• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Optimas don't like me....

John N

Addicted....Ex-SOA VP
Lifetime Member
SOA Member
City
Rockville
State
VA
8 or 9 years ago I got my first Optima, a red top. Within a week, it was no good and had to be replaced under full warrenty. That one lasted 5 or 6 years, but I had to keep charging it to get it work that long....decent, I suppose for a life on that one. 2 years ago, I gave up on the red top and got a new yellow top, I thought the yellow was a better choice with the winch and use it gets. The first one , had to be replaced within 6 months (36 month replacement on these at Sam's Club). The next one lasted less than 19 months, I kept it in that long, but it was dead. I got it replaced today, it was supposed to have 750 CCA and only had 91CCA...I took it off the charger at home and it barely cranked the engine; it wouldn't even start the engine after I got there.

My charging system is fine. I have 3 constant drain items, the Howell FI computer, the radio memory and the clock. I guess I just need to drive it more to keep the battery alive, but I thought these where supposed to be good for this type of use.

Anyone else have this type of issue with Optimas?
 
I just pulled my red top out of my truck last month that was 7yrs old. It was just starting to crank a little slow on the cold mornings. Other than that, I have had no problems with it even with it sitting for 2-3 weeks in the meantime. Now I'll use it as a test battery at the shop.
 
batteries

John ive had 3 Optima batteries and all 3 failed just out of warnnity (36 months) will never buy another one.........I'm running an Orileys gel cell............on my 3rd one in 6 years( however i do alot of heavy winching with my rig doing recovery for W.E.Rock several times a year also).........but they have replaced all 3 without questions for free so i figure as long as they will keep giving me free batteries i will keep using them............They did the same thing for my diesel tow rig replaced both batteries for free even tho they where 5 years old think their top of the line gel cells have a 84 month replacement warnnity i maybe wrong on that but might be worth checking in to. I have heard alot of good on the oddessy batteries but can't make my self lay out $300.00 for them.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the warning, John. I have been tempted to buy an Optima for my '81 Scrambler, but I don't think I'll consider it, now. Sorry to hear about your problems. Few things are more frustrating than battery problems in a Jeep on cold mornings.
 
i've had a red top without issues for a number of years. would not have a problem with buying another one when this one ever gives up the ghost.
 
I've had both my yellow tops for around 10+ years; one in my ZJ w/ winch and modest amplified stereo, the other in my '75 w/ winch. I've drained both completely flat dead 1-3 times each throughout the years, brought both back to life by jumping to start then drive a good 50+ mile trip. Ask and I'll tell you the secret of the myth about "once you drain them they're dead forever."

I've never had any issues w/ mine, I will buy another for my Scrambler, J20, and '47 when I win the lottery.
 
Mine works fine for me as well, going on 5 years and I have lete the Jeep sit for months at a time while connected. I throw it on a charger for a freshen up once in awhile and thats it. I like them.
 
I bought a yellow top for my TJ about 8 years ago and it was a great battery. Drained it twice and it came back both times and was still going strong when I sold it. However, my CJ had a one year old red top in it when I bought it and the guy I got it from was keeping it on a battery tender every night. When I brought it home it would die if I let it sit for longer then 3 days. I thought I had a bad drain on the battery but I couldn't find any. I took the battery in to a local Battery Outfitters store and they tested it and said it had a bad cell in it and had very low CCAs. They warrentied it for me and gave me a brand new red top. So far no problems but we will see. I've heard that since they moved their manufacturing to Mexico that the quality has really dropped off.
 
Back
Top