• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Dedicated LS and 4.0L CJ engine swap sub-forums - good idea?

bigwalton

Alaskan Postal nutjob
FORUM MANAGER
SOA Member
City
Dexter
State
MI
I have been thinking about creating two engine swap subforums on here. One for the LS and one for the 4.0L. A comment in @Kane's new LS swap thread made me write this out.

We have a host of great LS swap threads, I love that most of those authors are already on Kane's thread contributing to that one. I would copy their threads and Kane's one to that subforum with permanent redirects in the main drivetrain forum. @Randyzzz, @mysunnshine, @Ron84cj all have great threads/info to include too.

Similarly, after losing CJOffroad.com, there's no good forum home for 4.0L swap info that I'm aware of. I know that forum was a godsend when I did my 4.0L swap. Not saying that we have the best ones out there online, but someone somewhere really needs to restart all of that.

It might bring some non-Scrambler CJ folks to the site via google searches or whatever, but as long as they're talking CJ swap stuff, it's all still relevant. A CJ is a CJ for those swaps, for the most part, as long as it doesn't get back into older CJ models.

Seem like a good idea?
 
The 4.0L subforum could realistically include anything with swapping a 4.0L head and Mopar MPFI on as well. Lots of good info on that here too. @spankrjs comes to mind immediately there.
 
I like it! :thumbsup:

I wish I had been more informed about LS swaps a few years ago, and having all that information in one place might have motivated me to take the plunge.
 
If you do this i will be more inclined to provide a heavier amount of detail in my threads for others to read later on. I used to be that way but have backed off on forums alot over the years. I like the idea if it helps others.
 
If you know the link to a CJoffroad thread, you can still get the information from the way back machine.
 
If you do this i will be more inclined to provide a heavier amount of detail in my threads for others to read later on. I used to be that way but have backed off on forums alot over the years. I like the idea if it helps others.
This sounds like reason enough for me. Done deal, I’m on it!
 
I like the idea, but just don't call it "LS Swap" specifically. The "4.0 Swap" specifically is good, but maybe leave the other category title more open to include the Ford and HEMI stuff too...? Or at the very least, if you do an "LS Swap" category, also add a generic "Non-AMC Swap" just to maybe coax the Windsor, Coyote, HEMI and Jolt projects too.
 
Forums created, agree with the idea of including the others, but I think that the 4.0 and LS/LT are each big enough topics on their own, so I made a third for essentially any other swaps. I didn't see a reason to exclude AMC V8 swaps, so it's just all others. The AMC V8s and 4.0L swaps are different animals, so I don't want to combine them in one either.

Actually, now I want to make one for aftermarket/junkyard EFI too
 
Last edited:
This may be premature, but maybe we could have an "EV swap" forum too. We've got one going on right now (@timo439), and I'm super interested in how it turns out.

I remember Mr. Cunningham (my high school auto shop teacher, 1986) saying, "an electric car could burn rubber from here to Glenn (about 15 miles away), if we had batteries that could store that much energy."

I've never forgotten that comment, and I've been waiting a long time for those batteries to be invented. I think we're almost there! ⚡
 
Forums created, agree with the idea of including the others, but I think that the 4.0 and LS/LT are each big enough topics on their own, so I made a third for essentially any other swaps. I didn't see a reason to exclude AMC V8 swaps, so it's just all others. The AMC V8s and 4.0L swaps are different animals, so I don't want to combine them in one either.

Actually, now I want to make one for aftermarket/junkyard EFI too
I don't disagree that the LS is definitely a staple swap (I plan on one myself), but I am always leery about being so up front with those keywords for fear that unwanted search engine traffic will result. The "LS swap the world" commune is vast and not always useful or friendly...

I'm also a proponent of the Search function. It would be pretty easy to isolate LS platforms in a general "Motor Swap" subforum.....but I digress. Carry on....
 
I don't disagree that the LS is definitely a staple swap (I plan on one myself), but I am always leery about being so up front with those keywords for fear that unwanted search engine traffic will result. The "LS swap the world" commune is vast and not always useful or friendly...

I'm also a proponent of the Search function. It would be pretty easy to isolate LS platforms in a general "Motor Swap" subforum.....but I digress. Carry on....
The fact that it’s so popular actually lessens the probability of anyone not interested in at least CJs if not Scramblers will bother with it.

There’s going to be a while before there’s enough content to draw much rank in any basic google searches regardless.

it’s not like I’m going to allow Toyota LS swap threads or anything ;)
 
This may be premature, but maybe we could have an "EV swap" forum too. We've got one going on right now (@timo439), and I'm super interested in how it turns out.

I remember Mr. Cunningham (my high school auto shop teacher, 1986) saying, "an electric car could burn rubber from here to Glenn (about 15 miles away), if we had batteries that could store that much energy."

I've never forgotten that comment, and I've been waiting a long time for those batteries to be invented. I think we're almost there! ⚡
Maybe, I’ll move it to the “other” forum for now.
 
This is a great idea! It will be nice having the info in one place. And thanks for mentioning my thread. Hopefully it helps people out.
 
For mine? See if this works.

 
Back
Top