• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

My Scrambler is headed in a new direction

Grantshire

Legacy Registered User
Member
City
Richmond
State
VA
Well, here's the deal - my daughter will be driving to school Next year and the Scrambler is slated to be her DD. Her school is 38 miles from the house with 25 of it via the Interstate. The stock 258 is a little tired and gets poor mileage plus she cannot drive a manual so the T5 will have to go as well. So... what is the Best direction to maximize fuel economy?

Like a lot of you I have a few engines and transmissions stashed away but all have their drawbacks. They include:

Built 401 (no way!)
Built 360 (also, no way)
258 with 4.0 head
225 Commando V6
SD33 diesel from tug (see Ted's post)
Chebby 350

Transmissions (autos)
700R4
TF999
TH400
TF727

By my calculations the SD33 offers the best fuel economy but will require regearing to 5.38 and a 700R4 to have any kind of power. The Scrambler has 4.10's now and any OD transmission will probably require steeper gears.

I could also put a different drivetrain in (as in a more modern FI setup) but which one will get me into the mid 20's for fuel economy?

I have the opportunity to buy bio diesel from the farmer where we live at about $.50 less than gasoline so that makes a diesel a little more attractive.

Which way should I go?
 
Best MPG wise and stability wise would be a 5.3/4.8 Chevy with a 4L60E.

Just need to hunt for a totaled pickup that you can get everything from.

A little less up front money but less MPG but still decent would be a 305/350 or 4.3 out of a chevy half ton with a 4l60E in it. That TBI is bone simple to put in and figure out. Downside might be that engine is old enough to need a rebuild. But the upfront cost is less.

If you can find one and can get it in for her. The 5.3 and Automatic would be the nicest package.

But a 4.3 TBI could be a close second if you are looking to keep tire size reasonable.


Carl
 
Vote #3 for the 5.8 or 4.3 with a 4l60e. I chose that combo for mileage and power, with 4.10's you should have no problem with 33" tires.

Super8 had the 5.3/4l60e/4.56/37" combo and posted once that he got 27 mpg on the highway.

Sold me on the combo. Plus, after working with the Gen3 LS engines, I really like them. I think they're easier than a gen1 SBC!
 
another option would be to get her a honda civic with an automatic,they get 35 miles per gallon ,a new set of tires are less that $300.00,and you wont have every boy at school calling your house wanting to go out with your daughter[you know she would be the coolest kid in school with that scrambler and a V-8]just my 2 cents :cool:
 
Glad to see you aren't trying the 4cylinder route. I have driven an AMC 150...no real problems; however, exact same gas mileage as the 258 in our Jeeps. Personally, I would just do a quick rebuild on your engine and teach her how to drive a stick. Manual transmissions tend to get better mileage and the 258 is a long lasting engine. Would probably end up costing less in the long run anyway (and the 1-3mpg savings you would get from a different engine / transmission combination would get eaten up in the up-front costs and take years to make up).
 
Thanks for all the input guys and it is not an easy decision for several reasons. While the decision is not final (nor will be until I have actually purchased the donor) but here is where I think I am heading...

For several reasons I will be going diesel. I have a 6.2 with a NV4500 in my M715 and love it. The power is good, especially when you consider a 230 was stock, and it gets darn good mileage. Checking around with a few of my fellow Jeepers I think a 6.2 with a 700R4 in a Scrambler will get 28-30 mpg (know of two people getting 28 in heavier 4x4's) and have plenty of pep for the interstate. A 6.2 can criuse all day long at 1800 rpms without straining or lugging the engine. Another factor in leaning heavily toward a diesel is the availability of bio from the farm I sit in the middle of at a much cheaper price than gas.

Still in the research stage but I will keep everyone informed on the progress.:thumbsup:
 
6.2 now your talking,I had the same set up in a half ton chevy truck 6.2 700r4 with 3.42 gears and it was sweet on the mileage and had plenty of power unless it was towing,and is really close in size to a small block chevy.
 
Shoot truck a call.

He has at least one Blazer up there of the CUCV varitey with the 6.2 in it.

You might be able to get some sort of deal from him on that. I know that he has been sitting on one for a while.



Carl
 
Shoot truck a call.

He has at least one Blazer up there of the CUCV varitey with the 6.2 in it.

You might be able to get some sort of deal from him on that. I know that he has been sitting on one for a while.



Carl

Where is Truck anyway? I posted the "Here Truck..." thread to rib him a bit about the military 38.5 XL's and he never responded. I know he wanted/needs a set and I thought he would post a response or send me a PM but nothing!
 
Might be headed of to the sandbox. I remember him saying something like that before.

You know those Secret Squirles though they cannot talk before they leave. try a PM and see if he gets it.


Carl
 
Richard,

6.2 will work great. I know you want civie, but I have an extra military 6.2 or two. Be careful on the 700r4. They have problems behind the 6.2 unless built to with stand the torque. Even stock ones behind 6.2s had issues. If you decide you don't need overdrive I have th400s from behind 6.2s the hold up well. At the rate you do work and I do work you will get this done long before I get the 6.2 in mine that has been sitting for a while.

Truck
 
Richard I'd really be interested in how this turns out also. If you do it will you take lots of pictures? Thanks.

Truck... other than the truck around it, whats the difference?
 
Last edited:
Conversion

Richard: way too exotic for a DD. Why not a mild 360 or a 304 ( I have one for you) and a 999 auto with the d300. For the mileage you are talking an oil burner would not save that much money to justify the added fabrication hassle. Heck the 304 is a bolt in. I bet that a well sealed 304 2 bbl in this would get mid 20's for sure and still not be heavy, smokey or boring.
 
Richard: way too exotic for a DD. Why not a mild 360 or a 304 ( I have one for you) and a 999 auto with the d300. For the mileage you are talking an oil burner would not save that much money to justify the added fabrication hassle. Heck the 304 is a bolt in. I bet that a well sealed 304 2 bbl in this would get mid 20's for sure and still not be heavy, smokey or boring.

While I don't have a 304, I have several engines on hand I could use ranging from a 225 odd-fire to a built 401. If my daughter gets it and I stay with a gas engine I will go the GM route with a 4L60e or 700R4, already have the adapter for the 300. However, my M715 has a 6.2 and I love it, moves the truck nicely while getting great fuel mileage. I also like the simplicity of the non asperated diesels without all the electronic crap. A 700R4 would get awesome mileage on the highway.

No decisions yet but I have a few other options in the works.
 
Back
Top