• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Calling all Dana 60 & 14 Bolt Experts: Need some help/advice on axle upgrade.

Grantshire

Legacy Registered User
Member
City
Richmond
State
VA
Well here is the short version, upgrading axles on Goose, my 69 Commando trail rig. It currently has a narrowed WT FSJ Dana 44 SOA in front and FSJ centered 44 in back geared 3.73 and both have Powerlocks. I run heavy military Michelin XZL 39" tires and am on borrowed time with the Dana 44's. Don't want to wait until I break something because I will swap these axles under my Scrambler.

I am upgrading the front to a narrowed GM Dana 60 with 35 spline inner and outter shafts with a E-locker and 4.56 gears (do not want to outboard springs to run full width). My front 60 is already geared 4.56 and has high steer, also, I have two spare sets of 4.56 gears for a Dana 60. It is the rear axle I am undecided on and looking for some advice. I have several possible candidates on hand and they are outlined below:

Dana 60-2: Stock setup with 4.10 gears. Case is damaged from carrier internals exploding (not me) but fixable. Shafts are massive band would need rebuild and disc brake conversion. Would also narrow one side to center pinion and get WMS/WMS to around 62". Would need the 4.56 gear change and some type of locker (have a RichmondII could use).

Ford Dana 60 FF: Picked this up a few years back. It is 4.10 with Lincoln locker. WMS/WMS is 66" but I have Dodge aluminum rims with 6.5" BS (this is older Ford rear so same bolt pattern as Dodge). Could run as is until it breaks then upgrade to 1.5" shafts. Could use one of my spare 4.56 gear set and Richmond locker with new shafts.

14 Bolt #1: 4.56 with Detroit locker. Currently still has massive drum brakes but 14 bolt #2 below has been converted to disc so could swap them over. 67" WMS/WMS.

14 bolt #2: 4:56 gears with Richmond locker and as stated above it has disc brakes. Also, 67" WMS/WMS.

First, remember this is a Commando so frame is comparable to a Scrambler (meaning light). The 14 bolts seem over kill to me and I know they hang low. I should add that I am considering modifying the hubs to stay 6 on 5.5" so I don't have to buy new wheels and have the tires moved. The 60-2 could easily be redrilled to this lug pattern, not sure about the Ford. 6 lug hubs are available for the 14 bolt but they are major bucks.

Ssssoooooooooo... Opinions, advice, experiences, etc, please! I only want to do this once and I have no experience with either rear 60's or 14 bolts in a trail rig.
:shrug:
Richard
 
What size wheel? 15 or 16 or larger, and which caliper set up are you planning on using? I run 15" wheels and about the only thing you can get to fit is a chevy half ton rotor and caliper. I vote for the 60 but a 14 bolt can be shaved to get some extra ground clearance they both are strong and don't think you can go wrong with either set up, gears and lockers are more limited with the 14 bolt if you ever did decided to regear at a later time so check into that.
 
Sorry, forgot to say my wheels are 16"x 8". Measured shafts this werkend and the 60-2 has them all beat in diameter, they neck down to 1.5" & are 35 spline. I have most of a third 14 bolt and its shafts are 1.31" & 30 spline. Was surprised because thought they were all 1.5".

Have one other option forgot to mention:

Dana 70: Stock CJ10A rear axle, 4.88, Govlock, 77" wms/wms, giant drum brakes. Would have to be narrowed both sides and either regeared to 4.56 or change front 60 to 4.88.
 
Don't have any good advice, but I'll be watching this. My Scrambler knows how to put the hurt on the Waggy 23, so I'll be upgrading in the future.

Wouldn't it just be more cost effective just to buy new wheels with the 8 bolt pattern?
 
Wouldn't it just be more cost effective just to buy new wheels with the 8 bolt pattern?

With the exception of my M715 all my Jeeps are 6 on 5.5" so I can swap wheels and tires between them. If I go 8 lug I will lose this ability on my trail rig and I really don't want to (I swap 35" BFG AT's on it when I take to the beach).

Cheapest route is 14 bolt #2 with the Dodge rims I already have, just the wheel mount & balance cost. The 14 bolt is a big honking axle though. I could have it shaved (can't do that my self) but I keep eyeing those 1.5" 35 spline shafts on the 60-2!
 
I vote for the 60-2 ( so my j-4000 can live on)

Are you going to put the scrambler axles in your daughters new rig ?
 
I'm not a 60 expert but I narrowed a Dana 60 out of a 3/4 Ton Ford van back in the early 80's. It was a offset design and narrowed the long side to the same length as the short and used short side axles. I don't remember the spline count or shaft diameters, but I've used this axle with a CJ7 on 39" TSL's and detroits and currently under my commando with 38" boggers (soon to be under my Scrambler with 36" ? and never broken it (knock on wood). The WMS is approximately 59"
Below is a photo with this axle mounted on my commando to give you an idea on width.


P1010356.jpg
 
14 bolts are pretty cheep to build, but you have to be able to do a lot of that work yourself.

The kit or at least the tabs to mount the caliper is pretty cheep so that conversion to disks is easy. Check out the build tips in that issue of Crawl. Doing a rear is very easy. Also the cost of a Detroit fir it is about half of the one for the Dana 60.

If you look into shaving it you can get more clearance than the Dana 60 will have.

I still have that 9.5" 14 bolt down here if you want it too.


Carl
 
14 bolts are pretty cheep to build, but you have to be able to do a lot of that work yourself.

The kit or at least the tabs to mount the caliper is pretty cheep so that conversion to disks is easy. Check out the build tips in that issue of Crawl. Doing a rear is very easy. Also the cost of a Detroit fir it is about half of the one for the Dana 60.

If you look into shaving it you can get more clearance than the Dana 60 will have.

I still have that 9.5" 14 bolt down here if you want it too.


Carl

Thanks Carl, will check out the magazine. Don't turn that SF 14 bolt loose, we just haven't been able to get together. Let me know you schedule and will set up something. As for using the 14 bolt, I may just have the one with the Richmond lock-right shaved and go with it. With the Dodge rims it will be about 62" WMS/WMS and will match up nicely with the narrowed front GM Dana 60.

I have a spare set of the Michelin 11.00R16 XZL's stashed in the basement at work so I may just have them put on the Dodge wheels.
 
That truck is not slated to go anywhere. Still sitting beside the house.

Need to find the time to pull the engine and all out.

Like it sits is not an issue, I need to go and crank it up and move it to mow around it for winter. Nice to keep things in the yard moving.

After talking with the guy from Xtreme4x4 up in Pa at the Jeep show it seems like the 14 bolt is a good way to go, if you are looking at going bigger.




Carl
 
Back
Top