• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Tires...something that works good, but quiet

Scott_P

Legacy Registered User
Gold Member
City
Benzonia
State
MI
Long trips are killing me in the Scrambler when it comes to noise, especially tire noise. I'm talking like a 4 - 8 hr trip, mostly hwy to my off-road secret camping spots in the UP of MI. I currently run BFG MT's (the classic tread) and would like to find something comparable, but quieter. Who's running what, and how do you like them. While from a practical sense most mileage is on road, I still like to think I need something that will handle a little mud. BFG AT's have been good in the past, but was hoping for something a little more aggressive looking.

Good Year Dura-Tracs?

Rate your favorites for:

Noise
Snow
Rocks
Mud

Thanks!
 
I am a huge fan of BFG MT and ATs...I am about to make a 2000 mile trip in my Scramber and just mounted some 31" BFG ATs.. now as far as the MTs, I think they are the quietest aggressive tire out there...I have them on my XJ in 33"...super quiet. Seriously, they are. For a MT. Two tires I would STAY AWAY FROM for noise reasons: Love the look, but Pro Comp MTs...noisiest tire I have ever had. Have them now on a CJ in 32" And also Goodyear Wranger MT. although I dont think they make those anymore.
 
Yep, I've been happy w/the BFG's too. Maybe I'm getting old....it seems the trip "to" is tolerable, but the trip home is rough! I have a set of 1/2 used 33x10.5 AT's off my old Waggy I am considering finding a set of rims for...

I agree on the "old" Good Year MTR's. I ran a set on my CJ-7....terrible for noise and wear.
 
I have BFG MTs on my Scrambler and BFG ATs on my '06 Land Cruiser. I have a little over 20,000 miles on the ATs and was at Discount Tire just yesterday to have them rotated. Since the Land Cruiser weighs so much (over 5,500), I've been really good about rotating every 5,000. They put the tread depth gauge on them and said "Wow. These are like new - there's almost zero wear" The BFGs are quieter and more comfortable than the Michelin Latitudes HPs (a "luxury SUV tire").

If interested, I'll shoot a pic of the tread - to show the 20,000+ wear
 
Have you looked at the Goodyear Wrangler Duratrac's? They are a slightly more agressive all-terrain tire than the BFG all-terrains and receive very good reviews in snow/ice/dirt/sand...are moderately good in mud and rocks. One downfall is sidewall resistance to punctures when doing rock-climbing, but they werent intended for that type of off-roading.
 
I drove across the country to Moab and back on BFG KM2 MT's, no complaints:thumbsup: They work well on rock, mud, sand, dirt, rain, I don't know about snow or ice, that stuff doesn't exist where I live:D

I have Good Year Duratracs on my 05 Rubicon. They are very quiet/smooth, and work well off road. However, the sidewalls are kind of weak. The sidewalls on mine are a little "chewed up" from the few times they have been on rocks. No tears or any bad damage, but they are missing some small pieces of rubber off the sidewalls. They do work great on the road, wet roads they are perfect, in the mud they are as good as the old MTR's that they replaced IMO, pretty good tire. I have close to 30,000 miles on them, they still look like new, all the siping is still present on all the treadblocks:thumbsup:
 
Thanks for all the input guys! I have been eyeballing the Dura-Tracs...so far I have not heard much bad about them....
 
I am about to make a 2000 mile trip in my Scramber and just mounted some 31" BFG ATs..

Would that be to Silver Lake Sand Dunes in August??? I hope to make it down for the day, but this is our busy season for land surveying!
 
I HATE Goodyear MTRs... garbage garbage GARBAGE!!! way too LOUD and wear out way too fast...

BFG ATs... great tire, long wearing, quiet, but not aggressive enough for anything besides asphalt.

BFG MT KM2s... Best tire I have ever had, quiet (compared to any other MT i've had), long wearing, good looks and aggressive for everything I do.

BFGMT (old style)... same as above except louder than the KM2... upgrade to the KM2. nuff said.. :D
 
I have antique BFG MTs on the Scrambler, and it depresses me that I can't get them again.
I'm running the General Grabber AT2 on the Rubicon. A couple of mags seemed to prefer them over the BFG AT in those annual comparison articles, and they cost a bit less than the BFG. I've been very happy with them so far, though I do miss the more aggressive MT look. They are quiet, but they are very durable. I've banged around Rausch Creek a few times, and they have held up very well while also getting solid grip on the rocks and gravel. I doubt they would do as well in good ol' Pine Barrens black mud, but I knew that when I bought them.
 
Last edited:
Pro Comp AT's.
Great wearing tire, quiet, good on wet roads, snow (what little they saw in North Alabama), rocks ... meh - maybe better options, and mud - again, meh - maybe better options but decent.
 
Would that be to Silver Lake Sand Dunes in August??? I hope to make it down for the day, but this is our busy season for land surveying!

The land that needs surveyed will always be there.
The sand is always shifting.
In a hundred years there will be no more lake.
Do not miss an opportunity to commune with the sand.
Sandblast 2012 is going to be epic.

Oh yeah, I like BFG ATs, too.
 
On my Scrambler, I love the BFG KM2 MT's. I ran the BFG AT's in winter and used to think they were the ultimate all-around tire. That was until we put a set of the Dura-Tracs on our Tahoe. They are amazing. We';ve since sold the Tahoe, but my daughter put the Dura-Tracs on her Sequoia. It does great in mud, sand, pavement, and especially snow. I think it would climb a tree if you put snow on it. If they made them in a 37" tire I'd have them on my Scrambler now.
 
So your looking for a decent set of MT/AT with little to no road noise...Personally I would never touch the BF M/Ts again period but thats just me I have had a set and so did a friend and they just were crap we had blow outs and had very bad luck with them..I have heard they are good but thats just my opinion and expiernce. We ride the tires hard out here...

So over all my favorite A/T If I had to go that route would have to be the Hankook RF10...Great Tire I have a set on my S10 Blazer 235/75/R15 and Personally I love them...I have had it up to its doors in water and kept on trucking not a problem,Snow was not a problem/ They are about average for any A/T on Rock and Mud but I have seen the Rf10s do a dang good job at Mud and Water lol.
Road noise is very little. I dont know if you run with a stereo or not but I barely hear any noise off the RF10

As for Mud Terrains...

Herclues Trail Diggers 33 12.50 16 Love them. I have a set on my K10 and they are the best dang MT I have had besides Mickey Thompson MTZ ...The trail digger has some road noise but it aint bad at all one of the quietest ones I have had in a very long time. To compare them to the Km2s I couldnt tell ya. But over all I was very impressed with this tire...I have had it in some seriously sticky spots with clay based soil and it performed very well..self cleaning was excellent..

If your looking at M/T can not go wrong the trail diggers or the Mickey MTZs.

A/T Check out Hankook hell I have heard the Hankook Mt is an amazing tire.
 
I now have BFG ATs on my Scrambler and they work fine for what I want; I cant hear the tires over the wind noise in the cab anyway and they are fine for the wheeling I do which tends to be dry. I know they arent great in snow or mud though, in fact I had a very early set of non radials years ago and they were terrible in the snow, but that was a looong time ago. I recently put a set of Falken Rocky Mountains on my Dodge though after the 3rd of four Treadwrights blew out and they are silent! silent and smooth but I havent had them off the pavement and likely wont other than very briefly
 
Would that be to Silver Lake Sand Dunes in August??? I hope to make it down for the day, but this is our busy season for land surveying!

Yes that would be the place. Then up into Canada and down to Niagra and into butler pa for the bantam fest. All from the right side and trusting an ol 258 with 260000 kilometers. Glad I have my triple a card and a ton of extra parts :bacon:
 
The land that needs surveyed will always be there.
The sand is always shifting.
In a hundred years there will be no more lake.
Do not miss an opportunity to commune with the sand.
Sandblast 2012 is going to be epic.

Oh yeah, I like BFG ATs, too.

:rotfl:
 
Thanks again guys...

The comments on the KM2's I find intriguing...I am surprised they are quieter than the MT's...must be the computer designed tread!

On the General Grabber AT2's, I agree, quiet and great in the snow, I have a set on my work truck and have been very happy w/them.

No more lake in 100 yrs?! What have you learned?
 
Just went on a mini-vacation in my daughter's Sequoia with the DuraTrac's. Lots of highway driving...quiet as can be. I think they're my new favorite tire.
 
Back
Top