• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

401 or 258? Buying preference inquiry

racinrudy

Scrambler Junkie
Lifetime Member
City
Findlay
State
Oh
Hey all, I'm building a "new" Scrambler and am at a crossroad for the drivetrain. 258/T5 or 401/T177 ?

The Jeep will be a beauty queen mall crawler when done. Too pretty to wheel

If you were buying, which combo would add the most value to you? Both will be rebuilt and carbed. Nothing radical on either.

...and assuming you like the 401: How much more would you pay for it?

I have access to both combos.

Thanks for any input
Rudy
 
401/Turbo 400!
Maybe a cam that talks to ya!:D
(That was one of the options wasn't it?)
 
Rudy if you are looking at most appeal to a buyer in the future I would go with a 5.3l SBC and a 4L60E. You can get a nice exhaust note, great MPG and probably the best resale value in the end.


Carl
 
Thanks Carl but I'm working with what I have in the shop so my two choices are predetirmined.

Anybody else?
 
I don't think you'll get close to anything that would actually matter in terms of resale by asking on here... too many factors that would play into it (condition of motors, age, gas price when you go to sell, etc)

I'd look at it like this, what would you do with the 401 otherwise? That will be a big plus to lots of people in any vehicle. The Scrambler is "rare" (read different) already, so I don't see the 401 doing much as a plus over the fact that it's a Scrambler already.

I guess I'm saying that if you're mainly concerned about resale, I wouldn't bother with the 401 in the Scrambler and save it for when it would be the main feature of the vehicle or is needed (power for real offroading).
 
That's kind of what I was thinking as well, regarding the rare factor.

I just often don't see things the same way as others. I honestly don't like AMC V8's because they don't like me. I've had nothing but trouble with them... But I know many folks just live for em!

Thank you for the input...

anybody else have $.02 to throw in? I'll pay you back someday :)
 
Gas prices being what they are I'd go with the 258/T5 and save the 401 for another project, like Eric said, an off road project that needs the extra power.
 
Given that you are looking to live with what you have on hand.

Personally I would go with the 258 and sell the 401 or hold it off for another special project. The 6 should give decent MPG. If you have to have the V-8 rumble go for it.

Later on the 401 will be a premium for the sale but do not expect to get that much more out of the jeep for it.

Heck you might even be better off to shop the 401 for sale and put a 360 in it. might get a couple of hundred $'s to put into your pocket.

But for most appeal I still think some sort of variant of the SBC would be your best bet.


Carl
 
258/T5. Put a H.O. 4.0 head on it and it you will love it.

Many CJ drive train parts are not built to take the power of a 401. Even the T177 is marginal for this engine. The 401 is a better choice for Dana 44's or 60's, T18 or NV4500 (but I prefer an automatic with the 401), larger gas tank, and heavy duty u-joints and driveshafts.
 
401

I am partial to the AMC V8's. My trucks have 360's and 401's. If you are not driving it every day go for the torque of the V8. If you are considering the T-176 or T-177 behind the 401 then you better have a few spare because if you wheel it hard the 401 has been know to shread the input gear teeth. A much better combo is the 401 T-18 / Dana 20 combo. My 81 CJ 7 has a 360 with a T-176 but it is a street only truck.
 
Thanks guys...given this is all about the $$$ < I'm going small.

I really appreciate all the input :) :bow:

Rudy
 
If you decide on the 258, I'd consider fuel injection over the carb. When I had my 6 rebuilt, I went with the Howell TBI unit. It was less than half the price of the Mopar MPI unit and it runs like a dream.

Just a thought...
 
Back
Top