• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

buying a radiator

Ron84cj

Engine nerd
Lifetime Member
City
West Bend
State
WI
I'm trying to buy an all aluminum radiator and it shows 2 different options, one with the fill cap on the drivers side and one with it in the middle. It also shows different core dimensions but doesn't show if the mounting locations are different. Were there 2 different radiators available based on options? or did it go based on year? The jeep that I putting it in is an 82 cj8 (if you even want to call it that). I didn't have one in there before so I have nothing to go off of. Any help on this subject would be greatly appreciated.
 
I have an aluminum radiator with the fill cap in the center. When I ordered mine I was told by the rep that one was for the I6 and the other for the v8. I have the 6. I believe the mounts were the same on the two I looked at.

But others may have better answers. That was my experience with Champion radiators.
 
Save your money and go with something closer to OEM. Radiator.com is where I got mine - delivered locally in about 48hrs. The standard copper brass cool just as efficiently if not moreso than aluminum. I purchased an aluminum one listed for the I6 on a CJ, and it was too deep - fan blade chopped it up on the first start.

Your mileage may vary, just my opinion.
 
I'm trying to buy an all aluminum radiator and it shows 2 different options, one with the fill cap on the drivers side and one with it in the middle. It also shows different core dimensions but doesn't show if the mounting locations are different. Were there 2 different radiators available based on options? or did it go based on year? The jeep that I putting it in is an 82 cj8 (if you even want to call it that). I didn't have one in there before so I have nothing to go off of. Any help on this subject would be greatly appreciated.

The options you are reading are likely in relation to with and without heavy duty cooling. Center fill rad and fixed 4 blade fan and no overflow bottle was standard on 6cyl scrambler. Heavy duty cooling option was side fill rad, viscous 6 blade clutch fan, and overflow bottle. All years of scrambler were this way. Bolt mounting pattern is same on both rads but rad depth mounting clearance is dif for the two fans.
 
Save your money and go with something closer to OEM. Radiator.com is where I got mine - delivered locally in about 48hrs. The standard copper brass cool just as efficiently if not moreso than aluminum. I purchased an aluminum one listed for the I6 on a CJ, and it was too deep - fan blade chopped it up on the first start.

Your mileage may vary, just my opinion.

I might have to look them up the next time I need a radiator, all the parts houses have pretty much switched to the plastic/aluminum radiators:angry:

Thanks for the vendor name :thumbsup::cheers:
 
I swapped out my old radiator on my stock 81 I6 with an Aluminum one with no shroud and it made an immediate 10-15 degree difference in cooling. That was 5 years ago and I still have not put the shroud back on and that's running the AC in this Louisiana climate.. Mine is a all welded Radiator.

PS. I have the center fill, with a overflow bottle and a six blade fan.
 
Another option is to simply recore the one you have now. It's often the cheapest route to go and you can be sure what you have will fit.

/when I replaced my original with a copper brass it was also a vast improvement over the old one. The temperature was still controlled by the thermostat, though ;)
 
Another option is to simply recore the one you have now.

That's what I did with my CJ7, and in worked fantastically! I live in hot Northern California (100+ in the summer), and I never again had an engine heat issue with the 258, even one summer when I ran A/C.

My CJ8 though, has a 350 SBC, and the fan sits 6" away from the radiator (flex fan w/2" spacer). It didn't have a shroud when I bought it (in November), and it would get pretty hot at idle/low speed. I added a Jeep 304 shroud, and it seems to help, but the shroud doesn't fit the fan very well, and I don't have high hopes for summer temps. I'll either need to fab a close-fitting shroud, or do something completely different.

I've been looking at aluminum radiators, and it looks like some of them have cores that run sideways instead of up and down, which supposedly gives the water more time to cool in the radiator... that doesn't make much sense to me though, since the water pump is circulating the coolant at the same speed...?

Anyhow, I've been looking at the aluminum radiator/electric fan setup that Novak is selling. It's expensive... but if it works, it will likely save me money in the long run.
 
Last edited:
I don't have one to recore. Even if I did, my local shop quoted me about $450 to recore, Or I could buy a new brass/copper for about $375. To my surprise he actually advised me against this and I should buy an all aluminum one saying they are actually more efficient. The guy that told me this has been in the radiator repair business for over 50 years so kinda I believed him. One place I looked at was radiatorexpress.com and they have the brass/copper one for $276 with only a 1 year warranty or the all aluminum one for $189 with a lifetime warranty. So I think I'm going to try the aluminum one. I just wanted to make sure I'm ordering the right option. This jeep is getting so close to being running and driving again after 10 years of being in pieces. I'm so excited. Thanks for your help guys!
 
I usually does come down to personal preference. A new radiator, or a recore, will be an improvement over what you have (or don't have!). There is still plenty of debate and not a lot of science on whether aluminum is more efficient than copper brass. It's like valvoline vs. castrol; weber vs. motorcraft. In my experience the copper brass was comparable in price and on top of that it just fit. It managed very well in 100*+ heat on the front range of Colorado with an 8274 in front of the grill. I did the install myself saving me mark-up costs and installation.

I've been looking at aluminum radiators, and it looks like some of them have cores that run sideways instead of up and down, which supposedly gives the water more time to cool in the radiator... that doesn't make much sense to me though, since the water pump is circulating the coolant at the same speed...?

It's physics, but still sounds wrong to me. If you have a longer path of coolant flow - e.g. if somehow they were able to make the path the coolant took from top to bottom longer by changing the orientation of flow - then in theory the coolant would be a touch colder by the time it's gone through. What still confuses me is how they can fit more length of piping in the same amount of radiator space. Unless there's a touch more radiator space - even if it were only half an inch larger in every direction, you'd add maybe 10% more cooling area. Other than that, physics and math, which hurts my brain at 6 in the morning.

Uncle. :) I give in.

It's so subjective - it's not like we're all out there with temp sensors taking measurements. Not like the companies are doing direct comparisons with the same engine in the same environmental conditions. The important thing is that both varieties do their job.
 
But I was out there with a lazer temperature sensor and I know what reading I got on my old copper/brass radiator compared to my new Aluminum one using the same thermostat. And I am still wrong which I could understand if I was arguing with a woman.
 
But I was out there with a lazer temperature sensor and I know what reading I got on my old copper/brass radiator compared to my new Aluminum one using the same thermostat. And I am still wrong which I could understand if I was arguing with a woman.

The important thing is that a new radiator, regardless of style, does its job :)
 
They get additional cooling area by using larger tubes/more fins, not by making the radiator bigger. Read about this in Hot Rod or the like, don't remember exactly...

Copper-brass is a better heat conductor material than aluminum. That is the material science.
But then, construction and material properties take over. For example, copper-brass is soldered construction, and the lead solder used to attach tubes to tanks and fins to tubes reduces the material's conductivity because of lead's material properties and because of how tightly the fins can be made to directly contact the tubes.
Whereas in aluminum, all those parts can be welded together with an aluminum alloy material which means better contact to tubes and less differential effect on heat transfer properties because of material differences.

Then, strength.
Copper-brass is weaker. So you must use smaller diameter tubes to keep thin walls and contain the pressures with vibration, impact, etc.. factors included. This means more tubes/fins are required to increase surface area of a radiator.
Aluminum can use larger tubes with thin walls and still hold pressure. That is why you hear things like "my 2 core aluminum is as good as a 3 core copper". That is likely real experience but it probably has more to do with having about same cooling surface area on tubes/fins in radiator body rather than material.
Thinking being - aluminum has 2 rows of larger tubes compared to 3 rows of smaller tubes in copper-brass to make up same cooling surface area.

Durability
Copper-brass is better and will last longer than aluminum just in terms of material. But that doesn't say anything about construction. We have all seen folks take lesser material and make it great, and great material and make it lesser. Hence, back to thinking more about construction than material.
In short, core/tube configuration and construction becomes key rather than material. Aluminum wont last as long as copper/brass just in material terms. But, a good aluminum radiator will probably last longer than a poorly made copper-brass radiator because construction will likely fail before the materials do.

Racing argument
Racers use aluminum because of the strength to weight ratio coupled with the idea that the whole radiator only has to last a few hundred really hard miles. They care about being able to hold 30+ psi of pressure with as little weight as possible. A copper/brass that would hold that pressure would be much heavier than aluminum.

OEM argument.
OEM makers have robots/fixtures for soldering and welding. So labor/input work is a wash in terms of how materials go together.
But, they buy materials by the pound. And aluminum is cheaper/stronger. And through chemistry they make it last 100k miles no problem so original buyer likely wont see it fail. And if it fails on next owner, it is a "used car" that was "maintained poorly" or whatever the discussion sounds like between owner/mechanic at that time.

Wow. That post got out of hand.
But I like how folks explain stuff on this site so I thought I would try to help too.
 
Good points cbford and you didn't make anyone feel bad doing it.
 
When I got a new radiator for my jeep, the one thing I really didn't want was a plastic tank. I found one online from the local parts store. It was even listed as a 3 core which I wanted as I had added AC and was recommended to go with 3 cores over the original 2 core. Well that one came in and was actually 2 core. Looking around, I found the aluminum radiators. Did lots of research and decided to give it a try. Only problem I had was that the 3 core I chose was out of stock nationally and they offered me a cut price on a 4 core so my wife got it for me (I was still debating on it). Well that thing cools better than I could imagine. Even the last couple of days it got up to 60-65 I never turned the electric fan on. The mechanical temp guage I have on the manifold ran around 205 the whole time (200 was what I've been running this winter). The radiator looks good and is all welded construction. My only issue was I really needed the 3 core not the 4 core. I had to do alot of trimming to get the electric fan in and not be hitting things.
 
Back
Top