• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Anyone else done with Optima Red Tops?

I currently still have an Optima from 2000 that started life in my 1989 XJ plow rig. Then it went into my 1984 CJ-7 with the 4.2L, and stayed in during the swap to the 5.9L.
It currently resides in my CJ-8 since 2007. It passes load tests with flying colors ( 800 A...good for a 12 year old), and has never been fully discharged. I dont have a charger with AGM setting...I have my old 2/10/55 which does the trick....I never charge higher than 2 anyway.

Through perseverence I have brought a couple Optimas back to life.when I ran the shop a few came in dead..... force a 10A charge on them for a few minutes...then switch up to 55 for a couple seconds...back to 10...repeat a few dozen times...and they will usually start taking a charge....even the ones that have gassed. One or two of those are still around too.

guess I need to knock on wood, pinch of salt over the shoulder, and every other voodoo hokum i can think of to keep this thing around!:crazy:
 
Had a Red Top since 9/10. Just ran down this winter and won't hold a charge. Gentleman at the auto place informed me that all the recent solar flares have caused many batteries failures this spring....:shrug:

Time to change..
 
If it is a Solar Flare issue.


Then why are all of the old batteries still going and it seems to only be the new ones that are going bad???????

Did they cut down on the Radiation shielding as a cost cutting measure with the move to Mexico, or is it that because of the tilt of the Earth that they need less down there????







Solar Flares.............:shrug:

Carl
 
If it is a Solar Flare issue.


Then why are all of the old batteries still going and it seems to only be the new ones that are going bad???????

Did they cut down on the Radiation shielding as a cost cutting measure with the move to Mexico, or is it that because of the tilt of the Earth that they need less down there????



Solar Flares.............:shrug:

Carl

I don't know about that, but a flock of fairies snuck under my hood last nightand sucked all the juice out of my battery. They also stole all of my blinker fluid and replaced my muffler bearing grease with mayonaise.
 
Blinker Fluid??!!! Well THAT makes more sense than solar flares! Or maybe one leaks into the other??!! Combined with the earth tilt difference in Mexico and recycled lead, I think we have the answer,,,:woot:
 
Yeah, the parts guy could have just said "they all do that" and been done with it.
 
I think I may have found the problem, and it is not specific to Optima batteries, but rather AGM batteries. We may be overcharging our AGM batteries. Once the battery is fully charged, it doesn't like to see 14 or 15 volts, this will produce something called "gassing" which is when the internal pressure inside the battery causes the internal gases produced by charging to escape through a safety pressure valve. This gassing and over charging shortens battery life.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VRLA_battery

http://www.windsun.com/Batteries/Battery_FAQ.htm#Battery Charging

I went through 2 yellow tops in 1 year, they replaced, third one only made it 6 months, I sold the other warranty batt. I did a lot of research at the time and found out three things about the Optima battery and why it does always do well in vehicles:
1 - they prefer slow charging, like a trickle charger or other solid state charger, the amount of charging a regular car alternator develops is more than they like
2 - you cannot discharge them completely, they will just die
3 - they are surprisingly affected by temp changes, they may resist shock and vibration well, but temp changes just kill them.
 
Wow, never had a problem with Optima and I usually get the Red Top......

Might take that off the parts list.

Any alternate recommendations?
 
Odyssey/Die Hard Platinum (rebaged Odyssey) seem to be the way to go if you want a good AGM.

Optimas just aren't what they used to be. I've bought redtops exclusively since the late 90's for our fleet (2 trucks, 3 Jeeps, a 4Runner, two tractors) and IMO they have declined substantially in quality.

I recently bought a Deka severe service battery from my local carquest. I have heard only good about them and just couldn't justify $200+ for a battery. The Deka is made in the USA, same warranty as an Optima, and was $115 out the door. Granted it's not a sealed AGM, but I haven't had any of the Jeeps upside down since 1996, so I think I'll be ok with a regular battery.
 
I don't know about recently, but I always used to use a duralast gold from autozone. 3 year free replacement with 7 years prorated. Not AGM, but a damn good battery nonetheless. Worked like a horse and because of the battery tray being pretty large I fit some monsters with 900-1050 cranking amps under two cj7's hoods
 
My yellow top was drained over night because I left the head lights on my '8 on all night I dropped it into my tahoe jumped it with the other tahoe let it idle for a few. Drove to work (6 miles), got to work shut it down, waited a min tryed to restart and it cranked right up. So dead optmias can be brought back!
 
I was watching spike tv's power block and found a segment on ctek chargers for optimum batteries/ all batteries.
I bought this one:
http://smartercharger.com/battery-chargers/#CTEK Multi US 7002

And I haven't had a problem since. My jeep is a summer toy so it sits for a period of time. not sure
about any problems with this battery in a DD?? but I've had this optimum battery in my jeep for some time now.
last year(I think maybe the year before) I noticed it wasn't holding a charge after trickle charging on my much larger sears
model charger. I had seen the advertisement on extreme 4x4 or trucks. google searched the product... and bought one.
no problems since then...

7jeeps7kings
 
My second hand blue top is still going strong after almost seven years. My last red top died after three years. I plan on some heavy research before my next buy.
 
I have two red tops, one in my scrambler and one in my classic mustang. The mustang battery sits on a ctek charger with AGM setting. The scrambler is my daily driver so no charger needed. Both batteries have been completely discharged at least once and both were brought back with the ctek charger. I do not know precisely when each was manufactured or where but the mustang battery was purchased 3 years ago and the scrambler battery 18 months ago.

This thread makes me rethink my next battery purchase. Thanks for sharing.
 
I had 2 red tops... one was 9 years old before I sold the Jeep that it was in (It was in many Jeeps) The other was 4-5ish years old, sold Jeep.
I have a blue top now, came with Scrambler. I have had it hooked to a battery "maintainer" all winter. Still good. Its AT LEAST 2 years old.
 
Back
Top