• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

oil 10w30 or 10w40?

what oil do you use?


  • Total voters
    21
  • Poll closed .
I use the 10-40 because it never really gets cold here. I'd imagine northeners use thinner oil.

If you had the books that they use to write the owner's manual, you'd see that they choose oil based on outside temperature. Some manuals will even have different weights for different temperature ranges. I think my old 7.3 diesel was listed that way. Also, if your motor is well worn, you can step up a weight or 2 to keep the oil pressure up.
 
Last edited:
ryankopecki said:
Also, if your motor is well worn, you can step up a weight or 2 to keep the oil pressure up.

STP!!! Used it plus 50w to pass an e-test in Colorado once and it worked!! That was on my first Scrambler that my wife ran out of oil and threw #6. Got rid of it because it was rusty, it had a little quarter size hole under the "Jeep" on the passenger side. I hate rust :D

I buy castrol 10w40 by the case, use it exclusively.

Paul
 
We've done some testing on motor oils here at the university. Top 3 were chevron dello, shell rotella, and exxon. Bottom was penzoil, yes even below the walmart brand. This was just of conventional oils though, no synthetics. I think I've got the list saved on my computer but I can't find it. Castrol was high on the list though. There were about 100 on it. When I worked at the steel mill, we did a study on motor oils in the trucks. The tops there were shell rotella, exxon, and dello. It was interesting that all the oils held up much better in the cummins and cats than in the detroits. We used exxon because that was the normal supplier for all oils. Also tested with mobile 1 synthetic and found it to be really good stuff, but the extra cost couldn't be justified. It probably extends engine life, but we weren't worried about that because the trucks would be sold before 500K anyway, the motors can't wear out in that time.
 
Ryan,
That would be an interesting list to have. The oils you list on the top are rated by API as CC or CD oils, in other words compression combustion (Diesel). You shouldn't use these in gas engines.

Here's an interesting link that will hopefully take the mystery out of oil selection. Probably more than enough info for the average guy.

http://www.carbibles.com/engineoil_bible.html

Bottom line...Choose quality by the rating system and change often.

Paul
 
mtruckstuff said:
Ryan,
That would be an interesting list to have. The oils you list on the top are rated by API as CC or CD oils, in other words compression combustion (Diesel). You shouldn't use these in gas engines.

Here's an interesting link that will hopefully take the mystery out of oil selection. Probably more than enough info for the average guy.

http://www.carbibles.com/engineoil_bible.html

Bottom line...Choose quality by the rating system and change often.

Paul
Very lengthy, but informative read on everything you wanted to know about oil
 
If you plan on keeping your vehicle for very long, use a good synthetic. I have a Class C mothorhome with a Ford 460 engine. I bought it new in 1993 and used it in my business as well as a tow vehicle for the Scrambler. It now has 290,000 on the odometer with the engine never being touched. It just passed the emissions test that we have in Utah. I use synthetic in all of my vehicles.
 
20w50

I use Castrol, because I did my own test years ago in my motorcycle.
The engine oil also lubes the tranny and washes the clutch. When the oil fails you can feel it in the clutch. Of the oils I tested, Castrol, Valvoline, and Honda Gold label were the only ones that lasted.

20W50 because every thing I have is old and worn. :)

I had a Toyota pu where the PO used straight syn all its life so I continued for awhile, but it tended to leak = expensive. When I tore it down, the engine was clean as a whistle. I wouldn't start with syn late in life.
 
synthetic

i was considering synthetic oil, but i had heard that with a worn engine it could do more harm cleaning the deposits and alowing blow by. not sure on all the reasons.
 
Forgot to mention, I didn't start with synthetic until after 100,000 miles. Do some research, there have been lots of tests that will give you facts, not just someones opinion. Synthetic is the only way to go if you want the maximum life from your engine.
 
I guess, considering the cost, I wouldn't bother if, let's say, my rear main was leaking like a sieve, or my valve cover was washing down the distributor. What synthetics WON"T do is heal anything that's wrong with the engine.

I also wouldn't use synthetic on a new or newly rebuilt engine until it was completely broken in.
 
I like 15w40. I use Castrol, it's CD rated too, but says it's good for gas engines. I can't find that weight in a "gas only" oil, but it gives me decent oil pressure without going too heavy.
 
Back
Top