Tall person opinion... trouble.
Our dealer finally got a 4-door (2WD, just moronic, auto, hard top) and I took a look.
I dislike the flenders even more in person. I was hoping that after seeing them up close, they would make more sense or look better, they don't. They simply look like they're about 10% larger than they should be. Maybe this effect wouldn't be so bad with larger tires, but the thing that gets me is the connection between the flender and the hood/grille corner. It just looks like someone made a mistake in design or production. It's a minor thing, but with the old fenders/grille being such a big part of the look, it's just wrong. I'm thinking of starting a business making various replacements, that market will be HUGE IMHO.
The V-6 looks wrong obviously, but the worst is how horribly far back it sits in the bay! I don't know what kind of setup you'll have to have to get the passenger-rear cylinder's spark plug out. The rear of the engine is recessed back into the firewall and the plugs are angled to the rear. There's a silly amount of space between the pulleys and the electric fans on the back of the radiator.
The frame is BEEF, between this and the longish suspension arms, this was the most impressive feature to me. You won't need frame plates and what not on these. I can see where just a little lift will clear huge tires, and I bet long arm kits are considerably less popular on the JKs, you simply won't need them.
Finally, I got to sit in it... what a complete let-down!!!

If that thing is supposed to be larger (I'm talking driver seat here), it sure ain't on the inside! The dash comes out at you, making the steering wheel/windshield feel like they are right up in your face, but that's not the worst part.
The rollbar is twice as close to the side of my head (remember, I'm 6'6" so this won't matter to most people, but still) maybe within 1.5" (on my LJ this distance is easily 4" if not 5") but the worst is the crossbar behind your head... it basically touches! If I move my head at all, it rubs. In the LJ, there's a good 4" and it's above my head, where the JK has it much lower and behind my head. I suddenly became very worried about ever having one for fear of being in an accident with the rollbar there.
I pointed this out to the salesman and he mentioned ratcheting the seat down (there's a lever to move the seat up and down). I tried, but it was already in it's lowest position. I'm guessing no one on the design team was over 6'1"
Needless to say, I was seriously dissappionted, I thought I'd have MORE room in the WIDER, LONGER 4-door, but that sure ain't the case.
I'd probably get one for Kate to drive, but I wouldn't want it to be a DD for me.