I am running Mopar MPI on a stock 258, factory 20 gallon gas tank, and the Hesco supplied High pressure external fuel pump on my red Scrambler. I have over 25,000 miles on this set up. That 25k includes two cross country trips to Moab, up to Michigan, Missouri, Arkansas, and all over the rest of the Southeastern part of this country, where summer time temperatures exceed 100 with 100% humidity.
1) I have never "starved" the engine/fuel pump for fuel, off road or on road. I can suck my stock tank down to where it takes 19.8 gallons to fill it back up, no problems.
2) My fuel pump does not get "hot". I mounted the fuel pump on the forward face of the cross member that the front of the gas tank mounts to. I have never had a fuel pump "overheat" issue.
3) As for noise, using the Hesco supplied fuel pump, I can not hear the pump over the engine.
I a running factory GM TBI on a stock TBI 350, factory supplied 20 gallon gas tank, and a NAPA low pressure external fuel pump made for a Ford Van/truck with EFI. I only have around 5,000 miles on this set up. That mileage includes a trip to Michigan/wheeling in the dunes for a weak, trips to Sicily Island Louisiana, and trips to Alabama. Same thing as the red Scrambler example, it gets really hot down here!!!!!!
1) I have never "starved" the engine/fuel pump for fuel, off road or on road. I can suck my stock tank down to where it takes 19.8 gallons to fill it back up, no problems.
2) My fuel pump does not get "hot". I mounted the fuel pump on the forward face of the cross member that the front of the gas tank mounts to. I have never had a fuel pump "overheat" issue.
3) As for noise, using Napa supplied fuel pump, I can just hear the fuel pump when the Scrambler is idling. It is not obnoxious, but you can hear it hum. You can not hear it while driving.
The only heat/fuel issues/problem I ever experienced:
1) Red Scrambler, driving north out of Amarillo, TX into New Mexico. I had a tank of crappy gas, drove 2.5 hours at 75mph into a strong head wind, the Scrambler sputtered and died, fuel starved. Plenty of fuel in the tank, fuel pump cool to the touch. My "fuel/heat" issue was from under hood heat - When I poured a bit of gas on the throttle body intake blade, it instantly boiled off!!!!!!!!!! After restarting the Scrambler this way, I continued on driving at 60mph. Re-filled the tank with higher octane/less crappy gas, never had another issue.
2) Tan Scrambler, driving north on I-65 through Alabama in August during the middle of the day, super hot outside, cruising 75-85mph. When the tank would get near 1/2, I would have a bit of hesitation. Immediately after refiling the tank with fresh, cool fuel from the gas stations, no problem. Again, fuel pump cool to the touch. Problem - under hood heat, fuel lines rest directly on the valve cover/front of the engine. Theory - the fuel was being heated inside the fuel lines that rest directly on the engine. The fuel temp is constantly being raised by engine heat, until it starts to boil off inside the stock factory metal fuel lines. These metal fuel lines were as hot as the engine, which runs between 200-210!!! Solution - re-route metal fuel lines off the top of the intake/valve cover, problem solved.
Just my "two cents"
Also, Red Scrambler "issues" in New Mexico. I even changed the fuel pump on the side of the highway in less then in hour. It did not solve the problem. You can't do that with an in tank pump, unless you have a hole/access cover in the bed floor
I like the in tank fuel pumps, too, my old TJ/new LJ had/have them, no problems. On my older Scramblers, I like the external pumps, easier to install, easier to swap out in the field. Just my experience/opinion