• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Element fire extinguisher - just tested one

gpassida

Basic User
Member
City
Redding
State
Ca
1669442018067.png

I know we had a few posts asking about these things. I could not find it. As my build is getting back on the road and trail, I REALLY wanted to use one of them. Lot's of benefits: Small, non-toxic, no residue to clean up, never expire, not going to knock you out if it comes loose, works on many types of fires etc.

I bought a 50 second Element Fire Extinguisher(with my $79.99) for my Jeep Scrambler. I had watched a few test videos on YouTube but wanted to test it myself.

We put a 50/50 mix of used motor oil and gasoline into three drain pans and built a wood fire. We lit up everything and tried the Element Extinguisher on them.

Unfortunately it failed pretty badly. I really had high hopes as I wanted to put the 100 second extinguisher in my kitchen and garage and 50 second ones in all my vehicles.

It was a little windy but not too bad. You can see from the flames and pattern of chemical coming out of the Element. It did put the fire out in the immediate front of the extinguisher but if ANY flame was left, it re-lit. The Element did not have enough output to kill even the first pan of fire. I was hoping to put them all out. And I had to get very close to the fire to have any effect.

Even the wood fire was a challenge for the Element. The flames went out quickly but as soon as the red hot coals got new air, they re-lit too. This was 100% wood - we lit small pieces first. No fuel or other starter material was used on the wood fire.

It burnt for more than the 50 seconds so that was good.

We should have filmed it but all four fires were easily and quickly put out by a few puffs from the traditional 5 lb First Alert dry chemical extinguisher I have always carried. There was a decent amount left in the extinguisher too after putting out all of the fires.

I think the Element might be okay on small fires where the spray can totally cover the fire and ALL fuel. But seeing how easily and quickly the traditional extinguisher worked, I can't chance it with just an Element. Yes, you have the mess to clean up but at least the fire is out and the damage is limited.

If anyone has any feedback on the test, please leave it below. For me, I will continue to carry a dry chemical extinguisher or two.

I referenced the "Jeep Talk Show" podcast. They recently featured the distributor for these and had a 10% discount.

Here is my video on YouTube:
 
Wow, really appreciate you doing this review and test. I bought a few for my jeeps and now need to rethink what I carry. It would be interesting to send video to Element support and ask what went wrong… back to the old…
4C1D5556-C8AE-4872-8F48-B9358A0074CA.jpeg
 
So it's more of a 'fire slower' than a 'fire extinguisher'.

I'm thinking I'll stick with my clunly old tried- and- true extinguisher...... thanks for doing that George!
 
Thanks for the test and video. I will keep my other extinguisher.
 
Wow, really appreciate you doing this review and test. I bought a few for my jeeps and now need to rethink what I carry. It would be interesting to send video to Element support and ask what went wrong… back to the old…
I did email the link to the video to Element and my test details. We'll see what they say.

The only thing I can think of that they will say is that on the oil/gas fires, moving back a little to get their fog to cover the whole pan would have helped. I was able to cover the entire wood fire and it did kill the flames - as you can see. But it immediately re-lit when I moved off because of the hot embers getting air. For their extinguisher to work, I think you have to get all the flames out together or in a line in one direction. Once the fuel gets any flame from the rest of the fire, it instantly re-lights.

I really wish we recorded the dry chemical extinguisher putting all four fires out. A quick puff or two on each fire and they were out. I don't want to have to determine how fight the fire in the exact right way when under stress. For me, get the extinguisher on it and get it out.
 
One of the reasons emergency procedures so rarely change in the airlines is because in high stress situations which require quick action, it's best to have effective, simple and well-engrained solutions. Introducing complexity in a time-critical event can delay or prevent the desired results.

Secondly, the fact that you had to actually touch the fire to temporarily put it out is a really bad idea in an enclosed chemical fire. Standing back and spraying/sweeping is far safer.
 
I’ll stick with my old Halon extinguisher. I’ve used one on a burning motorcycle and I know they work, and leave no residue. I realize Halon is no longer available, but a similar product is.
 
I’ll stick with my old Halon extinguisher. I’ve used one on a burning motorcycle and I know they work, and leave no residue. I realize Halon is no longer available, but a similar product is.
Sandra wants one for the JT. Any specific links to what is a good one, as far as the Halon equivalent is? Really want to avoid the residue... Bought a bracket that will take a typical 2-1/2" dia bottle...
 
BTW, the video I posted above of my Element Extinguisher test was pulled down by YouTube. Element asked me multiple times to pull the video down and I resisted. They filed a copyright claim with YouTube and they pulled it down. I appealed and lost. YouTube nor Element can tell me how I violated their copyright. All I did was buy their product with my own money and film a test of it. I did not make any money off the video; represent it was my product or use it to promote anything. There was no copyright violation. But unless I get a copyright attorney involved, YouTube will not do anything else to restore the video. I found out the email of the person at Element who filed the complaint and got no response or explanation on how it violated their copyright. They don't want their product to be seen in an actual test that is not favorable to them. And they will go to great lengths to hide that.

I'm very disappointed with YouTube on this.

I do have an Element strapped on my roll cage, but I also have a regular dry chemical extinguisher mounted as well. The Element "fog" has to completely cover the flames at the same time to put it out. The dry chemical actually leaves behind the powder that prevents that section from relighting. (hence the mess) In the right conditions, the Element may be good but there was some wind during my test that defeated it as you could see in the now removed video.

If you have an engine compartment fire and you get the Element "fog" in there and it can fill up the entire space, it will likely choke out the fire. But if it's windy, or you can't completely cover the flames, it probably won't.
 
BTW, the video I posted above of my Element Extinguisher test was pulled down by YouTube. Element asked me multiple times to pull the video down and I resisted. They filed a copyright claim with YouTube and they pulled it down. I appealed and lost. YouTube nor Element can tell me how I violated their copyright. All I did was buy their product with my own money and film a test of it. I did not make any money off the video; represent it was my product or use it to promote anything. There was no copyright violation. But unless I get a copyright attorney involved, YouTube will not do anything else to restore the video. I found out the email of the person at Element who filed the complaint and got no response or explanation on how it violated their copyright. They don't want their product to be seen in an actual test that is not favorable to them. And they will go to great lengths to hide that.

I'm very disappointed with YouTube on this.

I do have an Element strapped on my roll cage, but I also have a regular dry chemical extinguisher mounted as well. The Element "fog" has to completely cover the flames at the same time to put it out. The dry chemical actually leaves behind the powder that prevents that section from relighting. (hence the mess) In the right conditions, the Element may be good but there was some wind during my test that defeated it as you could see in the now removed video.

If you have an engine compartment fire and you get the Element "fog" in there and it can fill up the entire space, it will likely choke out the fire. But if it's windy, or you can't completely cover the flames, it probably won't.
I guess I will get a dry chem one. Hell, if the Glad has a fire I am not as concerned about it getting messed up with dry powder vs, my '8 or Corvair. Insurance will get me a new one... ;)
 
I just ran across this in another forum

https://www.blazecutusa.com/

Looks like a great solution to under hood fires. A little expensive but much cheaper than the damage caused from a car fire. There are similar systems being sold on amazon under different names, but they all appear to be similar.

Fire Slayer

I might buy it for peace of mind, although I won't know if it really works unless I have a car fire.
 
Back
Top