• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Anyone else done with Optima Red Tops?

bigwalton

Alaskan Postal nutjob
FORUM MANAGER
SOA Member
City
Dexter
State
MI
I had to return one myself and I just helped my neighbor diagnose that his was bad (he didn't want to believe it could be the Red Top) after only 6 months.

I won't be buying another one, I know I've seen people mention that they also had trouble. Curious if we could get a list of folks with FIRST HAND experience with them going bad way too soon.

Methinks Odyssey is the next one I get.
 
I bought one on line, lasted 6 months, got an Auto Palace special and it has been running strong for 4 years... just a trickle charger in the winter is all I do.

The Red Top ran down one time and it never could get back to charging.

cb
 
I have had great luck with the Yellow and Blue Top versions, but I think the quality is definitely "hit or miss":shrug::(
 
I have had great luck with the Yellow and Blue Top versions, but I think the quality is definitely "hit or miss":shrug::(

I have always got 5-6 years out of mine...quit buying them when they doubled the price..the first ones i was buying for 100-130..
 
I did some research a while back on batteries. Everything I read was to stay away from the optimas. IIRC, there was a Sears HD one that seemed to be getting the best reviews.
 
Have had the same problem with them . Spoke with my battery rep and he said they no longer use virgin lead it is recycled lead. I went with a North star battery and have had no problems US made and a good warranty . I have heard the odyssey is also a good one.
 
The Sears Platinum is a rebadged Odyssey. Supposedly great battery but $200 is steep.
I've run red tops for years. Bought two in Aug of 2009 and both were dead in a year. I'm done with them. Johnson Controls bought them out and now they're made in Mexico. Turned to crap and doubled the price at the same time. No thanks.

Got a Deka farm battery at Carquest last time I got a battery. $116 with tax. Made in the USA. Same warranty as the Optima and the Odyssey.
 
Boat

I had a blue top in my boat for one season before it went (last spring). They warrantied it, but lectured me that I wasn't using a good enough trickle charger.....
 
Every Optima I've bought went bad quickly and had to be warrentied. I had a thread on this a while back. I have a Yellow Top in the Scrambler currently....it's been warrentied, too.
 
I have had a couple last 5-6 years, but Sam has had lousy success. Several warrantied. He just kept getting them because they were under warranty.

I bought a Sears Platinum for our Scrambler. 3 years and counting.
 
I have one that has been working well for a couple years. My old fashion battery charger does not have an AGM selection on it and I wonder if that could be part of the problem some people are having in getting them to recharge.
 
I just bought a battery for my Lincoln the end of February. Car died a week ago, the battery is at 75% after charging for 24hours. Took it back to and the store is trying to tell me the battery is fine, I said well if the car dies again you picking up the towing charge. They warranted the battery and I walked out with a new one.

Not a red, yellow, blue or any of those rainbow colors but maybe the whole battery world is going to hell
 
I'm running a pair of Red Tops- both are from 2008/2009, they sat on the shelf with a maintain charger until about 6 months ago. Bummer for me, I sorta need to stick to Optimas, I have 2 custom battery boxes powdercoated to match for them...
 
I have an 8 year old Farm and Fleet special in my Scram--don't see the need for big buck batts folks, never had one and never will. Save your money!
 
I have an 8 year old Farm and Fleet special in my Scram--don't see the need for big buck batts folks, never had one and never will. Save your money!
Is that a gel cell spill proof battery? I do NOT want anything with liquid acid in my Scrambler.
 
Thanks...mine was working fine...until now! Full recharge started the car twice...now dead! :angry::angry::angry:
 
I think I may have found the problem, and it is not specific to Optima batteries, but rather AGM batteries. We may be overcharging our AGM batteries. Once the battery is fully charged, it doesn't like to see 14 or 15 volts, this will produce something called "gassing" which is when the internal pressure inside the battery causes the internal gases produced by charging to escape through a safety pressure valve. This gassing and over charging shortens battery life.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VRLA_battery

http://www.windsun.com/Batteries/Battery_FAQ.htm#Battery Charging
 
Why did they used to be so good for so long? A chemistry change roughly timed with their manufacurig move to Mexico?
 
I had a lot of "may"s in my statement.....

After I fully charged the battery out of my Jeep using an AGM charger setting, I then put it back in my Jeep and ran it. After shutting down my Jeep, the battery hissed at me as air was escaping the one way valve, the battery is now toast. May or may not be related to Mexico, may or may not be related to overcharging, perhaps my brake lights were just stuck on again....:shrug:

Either way, I am getting a new battery, but I am going to pay closer attention to the voltage regulation on the charging circuit.

I'll gladly buy an American made AGM battery next time....even though my Jeep was made by some French company....:jeep::usflag:
 
i had a red top in my ranger for 3 weeks. volt meter was ALWAYS at 13.6 volts. the red plastic started to melt after 3 weeks. i put my 8 year old walmart battery back in it. i also used to have a deep cycle blue top for my trolling motor that would last about half of what my el cheapo deep cycle would. the motor wasnt as fast either. i got about 3 seasons out of that compared to 5 or 6 with my other batteries. my friend swears by his but hes only had it a month in a car that isnt on the road yet.
 
Back
Top