier. I do have some donor CJ7s. I wouldn't mind doing multi port FI as long as I can use the electronics from the donor Jeep. I have two iron duke bellhousings. My son wants one to have a Chevy V8. Lots of XJs with automatics available. I like the flip ring kit idea. Do these automatics (91 to 99) have electronics controled by a computor? Getting an I6 with the 5 speed might be more desireable . . . at least to me (I like shifting, my wife likes an automatic). If a clocking ring and spacer makes that fit to the dana 300, that's a good choice. I like variety, and these choices give me that. Thanks for giving me more to think about when collecting parts to put these together.
 
Personally, I like the manuals. The AX-15 was a good transmission as well as the NV. The automatic AW4 was computer controlled, but you can get kits to make it a "manually controlled automatic". If you have a Dana 300, USE IT. They are virtually indestructible. Clocking rings are like $120 or so.

Multi port fuel injection is great, but it does take some work and $$ to make it work.
 
There seems to be more older Cherokees, late 80s, with 5 speeds than newer ones, 91 up. If I find an older one, I can live with a carb and less electronics. Probably what I should do anyway. What years had the AX-15 and the NV?


Personally, I like the manuals. The AX-15 was a good transmission as well as the NV. The automatic AW4 was computer controlled, but you can get kits to make it a "manually controlled automatic". If you have a Dana 300, USE IT. They are virtually indestructible. Clocking rings are like $120 or so.

Multi port fuel injection is great, but it does take some work and $$ to make it work.
 
The older xj has a different EFI controller. Rather than Chrysler it is Renix. Still a multiport system but has less power. If you search it up it seems to work ok.

Most of those years will also have the Peugot transmission which is ok if you aren't going to beat on it much or bump up the power levels.

The AX-15 started in 90 I think. The NV came after the AX, in the early 00's.
 
I have a 96 Cherokee sport that was my daily driver for many years, then retired due to rust. It still gets started once in a while to keep things moving around the property and for a future swap. Its a 4 door fairly loaded but left the factory with a 5spd. It has 235K miles on it and even has its original clutch. The engine is less noisy (no ticks at all) than some I know with 120K miles and tons of oil pressure still too. Sometimes you just get a good one. The 4.0 at least in the mid 90s is pretty much the best 6cyl ever made IMHO and for reasons stated above. I think it was '92 that the 4.0 HO 190hp version came out, or maybe it was 1991.
 
Most of those years will also have the Peugot transmission which is ok if you aren't going to beat on it much or bump up the power levels.

I think this may be the first tine I have seen/heard a comment about the Peugeot trannys that was not negative. I would never recommend swapping one into something from all that I have heard and read.
 
I think this may be the first tine I have seen/heard a comment about the Peugeot trannys that was not negative. I would never recommend swapping one into something from all that I have heard and read.

Yeah....That.....
 
Absolutely. The dreaded split case design and internal slave. And that's just getting started ! :evil:
 
I blew a peugot making a uturn in nj. Pos..

Sent from my SM-N910P
 
I'll jump in here to mention the ZJ V8s a little too since there's been no discussion on them.

They are the Magnum 5.2L engines, and aren't bad little powerplants. The biggest issue with them was the "kegger" aluminum intake manifold, which due to manufacturing processes, ended up with a steel plenum plate screwed to the bottom. Steel and aluminum do not expand and contract at the same rates. Accordingly, ALL of these engines had plenum gasket failures around ~30K miles. Chrysler typically did the first gasket replacement for free under warranty, but when you're looking at an engine with 80K+ miles, you're almost guaranteed to have an engine with another failed plenum gasket. The failure causes oil vapors (and oil) to get sucked into the intake. This lowers octane ratings, and also significantly increases carbon deposits on the pistons, which leads to major pinging, increased compression, and eventually a rod getting tossed. Accordingly, engines pushing over 150K miles that haven't had a second gasket replaced likely have been pinging for a while, and have some carbon deposits to address.

That's not to say that these engines can't necessarily be saved, depending on what unknown damage may already exist. The aftermarket responded with an aluminum plenum plate, which when installed properly, permanently fixes this issue. And a couple cans of the MOPAR Combustion Chamber Cleaner will do wonders for the carbon deposits.

The OBDI engines are probably the easier engines to swap due to the simpler control systems for OBDI. Those 5.2Ls also came bolted to the 46RH, which is NOT a computer-controlled transmission. The issue with all the ZJ transmissions (except for the AW4, bolted to the 4.0L for just a couple months in 1993) is that they require periodic band adjustment per the FSM, and regular fluid/filter changes. Again, if the transmission's been maintained, they're known to go over 200K miles. But if they're ignored, they'll commonly fail before 150K. If you get the OBDII engine, it'll come with the 44RE, which uses the same PCM (powertrain control module) as the engine, not to mention being somewhat weaker than the 46RH. While you can transplant the OBDII engine and make it run with another transmission (including the 44RH), you'll have a check-engine light because the PCM will be looking for the appropriate electronic transmission to control.

Lack of addressing the plenum and lack of basic transmission maintenance frequently causes cheap ZJs. I see $300-$500 ZJs ALL THE TIME advertised with either a blown engine or a bad transmission.

There's lots of aftermarket support for the Magnum engines, and quite frankly there's a LOT of these engines out there since Chrysler used them in so many applications. And because they use a standard Chrysler bolt-pattern, your transmission world opens up to all the other MOPAR transmission options.

Most of the ZJ 5.2Ls came with the NP249 transfercase. This is a full-time 4WD case that uses a viscous coupler to split power. Either way, it's not something I'd generally recommend for a CJ (aside from it being the driver's-side drop). The viscous coupler was never designed to last much more than 100K miles, so if you find a ZJ with a transmission that still seems functional and a plenum that isn't completely blown, it'll probably still have a bad viscous coupler. If so, that's a good donor.

Keep in mind that the 4.0L carried on with the AMC bolt-pattern up through its demise. If you go with one of the 4.0L drivetrains, as been mentioned above, you'll run into problems with the CJ's passenger-drop front axle. So at some point you may need to consider a transfercase adapter to keep the Dana 300, or a bellhousing adapter to keep your existing CJ transmission. The 4.0L also uses a crank-position sensor, requiring you to either machine your 258 bellhousing, or get one specifically designed to work with your engine/transmission combo. Advanced Adapters makes a nice bellhousing designed to mate a 4.0L to the CJ transmissions, using the CJ clutch linkage.
 
Last edited:
As for MPFI. The 87-90's are Renix and have a higher port head that is just more difficlut. They have a knock sensor = Better but that is about it. 91-95' are the original "HO" engine with an OBDI computer. These are the easiest to use. That is what Hesco designed the Mopar MPFI kit from. Actually a 94' YJ computer. They still are the place for getting small parts to make that conversion work. If you can find a 94 YJ with 5 speed, you got the grail of switching for a CJ. The 96' and up are the OBDII computer. A little more work, but beware of the Sentry key computers. The Grey Key as opposed to the black key has a chip and you have to include the sensor with an original key to make these work. They can be reprogrammed but it is expensive. Like additional $200 to make it work.

They AX-15 5 speed came in around 1990 IIRC. all of the HO engine had the AX-15 so a 91' and later you are OK. The 2000 was the first year for a NV 3550 with a straight cut first gear that is somewhat noisy. Good transmissino with lightly more torque rating than the AX-15. But both are in line with teh T-176 for strength. 2004 I think it was am the 6 speed manual I have no experience with it but might work if you found a TJ complete and easy to swap.

The old 999 or 904 is the automatic that was in our CJ's they also used in in YJ's up to a point and then they switched to the AW-4 which is the computer controlled OD versions used in the Cherokee and later wranglers till they went with the Dimalar stuff.

The 4.0 engines were pretty stable on the Long Block. in 86' they basically went to a slightly wider block casting for all of the inline 6's both 258 and 4.0l series. That is why some 258's can use a 4.0l head unmodified and not leak. The Renix head has the older style combustion and runner design with a hig port, no advantage over the 258 head. The HO engine had a slightly higher port than the 258 but a much better runner and dome design making more power. That is part of why the 4.0l head is a good swap. To stay carbed you take the 258 intake and mount it above the locating pins rather then in the 258 locations, much easier to describe when you see that in person. But you can swap pretty much any of the 91' on heads to a 258 for 10-25 HP, debateable. But you can adopt the MPFI intake and head and comuter to a 258 longblock and get a great system.

If you swap in a 4.0l in place of a 258 not much different. You do need to use the late model motor mounts. And now they have some with as many as 7 bolt locations as opposed to the factory 3 bolts. It is easy to break those in a crash or rollover. MORE has a very good set of motor mounts. If you are hooking to a CJ transmission you have to drill the Bell housing for the crank sensor or buy the Hesco kit and put it on the front. Your choice. The engine to bell housing bolt pattern is the same. But if you score a complete pull out then the Dana 300 to YJ/XJ/ZJ transmission is easier.

Lots of easy options there. If you give a little more info I could steer you in a better direction. Now lots of ways to go with the Chevy if that is what you want to do. Plus they actually made a NP241 transfer case that was driver drop mated to a 700R4 auto. That is a good option for a gen 1 or Gen 3 SBC.


Carl
 
I have to do the plenum repair on my '03 Ram 1500 5.9. My last dodge had 160,000 on it('96 1500 5.2) and it never need to be replaced.
 
Thanks for all the replys. Awesome. Looks like Peugeot . . . hell no! Good to know. Now I know why those 87-89 Cherokees with the 5 speed are so cheap. 91 to 95 4.0 sounds like the best choice for a low budget swap and preferably with the AX15 behind it. From what you said, the CJ automatic will bolt up to the 4.0 or a V8 and I won't have to worry about hooking up electronics for the transmission. I was planning on staying away from a 200K mile 4.0 but if Erik has 235K on one and its still going strong, I'll re-think that if I find a well cared for one. Good to know about the ZJ v8s and their intake problems and how to fix them. So much info on choosings, and upgrading, and aftermarket parts to make the swap, I'm printing this out. This has to be the best Jeep Forum in existance.
 
Thanks for all the replys. Awesome. Looks like Peugeot . . . hell no! Good to know. Now I know why those 87-89 Cherokees with the 5 speed are so cheap. 91 to 95 4.0 sounds like the best choice for a low budget swap and preferably with the AX15 behind it. From what you said, the CJ automatic will bolt up to the 4.0 or a V8 and I won't have to worry about hooking up electronics for the transmission. I was planning on staying away from a 200K mile 4.0 but if Erik has 235K on one and its still going strong, I'll re-think that if I find a well cared for one. Good to know about the ZJ v8s and their intake problems and how to fix them. So much info on choosings, and upgrading, and aftermarket parts to make the swap, I'm printing this out. This has to be the best Jeep Forum in existance.

A CJ automatic can bolt up to the 4.0L, but you'll still need to machine the housing for the CPS. It won't require tearing down the transmission, but it still will be a mild PIA.

A CJ automatic WILL NOT bolt up to a Chrysler 5.2L Magnum V8. If you got with the 5.2L, you'll definitely need to source a Chrysler transmission. BUT the AX15 and NV3500 were also put behind Chrysler bolt-pattern engines (I think Ram 1500s and Durangos, but don't quote me on the correct source for parts; I just know that both of these transmissions have been stuck behind 5.2L and 5.9L engines in ZJs).

A well cared-for 4.0L can easily go behind 200K. We got my wife's '95 4.0L ZJ with 255K on the clock, and sold it with almost 290K. I took care of basic maintenance, oil leaks, plugs/wires/distributor, and did a Seafoam treatment, all while we had it. It pulled like it was new.
 
Thanks for keeping me straight on MOPAR and AMC. If I want to stay away from electronic controled transmissions, then I should leave the MOPAR v8 alone. I do have a CJ Automatic I bought a few years ago that is supposed to be in good shape. If I put it behind a 4.0 then I need to have the housing machined or go with the Hesco CPS at the crank pulley. Crank pully position seems easier. I do have a question on the 4.0 FI. Is the fuel rail different depending on if the car is auto or manual? I had heard that it was but what would be the difference? I also have an Advance Adapter bellhousing for the 4.0 that has the place for the CPS that would connect to the CJ manual transmission. Any chance an AX15 would fit that bellhousing with some drilling?
 
Thanks for keeping me straight on MOPAR and AMC. If I want to stay away from electronic controled transmissions, then I should leave the MOPAR v8 alone. I do have a CJ Automatic I bought a few years ago that is supposed to be in good shape. If I put it behind a 4.0 then I need to have the housing machined or go with the Hesco CPS at the crank pulley. Crank pully position seems easier. I do have a question on the 4.0 FI. Is the fuel rail different depending on if the car is auto or manual? I had heard that it was but what would be the difference? I also have an Advance Adapter bellhousing for the 4.0 that has the place for the CPS that would connect to the CJ manual transmission. Any chance an AX15 would fit that bellhousing with some drilling?

The 46RH is not electronically controlled, FWIW.

Yes, you can totally do the CPS at the balancer; that's how the MOPAR MPFI kit for the 258 is set up.

No, the CJ-transmission bellhousing won't bolt up to the AX15. If you look at the front of the AX transmissions, you'll see they're shaped completely differently.

I've never heard that the fuel rails are different, but at the same time, I couldn't confirm that for you either way.
 
Back
Top