• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Charlie's cummins diesel transplant thread

Bash away...

Well,
Like all opinions mine will be thought to stink but I disagree with the concensus of JPs dislike for diesels. I have been reading that "rag" for many, many years. And even back then I never bought into a lot of the negetive flak thrown at it. Its not a perfect magazine certainly, but which one is? Back in the day when 4wheeler or 4wheel and off road were pushing 18" liftkits on full size trucks and 50 pastel colored KC daylighters as "the cool stuff"...JP was turning a corner. And while it may have de-evolved for a while into unjeep like rock buggies and "extreme" moon rides...At least it has offered us an entire magazine devoted only to "jeep stuff".
And to my limited experience it was JP that first ignighted the idea of a diesel in a jeep to me. I had never really given it much thought before they mentioned it years ago. Each time I see an article pertaining to a teaser jeep that some Chrysler Corp. big wig had built to flaunt the idea at us with something very do-able...to me it was always JP that brought me the first intel. If anything I would think they are growing tired of writing articles on these pathetic, one off creations that jeepers have begged for for years only to have the mother corp. deny us.
DO they bash the 4BT, vibration, output...sometimes. Is it deserved...no. Take a ride in a bone stock MB or 2A and then talk about noise. Roll down the road in somethng shod with 49 inch mudders and tell me about vibration being an "issue". Sure, there may be smoother, more powerful diesels out there...SO! But while I love the 4BT and wish I had one of my own...I will not thumb my nose at any other options out there. Shoot, I WISH jeep would build a truck with a cummins in it...or the MB based Grand Cherk diesel...Hell, pull a Sprinter MB motor in with a manual tranny and give me the ability to tune it...I won't scoff at 30mpg and more grunt than a Hemi!
So this is all just my opinion..feel free to disagree or bash if you wish. It is your right. I just offer that they are one of the few "jeep specific" magazines out there that is Still being published...and I will take it as I can get it. I am smart enough to make up my own mind but having new info available is nice...:cheers:
 
Well, I just wrote what I thought was a long and well thought out response and somehow I deleted it. The long and the short of it is I didn't mean to slander JP magazine. I've read many a copy and gleaned much usefull info from its pages. I just don't think they have the same wheeling goals in mind as do I.

Brian, I responded to your PM using my phone early this morning. Let me know if it didn't come through.

P.S. How did I get a "thumbs down".
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well,
Like all opinions mine will be thought to stink but I disagree with the concensus of JPs dislike for diesels. I have been reading that "rag" for many, many years. And even back then I never bought into a lot of the negetive flak thrown at it. Its not a perfect magazine certainly, but which one is? Back in the day when 4wheeler or 4wheel and off road were pushing 18" liftkits on full size trucks and 50 pastel colored KC daylighters as "the cool stuff"...JP was turning a corner. And while it may have de-evolved for a while into unjeep like rock buggies and "extreme" moon rides...At least it has offered us an entire magazine devoted only to "jeep stuff".
And to my limited experience it was JP that first ignighted the idea of a diesel in a jeep to me. I had never really given it much thought before they mentioned it years ago. Each time I see an article pertaining to a teaser jeep that some Chrysler Corp. big wig had built to flaunt the idea at us with something very do-able...to me it was always JP that brought me the first intel. If anything I would think they are growing tired of writing articles on these pathetic, one off creations that jeepers have begged for for years only to have the mother corp. deny us.
DO they bash the 4BT, vibration, output...sometimes. Is it deserved...no. Take a ride in a bone stock MB or 2A and then talk about noise. Roll down the road in somethng shod with 49 inch mudders and tell me about vibration being an "issue". Sure, there may be smoother, more powerful diesels out there...SO! But while I love the 4BT and wish I had one of my own...I will not thumb my nose at any other options out there. Shoot, I WISH jeep would build a truck with a cummins in it...or the MB based Grand Cherk diesel...Hell, pull a Sprinter MB motor in with a manual tranny and give me the ability to tune it...I won't scoff at 30mpg and more grunt than a Hemi!
So this is all just my opinion..feel free to disagree or bash if you wish. It is your right. I just offer that they are one of the few "jeep specific" magazines out there that is Still being published...and I will take it as I can get it. I am smart enough to make up my own mind but having new info available is nice...:cheers:
First off, I've been, and will continue to be, a JP subscriber for as long as they're around. I know one of the past full-time writers, and I love that they're Jeep specific. I'm not bashing the entire magazine by any stretch.

You may not be aware because of the delay for things coming your way, but JP has an article in the current issue about the "10 Stupidest Engine Swaps Ever" and one of them is the 4BT in a CJ.

So we're not just reading between the lines, they just came outright and said it. They say it's great for FSJs and you're right about them always pushing diesels when they're mentioned for concepts and in rumors, but this is JP stating, in a nutshell, that a 4BT is too heavy, too noisy and causes too much vibration for a CJ. (as I mentioned, they basically said the same thing about any medium duty diesel from Ford and Chevy in another one of the 10 they cited).

Just making sure you're on the same page because I know you said it takes a while for mags to get over to you. Your reply makes it sound like you're taking us as just negative on the magazine on the whole without them having specifically commented on the 4BT.

I would still love to have one regardless, and I'll keep being excited every month when JP comes :thumbsup:
 
P.S. How did I get a "thumbs down".

Somehow, maybe with the issue when your post was deleted, the post icon was selected as a thumbsdown (post icons are right below the text field when you compose a post). I deleted it for you.
 
The 4bt is definitely not for everyone, especially guys (and ladies) who have always owned and driven gas vehicles. With that said I will venture that the 4.0 swap is probably the best all around engine conversion (as a performance upgrade) for a CJ. There are other gas engines that are very cool, but for cost, ease of installation and relative "bullet-proofness" the 4.0 seems like the best choice. Just to make it clear, you've got to like diesels period before you should think about buying anything pre-04, regardless of what it's in. They smell a bit, they need to be plugged in during the winter months in colder climates, they're louder and they should be idled before shutting down (turbo-charged engines). Those trade-offs are a deal-breaker to a lot of folks who grew up with gas powered autos. The plus side is kids think your the school bus when they hear you coming around the corner.

With that said, my 4bt doesn't rattle any worse than an 89' dodge with a 6bt, nor is it much louder. But, I wouldn't want to have one in my jeep if my primary objective was taking little kids to the icecream shop with the top down or taking a girlfriend on a Sat. trailride. They'd be def and she'd likely leave me. I put it in my 8 so I would have a diesel powered and reliable vehicle that was vintage and unique, but still more than capable of being driven 250 miles on-highway (at 65-70mph) to the trail, wheeled point to point without knowing what I was going to get into and driven home 250 miles. Nothing more, nothing less. I'd do it all over again in a heartbeat and really wouldn't change anything.

To me the 4bt is a little underpowered for an FSJ. Maybe if one were "built-up" from stock, but at 105-120hp, I think I'd want a 6bt.
 
Diesel...the "Wave of the...Past?"

You are correct BW. I have not yet seen the article as the last JP to grace the sandy shelves in our px was from March and it arrived last week...:banghead: To hear that JP would willingly knock the 4BT is sad but in a way, almost expected. To me, a loyal reader for over...uh...at least 12 years ( :eek: time flys) I have learned to not put much faith in every issue being a 'keeper". But conversely, I owe a good deal of my knowledge (useless and otherwise) to the past and present staffers. So why does it not really surprise me? Well, to be honest the magazine appears to be suffering a bit lately. There are a good number of causes but the least mentioned is what I consider..Jeeps lack of interesting current lineup!?! One can only write so much about the JK... And what else does Jeep offer that can wheel without major plastic damage? Not much.
On to diesels...
I love diesel...the concept, the execution...the power and the potential. If you notice I titled this response the "Wave of the past"...as a tribute to Herr Rudolph being so far ahead of his (and our) time that we are only just now starting to realize it! :bow: I have such a hard time understanding how we, as a society, can gripe and complain about gas prices, enviornmental impact, a potential end to fossil fuels, blah blah blah...And recently (within the last 15 years-ish) we have started jumping on this "alternative fuel" bandwagon...Electric vehicles, Hybred stuff, strange gas powered things like hydrogen or CNG...all very "new" and "cutting edge" they tell us...I say to all this...POSH!
So we want to reduce our dependency on "foreign" oil...reduce emissions, create powerful engines that provide more reliability, better economy, and less need for dino fuel? Well shoot...Why do we want to reinvent the wheel? Diesel? Anyone ever heard of it? More specifically...Bio-diesel.
Gee Wally...whats that? How about a "synthetic", man made fuel that will power a diesel engine with little to no modification? How about something that provides more (marginal but still) power and MPG and less emission output? Basically a plug and play fuel source that can be run in many of the vehicles used today without need for special pumping stations, electrical recharge way points, or even major change at all...
And if my information is correct (may be flawed.?.) Mr Diesel used Bio (peanut oil I think?) in the very first diesel engine! So its really as old as diesels themselves. Does it have flaws? Sure...cold weather gelling is one of the biggest. Also the fact that it likes to "eat" some incompatable fuel lines. It also tends to clean a used engine...so well in fact that they often require several fuel filter changes to sort out the junk. But all this is based on limited and a little out dated efforts to create it. Imagine if suddenly the major oil companies decided to invest more in solving these issues? How about Uncle Sam? Sure would be nice to have a 100% synthetic fuel to power our vehicles. And how about mileage increases? I know a lot of folks cruising around in their manual tranny VW diesels knocking down 50-70 mpg! And they are not suffering..these are modern vehicles with not much other than a diesel fuel only sticker near the fill nozzle!
Sorry...getting a little long here. In a nut shell, I love diesels. My secret goal is to find a good candidate for a swap while I am in Germany and let my uncle bring it home for me...ahem. Then swap whatever it is into an older Jeep (like my commando) that doesn't need to be poked and prodded by the emission Nazis...Just need to locat something that will fit the bill and be a reletively "easy" swap...As in a manual tranny, stand alone wiring, and preferably a TDI configuration...
 
good stuff

:twocents:
#1. awesome

#2, could u pm me ur ph #?
working on a hummin cummins transplant

Chris
 
Bullet Proof

Thats what that little unit is..........the right tranny, drive gears and you got a killer set up. those motors are in the old 70's toyota landcruisers in africa and australia. :cheers:
 
Back
Top