"My 81 has CC 3.31 Trac-Lok, and I have 2.5” lift with Rocky Road YJ spring conversion. I’m running 33x12.5 15R, and I have the I6 258 4.2. When going uphill she boggs down, and loses speed. I end up letting folks pass on mountain roads. What gears will allow me to get better MPG and have 4th pull me up the hill?"
Is this the question? 3.31 is pretty tall gearing for 33" rubber and the 258. Lowering it to at least 4.11 or lower would make a huge difference. I assume you've got the 4 speed still. Too low and you'll feel like you're going to throw a rod on the highway. 4.11 with the 1:1 4 speed will generally give you about half the rpm of your speed (60 mph= 3000 rpm, 50 mpg= 2500 rpm).i
Changing gearing is pretty involved. Smaller rubber and more usable horsepower (say with a sniper fuel injection, HEI and 2.5" exhaust) could give you the results you're after with much less work.