I know that this is an old thread, but I'm new here and I just wanted to add my .02. If it were me, I'd use a steel tub and here's why:
Aluminum doesn't rust - of corse not, rust is by definition Iron Oxide, but aluminum does corrode. And living in a place where salt is used on the roads, aluminum will corrode very quickly. I'm an aircraft mechanic working on business jets that come to us from all over the world, and we see some pretty nasty corrosion on some of them.
Fiberglass and Kevlar - no corrosion problems, and they won't become brittle at cold temperatures, but I don't like the wood supports that they use inside. Also, in my experiance, fiberglass and kevlar both have issues with the layers seperating. There is a term for it, but I can't think of it right now. Also, proper repairs, if necessary, can be problematic.
Steel has its draw backs, but it is easy to repair, and when properly protected, will last a very long time before it rusts away.
Just my thoughts on the subject.