• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Center-Diff 4wd systems Swapped into CJ's

The D300 is a close relative to the D20. It has a better low range, better bearings, and helically cut gears but operation is similar.
The newer chain drive cases are “shift on the fly” and that’s what makes them so nice. But- they only “shift on the fly” if the front hubs are already engaged.

Isn't the Dana 18/20 a sliding gear engagement versus a dog collar? That would explain the needing to stop to shift it, because you physically have to engage the gears from the helical high range to the straight cut low range. The dog collar type gear cases, like D300 and NP205, have the actual gears in mesh all the time, but use a collar to attach the outupts to the desired ratio. The dog collar cases can in fact be "shifted on the fly" from 4wd to 2wd to 4wd, but you have to relieve torque momentarily for the dogs to unload, such as blipping the throttle. I've ran twin sticked NP205's for years, which are dog collar gear drive boxes, and could engage or disengage the front on the fly by just applying pressure to the stick and lifting the throttle for a second. Granted, twin sticking probably makes it much easier than single stick.
 
Isn't the Dana 18/20 a sliding gear engagement versus a dog collar? That would explain the needing to stop to shift it, because you physically have to engage the gears from the helical high range to the straight cut low range. The dog collar type gear cases, like D300 and NP205, have the actual gears in mesh all the time, but use a collar to attach the outupts to the desired ratio. The dog collar cases can in fact be "shifted on the fly" from 4wd to 2wd to 4wd, but you have to relieve torque momentarily for the dogs to unload, such as blipping the throttle. I've ran twin sticked NP205's for years, which are dog collar gear drive boxes, and could engage or disengage the front on the fly by just applying pressure to the stick and lifting the throttle for a second. Granted, twin sticking probably makes it much easier than single stick.
Yes, you are correct. I was over-simplifying my answer. The D300 shifts with a sliding collar and the D20 has the collar machined as part of the gear. This does make the D300 somewhat easier to shift and yes, it can be shifted on the fly by modulating the throttle to release torque binding. However- the process is nowhere as smooth or transparent as with a chain drive case.
As far as strength, I will agree that gears are stronger than a chain. However- in a gear driven case, the torque loads are constantly trying to force the gears apart- out of mesh. That requires a beefy case to keep things together. Like an Atlas. This added bulk and weight is of no consequence to a rock crawler, but might be a concern for a daily driver or a trail runner. Sort of like a NV4500 is an amazingly strong 5 speed, but it’s huge and I doubt many daily drivers would choose it over a world class T5, AX15, or T56.
A chain driven case has the strength advantage that torque loads try to shorten the chain, forcing the two gears together, or skipping the chain if the chain is worn. A case can be much lighter but very strong with chain drive. And an advantage is butter smooth shifting.
 
Back
Top