• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

What's the best repro tub and why?

What's the best repro tub?

  • Aluminum

    Votes: 50 36.8%
  • Steel

    Votes: 74 54.4%
  • Fiberglass

    Votes: 9 6.6%
  • Kevlar

    Votes: 3 2.2%

  • Total voters
    136
Truck said:
NF,

Do you have aluminum? If you do I would love to see it. I'm going to be in Boston next week.

Truck

:cool:

Yes and OK.

E-Mail me at n1mau@gis.net and I will give you my address and phone.

Let me know when you will be here and if you will have any time.
Also, I live North of Boston.

A trip to the sticks.

Later,
 
aluminum

I have already installed a aluminum tub, maybe I a biased. It is easily on of the better improvements we have done to any of our 4 jeeps. When I learn how I will try to post some pictures of the swap.
 
if i spend 3 grand it will be for a tube chassis....for a crawler...if i was restoring...i would go steel..i think
 
I like aluminum

I am in the process of building an aluminum bobbed 8. I bought the Matkins Deluxe body. The floor areas are built very similar in look to an original steel tub. All the major mounting holes are predrilled and some have cage nuts installed. The firewall is also very similar to the original and reinforced around the brake booster area. Some of the welded areas were a little funky, but nothing major. Mine is coated inside and out with Durabak so it wasn't an issue for me. I live in Ca. and ordered mine in December. Price with shipping was just a few hundred dollars more then what JP had quoted me. I figured that was worth the time I would have spent locating and drilling all those holes. At the time, Matkins sold their "basic" flat panel style tub for several hundred less than JP. I'm not sure, but I think they both get the flat panelled tub out of Canada from a place called Aqualou???? As far as weight, I was able to unload it from the shipping frame by myself. Due to the size needed help lifting onto a rolling frame though. I am very happy overall with my aluminum tub. Good luck!
 
Getting ready to order...

From what I have seen this is the gist:
Steel will be slightly more "original looking," whatever that means.

Aluminum is more durable, um, OK.

I won't do fiberglass as I have seen fiberglass parts on the trail and not been impressed.

So here are my questions:
With an aluminum tub, what do you do with electrical grounds?
Since it has to be thicker than steel for strength, how are the seams?
What about fatigue, the curse of aluminum?

I am leaning toward steel because I think it will be easier on the install, but also down the road for a vehicle that will see a lot of DD duty and some moderate off-road.
 
I'm glad this thread got bumped up again. I'm on the final leg of my '82 Scrambler project, which has a 4WD Hardware fiberglass tub. As I mentioned earlier, it'll be a Summer daily driver, with some occasional light wheeling. I went with the 4WDH tub because of price & local availability.

If I had it to do again, I would definitely *NOT* use this tub. I have been less than impressed with the install process (and I'm a real detail guy...not someone who just slaps stuff together). I don't have time to go into too much detail here, but it's a series of things rather than one specific issue. I really wish that I had spent the extra money for a Willys-Overland steel tub, or a JP aluminum tub.

Craig

Click here for a photo of my Scrambler (aparently, you can't post pics on a poll thread).
 
not sure yet

The frame is being jigged, but still have yet to decide on the body. Matkins likes the aluminum. Might have found a decent steel one locally, not sure how much work it will need. I'm still concerned about how the aluminum will fatigue or how easily it will dent.
 
After looking over my Matkins body I'm not gonna worry about the fatigue thing for many many years. As far as denting, I'm thinking same or better than steel.... good luck, sounds like your doing your homework :)
 
Unfortunately I won’t have to serious think about tub replacement for a while. I have plenty of mechanical things to do before she gets to look pretty but while you guys are on the subject I’m wondering if an aluminum or a steel tub will easily match up with a stock full hard top. I’ve heard that fiberglass tubs are narrower and won’t match with the hardtop.

Also what do the firewalls look like on the aluminum tubs? Do think it would be a nightmare to convert them to RHD? “Lost” did a nice job of swapping the firewall on his new steel tub but it looked like a big job. Is an aluminum firewall a flat blank canvas ready to be drilled where ever I like?
 
The JPOffroad/Aqualu body is pretty much a straight panel that need to be drilled for everything. There is a cut out to allow the use of a rear distributor engine like a small block chevy. So that could be a bonus.

Let me know if you need picks by PM. Mine is out in the back yard and not yet mounted. It was a used body so there are already mounts that have been drilled. But if you ignore them it will give you a good idea.

There are picks of the firewall on www.jpoffroad.com too.

Carl
 
Willys Overland Tub

I just finished my re-build using a WO steel tub, I cut the "Jeep" out of my old tub and welded it into the WO tub. For the most part everything fit good, except for the Hard top and Role bar. The bulkhead for the hard top had to move forward about 10 to 12 mm and I cant quite get the hardtop and the doors to seal, there is a gap just behind my head where the window curves around. for the role bar in the bed one of the holes on each pad don't line up, so I am going to have to drill to get a bolt in there. It also looks like when they (the manufacturer) does the welds it is by hand and they don't spread the heat around to good so there are some spots that are wavy and need a bit more filler. Other than that it was a well built and fairly easy to work with, I would recommend it.

Mike
 
i just got my 4wd hardware fiberglass tub yesterday, and the quality is first class, carbon fiber and steel reinforced firewall, seat,rollbar, and body mounts. super thick fiberglass panels. only problem i found is that the cab divider needs 1/2 inch trimmed out of it because of the thickness of the floor. and im allittle itchy right now. i would have gone aluminum but for the extra 2 grand i would rather buy more parts like lockers, axles, tires, a weeks worth of fuel:mad: exc.
 
I know that this is an old thread, but I'm new here and I just wanted to add my .02. If it were me, I'd use a steel tub and here's why:

Aluminum doesn't rust - of corse not, rust is by definition Iron Oxide, but aluminum does corrode. And living in a place where salt is used on the roads, aluminum will corrode very quickly. I'm an aircraft mechanic working on business jets that come to us from all over the world, and we see some pretty nasty corrosion on some of them.

Fiberglass and Kevlar - no corrosion problems, and they won't become brittle at cold temperatures, but I don't like the wood supports that they use inside. Also, in my experiance, fiberglass and kevlar both have issues with the layers seperating. There is a term for it, but I can't think of it right now. Also, proper repairs, if necessary, can be problematic.

Steel has its draw backs, but it is easy to repair, and when properly protected, will last a very long time before it rusts away.

Just my thoughts on the subject.
 
The Big questions are, what your going to use it for? and where your from? I've had steel and glass. I'll never go back to a steel tub again. The major difference is no corrosion and the insulation factor. My glass tub is so much warmer in 20'f weather than my factory YJ tub was. The best glass tubs are from 4wd Hardware. My CJ-7's is one of the first editions. It's still going strong and it's been on the rig since the 80's. I have a 03' model on my CJ-8 and it's great. If you get one and have it LineX'd on inside and underside it ought to be about bullet proof. :D
 
Aluminum is stronger

Upon tearing down my jeep after the recent incident, I found that the Aluminum body is most likely the strongest and potentially lightest body availabe. If I had had a fiberglass body, it would have fractured and shattered at all body to frame mount locations, the tranny would have torn through the floor boards, and the tube fenders would have removed the firewall. A steel body in my senario would have ripples in the body panels and the body mounts would be warped. The only damage my aluminum body sustained was where the hardware for the tube fenders popped through the body, and a little deflection in the tranny tunnel lip where the tranny made contact. Now I just need to build myself an aluminum frame.........:rolleyes:
 
Antique thread reply...Just my opinion after owning and building 3 (and I'm sure Kevlar will be similar to Fiberglass) :

1) Matkins Aluminum
2) 4wd Fiberglass
3) Repro Tub (and having viewed Willys 1st hand)

They all pale in comparison to an original OEM tub for ease of reassembly and correctness.

I'd rather spend more for something in neglected shape thats rust free than build new again.

The new tubs stink for simple things like seat belts, fender nuts, seat mounting, roll bars...etc, etc...

Even if its neglected, it's going to offer you more donor parts that you will need and you will have more when it's done...unless you are building it just to wheel...

If built for wheeling, I'd go aluminum

Rudy
 
Rudy,

I heard that Matkins had gone out of business. Is he still arround?

Something to think about.


Carl
 
Matkins was barely in business when he was in business! LoL

Very unreliable and sketchy. My buys from him had pretty happy endings but I bet it was 50/50.
 
I asked because his web site is gone. And last I heard he was not answering the phone and his e-mail box was full.

Guess that those tubs from him are gone too.

How are those tubs from Willis/Overland. I had heard decent things about them but never got to work on one up close. I just know that I hate chasing
rust issues on original sheet metal.

Wish I could get one of those Philippine Stainless bodies.

Carl
 
I, too would like some first hand comments on W-O 's tub as I am just about
done building a frame and I'm thinking in about January getting a Repli-tub.
Thanks
 
Back
Top