• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Cooling water in my oil, need help

cjgoode

Legacy Registered User
City
Central
State
FL
84 258 6 cyl

I have a re manufactured engine, never been out of the driveway. It is getting cooling water in the engine oil. It is under a warranty for parts. I got a new head gasket and pulled the head. The old gasket looked good and did not really show signs of it leaking. Put in new head gasket and it is getting water in the oil again.

It has good compression in all cylinders between 152 and 155 for each
It runs perfectly and starts right up, but radiator water is getting in the oil, it is milky again and went from low to full on the dip stick after running it a few times. When I put new oil in it I purposely left it a quart low.

Any help on what could cause this. A warped head? A cracked block? can the block crack and leak water into the oil with no impacts on compression? Could it have overheated? It has never run for more then a few minutes at a time and never run without water and oil of course, and it has a good water pump.

Would like to know possible causes and fixes before I go back to the auto store. My fear is they will say it overheated and not covered.

Thanks for any input Chris.
 
With all the oil/water passages in a block, I'd think it could easily crack and not be in the cylinder wall where it would impact compression. I'm no expert though.
 
Yup, if you have a known good Head Gasket, the only other way for oil and ater to mix is a crack in the block somewhere. WARRANTY TIME
 
Did you remember to put sealant on the head bolt that enters the water passage. I believe that it is at the front of the block?

Check on a good rebuilding book. One of the bolts on a 258/4.0L requires some sort of sealant.


Carl
 
Thanks, even if it is not it I will sleep tonight with atleast some hope that it is.

I did not seal that bolt, and I have now checked the manual (Haynes) 5 times and it does not say anything about that at all. But it is such great news for me I dug out a chiltons manual, and there it is in the chiltons. Bolt 11 the front right bolt must be sealed. All the other bolts get torqued to 85 ft lbs, but bolt 11 should be sealed and torqued to 75.

Wow thanks a lot, atleast I now have hope of not pulling the engine. I pulled the bolt, drained the cooling system, blew the hole dry, sealed and torqued the bolt. I will now wait 2 days to make sure it dries and put new oil and water and test.

This makes sense to be this bolt since no oil is in the cooling water and it has good compression, and it is a re manufactured engine that was suppose to be 100% checked for cracks. I have been working on this for over a year and thought this engine would save me engine work, and I have had to work on the engine and never even got to drive it around the block.

Thanks a bunch, and if anyone else has input or can confirm this bolt would leak a lot of water into the oil I would still love more info.
 
Sill leaks, leaks water into the oil pan without even running it. Time to exercise the warranty and get a new long block.

Thanks for the input. Now I can return it armed with good info.
 
Where did you buy the rebuild from, was it rebuilt locally (to you) or out of state?

I bought one of my i6 from Cummins, it was a POS.
 
When you backed the #11 out did you drain down water first? By removing with full coolant in the system a lot of water will drain thru head into pan, you may want to retry with coolant drained down and apply non hardening sealant, drain and change oil, remove or loosen the temp sending unit from left rear of head and refill coolant. after coolant escapes from sending unit
reseat and start. You may want to try this before removeing the engine.
If this seems to hold coolant in place I would change oil again within a day.
Good luck, and let us know the outcome.
 
Good Luck! I'm sure they will take care of the warranty just like they are suppose to but....if there is problems, I have an extra 258 I know is good and ran great when I pulled it out and I will help you out on the price! So sleep well!
 
They are shipping me a new longblock. Bought it from Advanced Auto, a big chain here in FL, probably nation wide. Figured most of these places are getting the longblocks from the same place. Anyway they asked me a few questions and had no problems sending out a new block. It leaked into the pan while just sitting there, you did not even have to start it.

New block should be here next week.
 
Back
Top