I have several 8274's and they are about the toughest, most respected winch available. Plus it's the "correct" Jeep winch.
I mounted one on my Scrambler, but because it blocks a good portion of the radiator- and I have a 5.3 with a/c and a trans cooler- I ended up removing it. (I since found the possible cause of my heat issue- so the winch may not have been the cause.) I replaced it with one of the $300 Q-Tec winches. It looks to be good quality, but I haven't tested it yet. It sure isn't on par with any 8274...and I'm having a hard time justifying that I just bought a Chinese winch. (I did start a review thread of the Q-Tec Q9000.)
Anyways...$700 for a good working 8274 is not out of line. I will be selling my 3 8274's for around that price, but I will have resealed them, put on new solenoid covers, and basically make them look like new, with repo SE decals to boot! Don't hold your breath, I probably won't have them available till spring next year. Any $250 8274 will either need some work, or the seller doesn't know what he has.
If the one listed is nice, and you feel comfortable with that price, go for it!