We've done some testing on motor oils here at the university. Top 3 were chevron dello, shell rotella, and exxon. Bottom was penzoil, yes even below the walmart brand. This was just of conventional oils though, no synthetics. I think I've got the list saved on my computer but I can't find it. Castrol was high on the list though. There were about 100 on it. When I worked at the steel mill, we did a study on motor oils in the trucks. The tops there were shell rotella, exxon, and dello. It was interesting that all the oils held up much better in the cummins and cats than in the detroits. We used exxon because that was the normal supplier for all oils. Also tested with mobile 1 synthetic and found it to be really good stuff, but the extra cost couldn't be justified. It probably extends engine life, but we weren't worried about that because the trucks would be sold before 500K anyway, the motors can't wear out in that time.