• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Optima Batteries

Raven

Legacy Registered User
City
Glen Rose
State
tx
Are the Optima Batteries woth the extra $$? I have been trying to decide if I should buy one of these or not. I have a Warn 8275 winch installed on my 8.

Thanks
SC
 
I think so, I've run several of them and the only one I've been able to kill was a red top with 7-8 years on it, several full discharges/recharges and a couple vehicles. They have gotten much more expensive of late but I think they are a pretty good investment
 
I'd have to agree, an optima is definitely worth it. Mine was decharged and recharged more times than all the other batteries i'd had in the jeep put together. The only reason it died was because someone unsecured it in the battery tray, end result was it on the exhaust manifold resulting in a dead cell. Its also nice that they don't leak, if you roll your jeep you will be happy that you don't have sulfuric acid leaking out......
 
I put a red top Optima in my Cherokee 5 years ago. Done nothing to it since. Still cranks great all winter long. I'd vote yes, it's worth it. On the other hand, I have an Interstate Blem that I paid $25 for 4 years ago in 'Ol Blue with the same record. I guess maybe I'm just lucky.
Paul
 
Thanks for the input guys. I revised my search and found several posts regarding this topic. I went ahead & purchased a yellow top. I might try to set up the dual battery option later on, just too expensive for me right now.

Thanks
SC
 
Another satisfied customer here. Ran the same one in my Suburban for 9 years and the battery was still going strong when I sold the rig.

That being said, somewhere I read some reports that their quality may have suffered in recent years. I should see if I can find it. The one I put in the Jeep 3 years ago hasn't given me any issues, though.
 
I have a red top and a yellow top in my scrambler, a red top and 2 blue tops in my guide boat. YES I think that they are worth the money.

Mike
 
I have heard the same thing about their quality.

Wal-mart has Everstart batteries for like $45 and they have a 3 year warranty. I have had these things last for 5-6 years.

You don't need a gell battery unless you are running a dual set up with the batteries on their sides. If any acid spills out on the trail, just return the battery to wal-mart under their 3 year warranty.
 
I run Die Hards because of my good experience for them. $84 for a seven year with the first four at full coverage is hard to pass up. Usually get six years from them. However, because the jeep is starting to see such sharp angles, I'll be switching it over to a optima next spring. Reason is if it ever does find that critical angle and flop, it'll be one less fluid I have to worry about leaking out.

So, while the decusion is ongoing, which one is the better one to get for a Scrambler with single battery?
 
I put an optima in jeep for the reason about the acid. I'm not worried about a battery dieing from loosing its acid, its just all those things that acid leaks onto. And it kinda goes with my jeep's theme because it was free.
 
At Costco out here in So Cal, a red top Optima is only $105. Gotta love Costco...

Bill
 
That’s interesting, I called the Costco here in Fort Worth & they were no cheaper than the local batteries plus store. When I went in this morning, the red top 900 CCA was 139.00. They told me they would be going up in price sometime this week. I had to go back to get a second for my diesel & they were 169.00! The manager let me have it for 130.00, he told me the order to mark them up came right after I bought the first one this morning.

SC
 
Interesting... I bought mine a couple of months ago... I'll have to check the prices next time I'm in there...

Bill
 
My Costco is stocking the Red, Yellow, and Blue tops. Lots of Marine apps here.

But the Red ones here look different. They have a rectangulat base cast into the plastic, as opposed to carrying the cylinders all the way to the bottom.

I know that is not the old way that the red tops were made. Is this some sort of cheeper version of the typical red top?

Does anybody know. They are expensive and would hate to make a costly mistake. I might just go ahead and get the yellow top anyway.

Carl
 
Carl,
I checked the Optima website and the photos there show the style we're all used to seeing. They have established quite a reputation and I doubt they'd risk it by selling cut-rate products, but you never know. It could just be a design change. If you still wonder, get the battery model number at Costco and go to the Optima website and plug it in.
Paul
 
I've been using Optima red top batteries for many years in my cj8 when we bought the used xj I installed one in it,I read an article that vehicles with a winch should use the Blue Top which is designed for charging & discharging.A know nothing sales rep told me I could use the Red Top for an RV coach battery , he was wrong it went flat but I still got a new replacement w/o charge.
 
got the blue ... works great no problems.. have left the door to the tj open with the dome light on for over 16 hours and it didn't need a jump..
 
My Costco had red tops at $95, I have one in the Scrambler and one in the XJ.

As is mentioned, the battery itself is the last thing I'm worried about in relation to the acid spilling out.

I read a lot on them when I went to get my first one and I came to the opinion that if you're not going to run it down over and over at high load without the engine running, a red top is fine.

My call was between the red and blue, yellow is a deep cycle (despite what they say on their site about it being dual-urpose) and shouldn't be run in a mainly start-charge cycle that most street-driven rigs see IMHO.
 
"My call was between the red and blue, yellow is a deep cycle (despite what they say on their site about it being dual-urpose) and shouldn't be run in a mainly start-charge cycle that most street-driven rigs see IMHO."

This is interesting as I bought the yellow top for my jeep, taking in consideration that I have winch. I just read your post & called the guys I bought mine form and they told me that I bought the right battery for my aplication....

Bigwalton, don't take me wrong on this. I'm merley posting what I have been told. And at this point I guess since I already have the yellow top I'll just stick with it and see how it goes.

I wish I could have bought mine for 95$....

SC
 
Back
Top