spankrjs: that job reeks of bad prep. The liner lifted, water got under it...Rust.
A few years ago I did my TJ (RIP) in Herculiner cause the top was leaking and the carpet kept getting soaked. I did eventually replace the top, but that's not what this thread is about. I bought a decent undercoating spray gun and sprayed it in nice and thick. Of course, I spent a lot of time doing prep work before I started. I spent a few days removing stuff, cleaning stuff, masking stuff up and scuffing up the floor with scotch-brite pads. I didn't dilute the herculiner down with anything and I got (almost) three coats down out of a single gallon can.
You will get sick of sanding.
The instructions said something about removing all the seam sealer, but I just roughed the seam sealer up a bit with scotch-brite and hit it with xylene before spraying, just like the rest of the area I was spraying, and had no problems with the Herculiner coming up from the seam sealer.
The results were pretty satisfactory. The texture was nice and grainy. I had a bit of pooling in some of the ribs in the footwells, but I wasn't too concerned about it.
Tip: if you want to keep the bolt holes clear, foam earplugs work very well.
After having the Jeep with the tub lined for around two years, here's what I observed. I noticed that the rubber granules tended to wear down pretty fast in the high-traffic areas (front footwells) and fade a bit, but I never noticed any cracking, peeling or chipping of the Herculiner. The actual finish seemed damn near indestructible, but the traction-friendly rubber stuff wore down pretty fast.
I solved the wear problem by getting some Lloyd's front rubber floor mats. They never moved around and did a great job of keeping the rest of the rubber in the Herculiner from wearing flat.
Would I do it again? Now that I've got the tools and the know-how, yes...And if I get this unfinished '81 CJ8 project from someone for the low, low cost of $0, I probably will Herculine the tub again.