• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Lift and Gearing Help/Opinions

joshvt

Scrambler Enthusiast
Lifetime Member
City
charlotte
State
nc
I am getting close to pulling the trigger on a lift and gearing change. I have been researching this, reading all the threads I can find, and would welcome any opinions/ advice. I know enough to be dangerous about this stuff. The reality is I will be having a Jeep Mechanic do this work for me, so I am trying to educate myself as much as possible before moving forward.

My Scrambler: '85, 258, T-176 4 speed, basically stock other than recent "team rush" upgrade and planning a carb udgrade / emissions simplification in the near future. This is not my DD. It stays in the garage and I drive it when I feel like it- mostly around town. I am not planning heavy off road use- maybe a trip or two to the moutains/ some mild trails and on the beach during our annual NC OBX trip. Highway driving is only occasional, but I do want to be able to take the above mentioned trips (2-4hrs) at a comfortable pace.

Here's what I am thinking:

Tires: I'd like to run BFG K02's 33x10.5 on my stock 15x7 wagon wheels

Lift: BDS 2.5". My last jeep was a yj that I put a BDS lift on and was very happy. I've heard/ read some good supporting commentary about BDS lifts on CJ's so figured it seems like a good option.

Shackles: Consensus seems to be that I should replace the shackles, but I am not clear on what shackles would be a good choice. I've see the Currie greasable shackles get good reviews, but really not sure. I am not looking to gain excessive lift.

Gears: I have 2.73 gears. These seem too tall IMO, even on the street with the skinny bobo street tires that were mounted when I bought the Jeep. So I am thinking for my use, tire size, 4 speed, etc. a 3.73 would probably be a good fit. Haven't ruled out a 4:10.

In talking with my mechanic, I have realized the, gearing, axles, etc. isn't a small expense due to the case break and need for a new carrier. And while all this is being done, i might as well do solid axles...

Any opinions on the above would be much appreciated- especially from anyone who is running a similar setup either 3.73 with 33's
 
Here is a good reference for gear ratios.
http://www.offroaders.com/tech/gear-ratio-chart.htm

I've had a BDS 2.5 on one of my past CJ's and had no complaints with it, would use again

Shackles IMO I wouldn't replace them with anything to gain lift, if anything maybe just a little beefier one. I still run the factory ones on mine with 36's and have never had issues
 
I'd go with 3.73 for 33s and a four speed. A five speed would make 4.10 gears more acceptable.

I've got 4.10s and 33s with a four speed, and I'd really like lower rpm at freeway speeds.

I'd either like to swap in a five speed, or swap in 3.73 gears.

Good luck!
 
I would not rule out 4:10 gears. I'm running 4:10 with 31" tires but with a 5.3L and a 4L60 tranny. At 65 MPH I'm running right at 2,000 RPM.
 
I'm running a pretty stock 258 w/ a T5 (but I had a T4 for a couple years) on 32's. I regeared to 3.73's. I wish now I'd have done 4.10; but the 4 speed does create some issues at highway speed. At 72 ish on the highway when I had the 4 speed the 258 had to wrap more than it wanted too...... 4.0's (easy swap candidate at some point) are happier running at 3k all day.

My 2 cents
 
When a Jeep was sold new with 2:73 gears it also came from the factory with either 29 or 30 inch tires. Even when they came with the 3:73 they only wore 31" tires.
 
I have cj7 with 4.10 gears and t4 and have run it with 33"s and 35"s and really wish for a 5th or 6th gear. Great for trails and some around town but zero highway. I will swap the trans at some point but undecided at this time. Have 3.73gears and 33"s in the scrambler with a th400 automatic and it rides great. Sometimes wish it wasn't an auto though. Moving up to 35"s and 4.10 soon . Maybe just swap the axles/housings on the 7 and 8.
 
I have cj7 with 4.10 gears and t4 and have run it with 33"s and 35"s and really wish for a 5th or 6th gear. Great for trails and some around town but zero highway. I will swap the trans at some point but undecided at this time. Have 3.73gears and 33"s in the scrambler with a th400 automatic and it rides great. Sometimes wish it wasn't an auto though. Moving up to 35"s and 4.10 soon . Maybe just swap the axles/housings on the 7 and 8.
Swapping the rear end's sounds like a win for both Jeeps.
 
I would not rule out 4:10 gears. I'm running 4:10 with 31" tires but with a 5.3L and a 4L60 tranny. At 65 MPH I'm running right at 2,000 RPM.

Dennis,

Your setup sounds good for your application. :thumbsup:

However, with his T176 trans. and 33" tires, 3.08 gears would more closely match your numbers.

Your 5.3L and automatic don't really compare to his 4.2L and manual in the performance department.

My worn out 4.2L, T176, 32" MTR's, and 3.54 gears are not what I would call ideal in performance. (Which of course is subjective.)

This is a good resource for comparing different setups with like engines:
http://www.grimmjeeper.com/gears.html
 
FLCJ8- that grimmjeeper gear calculator is really cool. Thanks for mentioning.

So according to that, with my 4 speed, 3.73's and BFG 33 K02's (which are actually 32.5") I'd be turning 2699rpm's @ 70 mph. 4.10's would require 2967. Even 2699 sounds like a lot! I don't do much highway driving, but I want to be able to, when needed. What is the ideal highway rpm range for a 258?
 
4.10 if not a lot of highway driving. 3.73 if you hit the highway.

I had 4.10 with my 33 inch swampers, 6 cyl, and T150 3 speed. It worked great. If you had a V8 I would say go with 3.73
 
I would not rule out 4:10 gears. I'm running 4:10 with 31" tires but with a 5.3L and a 4L60 tranny. At 65 MPH I'm running right at 2,000 RPM.

When a Jeep was sold new with 2:73 gears it also came from the factory with either 29 or 30 inch tires. Even when they came with the 3:73 they only wore 31" tires.

Yes, you have 4.10's and 31" tires, BUT your 4L60 transmission has a very deep overdrive. My 05 Rubicon has 4.10's and 31" tires, but the stupid deep overdrive of the automatic transmission makes this OK, the RPM's are around 2,000 at 65mph.

I ran 4.10's/33" tires with a T176, Mopar MPI equipped 4.2, in my red Scrambler temporarily. It seemed that 65mph was a good top speed to run on long highway trips, the RPM's were just too high over 65mph with the T176:twocents: After one 7 hour highway trip, I purchased the AX15 to replace the T5's I kept blowing up :thumbsup:
 
I'm running 4.10s with 33x10.50 BFGs with 258 and T176
I am not bothered by running 3000 rpm on the highway at 70 mph, but I understand how some might be bothered.
Lugging the engine is worse than revving it to 3000 for any length of time

Most of my driving is backroads and it does run the backroads quite nicely in 4th gear.

I'd still like more power than the 258...
 
Thanks for all the input on this. I am torn- leaning towards 3.73's since I don't plan on changing the transmission. We shall see- I have been known to change my mind...

One other question for those running 33's- will 33's rub the springs at full steering lock? This happened on my wrangler. It wasn't a big deal with the shorter wheelbase, but I'd like to not lose turning radius on the scrambler. I believe the frame is narrower so hoping no rub
 
I have an 81 with narrow track axles and no lift. I tried a friends 33 12.5 15s on 10 inch wide wheels (with 4" backspace). They would rub on full lock turns on flat ground. Rear fender wells had plenty of room, the front was tighter. Wide track axles and a lift would certainly help in the clearance department though
 
I decided to go with 3.73's since this jeep is going to see mostly street use and I want it to be decent on the highway. I also determined I have a T-177 which has a lower first gear than a T-176 so that will help to get things moving a little better.

Last thing I need to decide is whether to am open or l/s rear. Thoughts on this for a jeep that will be mostly street use for now? I am reaching my budget threshold for this round of work, but also realize this is the time to do it, if I want to. When I do go off-road it will be moderate mountain trails or sand at NC's obx.

I dropped the jeep off at the shop yesterday so need to make a decision tomorrow. As always, appreciate any thoughts
 
Thanks for all the input on this. I am torn- leaning towards 3.73's since I don't plan on changing the transmission. We shall see- I have been known to change my mind...

One other question for those running 33's- will 33's rub the springs at full steering lock? This happened on my wrangler. It wasn't a big deal with the shorter wheelbase, but I'd like to not lose turning radius on the scrambler. I believe the frame is narrower so hoping no rub

I am running 33x10.5 and have no problems rubbing.
 
Last thing I need to decide is whether to am open or l/s rear. Thoughts on this for a jeep that will be mostly street use for now? I am reaching my budget threshold for this round of work, but also realize this is the time to do it, if I want to. When I do go off-road it will be moderate mountain trails or sand at NC's obx.

I dropped the jeep off at the shop yesterday so need to make a decision tomorrow. As always, appreciate any thoughts
If you plan on being in sand, I would definitely replace the open diff. Actually, I can't imagine any 4x4 with an open rear.
You'll be replacing the rear carrier anyway (as well as the front) so the additional cost should only be the difference between an open and non-open carrier.
 
I installed a Detroit locker in mine and I can hear the tires squeal when turning a sharp corner. I wish I would have gone limited slip sometimes. Nah, not really. :)
 
Back
Top