• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Noodle toaster: different size tires on locked axle

Duffman said:
I just read your last post- and thats what I was trying to imply. There just has to be greater F*d*(cos theta) which would not be completely 90 degrees as the tire and road are not in a vaccuum....LOL

Yes, but my argument isn't that the additional drag is what causes the extra force (I'm still ignoring any additional drag from the flatter tire), but purely the distance from the axle to where the force is acting. This was my initial thinking when I first thought about this.

BUT, I can't reconcile that with the fact that the same amount of tread has to pass under the axle (regardless of the force needed) and therefore they must rotate the same amount, hence no unlocking in the diff.

If we're talking about a not truly FLAT tire, but maybe just a 33 aired down to the same height as a 31 (that's only 1" difference at the ground) like in the original post, I don't see where you'd see THAT much more drag really...
 
I was brielfy thinking about Kepplers Law on elliptical orbits, and Boyles (?) Law of gases, but I really cant think of anything else crafty enuff to put down. If you can or do come up with some other varible thats been left out I'd love to read about it.
I just keep thinking about the battle of the minds on the old Star Trek b/t Spock and Bones- Dammit Jim, I'm a doctor not a physicist/engineer...
 
airing it down makes no difference...the lenght of tread around the circumference is the same and the distance traveled by that tire is the same per revolution...althought the tire will shrink slightly from airing it down..but not enough to keep the locker from ratcheting...

...if you are interrested in eliptical curves..you should check out Wiles' use of the Taniyama conjecture, as it applies to eliptical curves and the corresponding modular forms, in his solution to Fermat's last theorm....very good toilet reading..lol
 
the way to think of this problem is that the top of the tire that is not flat moves the same distance as it always did...so unless the tire is slipping ...then by continuity..the bottom of the tire moves the same distance as the top part...so one can see that airing the tire down only makes a very small practical difference..and near zero theoretical difference...

this turd might require the flush, plunge then flush method
 
Last edited:
Dude, your my hero for the that...:bow: ..I am still tearing I am laughing so hard...Man, this reminds me of those late night camp-out discussions....
 
First hand experience, it does not work. My 74 Suburban had a locked rear. I ran into a bind where my 33 inch tire on the rear got a sidewall gash on the highway. I had a 31" spare that would have caused some problem but not bad. We mounted it and it would not hold air. It leaked all around the bead do to rust. We found a tire that was about a 28 I would guess. Airing down the 33 actually made it worse. I just need to get the truck off the freeway so We did not go too far but when we got off we air both up tight as we could. This was better because it took the play out of the sidewall. We made it to a place we could keep it till a tire was aquired.

Your dealing with tread lenght and while that may change a little when airing down or up, it does not change enough.
 
Yeah, while I was driving back from a meeting a bit ago I talked myself out of the force argument because the area over which the force from the axle would be applied grows as you deflate the tire, more contact patch, so the force from the axleshaft would have a smaller torque arm, but more area over which to act.

It's a tread length thing and now we have trout's first hand experience... :wave:
 
its rim size all rim size, i know

okay , from experiance on a five i built a few yrs ago , cant remember all the specs but it went like this had 33s stuffed on a rim, got a flat,spare was junk from the wk before had a gash, borrowed a guys tire was a 31 on a bigger rim didnt wrk well blew out locker endlessly, okay had a long distance to go and we were caravaning so borrowed another guys tire was a 31 but on the same rim size as all my other 3, were aired my 33 side down wrked great ,got us all to thinking, so when we got home we put a 33 from my jeep on an different rim (smaller) didnt wrk to well even tried airing up and down in all the variations possible , now we put the 33 on a larger rim that the other side, didnt wrk to well either wether it was aired up or down to match didnt matter, so all in all we were still curiuos so we went back to my original size rims and tried various tire mismatches on them and they wrked fine if you aired em up or down to match it all wrked well till we got into putting anything bigger than a 35 on . so all in all we spent over 24 hrs playing with this and the thry we have wrked up is that its the evolution of the rim kinda like gears and stuff but thats just my fifty cents i think the reason the 35 or above didnt wrk is because this threw off the evolution of the rim due to more tread circum and the 2 more inches in height just coulnt be aired down enough without getting you tank tread theory jay
 
Do you think it would have more to do with the fact that very rarely (if ever) does a tire measure out to be what the spec says? Maybe that 31 and 33 were closer in actual circumference than the two 33s? (Especially if you take wear into account, on a 33" MT, a worn tire could have abouut .5-.75" less diameter I'd guess)

It makes absolutely no sense that the rim size would have anything to do with this. I could be a wooden wagon wheel and still work if the diameters matched...

I'm not saying you didn't see what you saw, I just can't think of any reason the rim would matter.
 
I've just just read this whole thread....why?

I just reread this whole thread and all it's done is verify some long held beliefs about engineers...:crazy:

If you were on the trail and this happened, I would be concerned with what I was gonna do, not so much the why.....Cut the tread off your 33" tire and wrap it around the the 31" tire and secure it with some bailing wire....That would increase the diameter of the 31" tire....Why ask why, just figger something out and get where you need to go....Personally I'd switch the fronts as was suggested earlier....

BTW...What is the relative humidity of the trail you are on?
 
If you aired down the tire, the width of the distance between the lugs gets closer where it contacts the ground because of the flex so your effective diameter has changed. Imagine blowing up a latex glove to 10psi. The distance between the fingers would change from what it would be if it were inflated to 1/8psi. How's that fexplanation from an arm chair engineer?
 
mysunnshine said:
If you aired down the tire, the width of the distance between the lugs gets closer where it contacts the ground because of the flex so your effective diameter has changed. Imagine blowing up a latex glove to 10psi. The distance between the fingers would change from what it would be if it were inflated to 1/8psi. How's that fexplanation from an arm chair engineer?


Your analogy assumes that the wall thickness of a tire will changed when you fill it with air. When you over inflate the glove to make its volume larger, the surface area of the glove increases too. The wall thickness of the glove is reduced as the glove stretches because the extra atoms must come from somewhere. This change is pretty equal because the pressure acts in all directions. The wall thickness of an OVER inflated tire does not change, so you will not get much of an increase in diameter by over inflating a tire.

Math coming:

A 31" tire has a circumference Pi*31" = 97.39" (it travels 0.29" per degree)
A 33" tire has a circumference Pi*31" = 103.67" (it travels 0.27" per degree)

If you cut a piece of string equal to the circumference of a 31" tire you can not wrap it completely around a 33" tire unless you somehow fold the tread in on itself to eliminate 6" of tread. You can not over inflate a 31" tire to 33" diameter (unless it was made of latex). So the tread length does not change much.

Each axle must rotate an equal # of degrees for the forces on each side of the locker to be equal. A 33" tire must 360deg to travel 103.67". A 31" tire must turn 384deg travel the same distance. Unless one of the tires was on a low friction surface, the forces will not be equal and the locker will ratchet.

How did I do???

Rob
 
If that's the case, take an ATV tire with 1 psi in it and wrap a measuring tape around it. Then add 10psi to it. The diameter will grow nearly 2". An automotive tire will be no diffrerent. It's only limitations is the carcass itself.
 
mysunnshine said:
If that's the case, take an ATV tire with 1 psi in it and wrap a measuring tape around it. Then add 10psi to it. The diameter will grow nearly 2". An automotive tire will be no diffrerent. It's only limitations is the carcass itself.




Wrapping a tape around a tire measures the circumference, not the diameter. I am going to assume you meant circumference. :)

The circumference might change on an ATV tire, but an ATV tire is not the same as a truck tire. An ATV tire has the ability to ballon somewhat due to it's construction, but a truck tire has a limited ability to ballon. I can get a bicycle inner tube to stretch pretty far by applying more air pressure, but that is not a truck tire either.

Under inflating a 33" tire still does not change it into a 31" tire.

Rob
 
been there done that

okay ive been there and done this and me and my buddies piddled with it for two weekends, it had everything to do with the rims, if you dont think then i invite you to put 2 different size rims on your jeep rears with locks and give it a whirl as i did to test the theories for myself and by all means put some wagon wheels on your jeep , if anyone thinks having 2 different size rims on their vehicle doesnt matter than they got no buissness driving on or offroad, peace out jay
 
Things to consider, when you "air down" you are allowing the tire patch (area in contact with the ground) to deform the round shape of the tire which reduces the RADIUS. When you lower the pressure, the supporting effort of the air pressure is reduced with allows the tire to deform. Part flattens out, the parts on either side of this bulge. The circumference has to stay the same just in a different, non-rounded shape.

Case in point, install same size tires on a locked axle. Lower the tire pressure in one tire by 5lbs. it will drive the locker nuts! Same DIAMETER, same CIRCUMFERENCE. Different RADIUS. The arch of the contact patch flattens out which allows for this.
 
3 pages of this and I have read all of the post and I keep asking myself why?

Subaru recommends changing all 4 tires on their vehicles if you get a flat and have to replace on because of the circumference difference and it ruins the transaxle. Most of the local tire retailers won't replace just one tire on a Subaru either because of it.

If that little bit of difference between a new tire and old will wreck vehicle imagine what a 2 or 3" difference will do.
 
No one's saying to try putting tires of different sizes on and run it as is (I realize I should have titled the thread differently now) I was asking in a pinch could you "make" the tires the same size as far as the locker's concerned by airing the big one down.

No one's ruining vehicles or saying anyone should run rims of different sizes, it was a mostly hypothetical (though stouttrout ended up in this situation as he mentioned to get off the highway) trying to think through the options if someone did find themselves in this spot...
 
Back
Top