• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Greenies trying to Take More - Tellico

donaghy

CJ-8.COM owner
SOA Member
FORUM OWNER
City
Lexington
State
SC
Attended the 21st Annual Dixe Run in Tellico this past weekend. We had a booth setup for GR8TOPS and hung around for the raffle Saturday night. Got to see RJ and chat with Mopedal for a few minutes too.

Anyways.. If you haven't heard, the greenies are trying to take our beloved Tellico. It has happened on several occasions and levels before but it has been noted that this one is a bit more serious and needs an all out response by the Offroad community.

SWFDA (Southern Four Wheel Drive Association) is taking on the brunt of the legal proceedings with the assistance and direction of United 4wd.

But, any other personal letters, phone calls and help is always needed. Not only does this of course have the direct effect on not being able to wheel, it would have a huge economic effect on Murphy, NC as all the cabin rentals, campgrounds, and gas stations, motels etc.

Read all about it here..

http://www.sfwda.org/trails/tellico/index.html

Form letters/any mail in letters need to be sent in by Oct 14th I believe, so anyone still has time to send one in.

There is a sample letter online through that link. Can always donate to the Save Tellico fund as well.

They raised over $21000 in an impromptu challenge for about an hour by clubs and businesses donating.

Matt
 
Yep! Matt is correct. The Forestry Service is about to wimp out and fold in to the demands of the "Trout Unlimited". Word is they are voluntarily shutting down "Lower 2", "Guardrail & Helicopter Pad" as well as "Slick Rock". This is happening even though a poll was taken from the trout in the streams where 9 out of 10 trout voted to welcome Jeeps instead of trout fisherman! Go figure!Lol!
Many of you haven't experienced these amazing trails. If things go foward....you may not ever have a chance after the next couple of months!
Get on the above link and do what you can now which is writing a letter expressing your desire to keep the trails open.
 
Written, ddressed and in tomorrow's mail

Don't forget that the entire USDA Forest service is doing their travel management planning now and in most cases their planning is resulting in wholesale closures, 70% of the current roads in the Santa Fe NF for example. Get active, no, get militant, just like the cabrones in trout unlimited, just like the a holes in the rest of the closure groups. BLM is also doing wholesale RMP rewrites, the San Luis Valley in CO is proposing a 51% closure despite acknowledging a 70% growth over the 20 year life of the RMP

Pissed yet? I sure am
 
Help me to help you!

Ok people. For those of you that don't know me off this site, besides being a jeep addict, I am a fish biologist and aquatic consultant. I solve problems like this all day. My problem is I can't find any real data on this problem. I contacted Trout Unlimited and they claim they don't know anything about Tellico. This leads me to believe it must be a local chapter getting involved. I also contacted the Forest Service, who was less than helpful. I requested a copy of the EA (Environmental Assessment) or any other documents they had. They said they did not have anything to email me. From my conversation with the forest service, they are citing NEPA and CWA 404 water quality issues as the reason for the possible closure. This is good if you want my help. I am a Certified Erosion and Sediment Control specialist.

Now here is what I am offering: I want to look over any data the forest service has and offer how to counter their arguments. I will offer any and all services I provide to help keep the trails open for free. I will draft counter proposal, act as expert witness, draft sediment and erosion plan, etc. What ever is needed.

Here is what I need: Someone to pickup hard copies of the reports from the forest service and mail them to me, someone to act as my local eyes and ears, and someone to get me in contact with the proper people at SWFDA.

I know that SWFDA has money and lawyers to fight this battle, but what they really need is someone that understands environmental issues. I already have some ideas how to work on this problem. If trout unlimited is involved, I can get them on our side. Just let me know if you want my help. We can win this one and set precedence for future legal battles!

I will now get off my soap box

Bill
 
Bill, I sent a link to your comments to Carla Boutcher, attorny for United 4 Wheel Drive Asso. She would be a great contact for you to discuss this with. She has a great track record working on exactly this type of issue.
 
Bill here is SFWDA contact info, glad to see a biologist chiming in on this.


Director of Conservation and Land Management
Sean McLeod
Email: sean.mcleod@sfwda.org

Director of Legislative Affairs
David Borum
Oak Ridge, TN
Specializing in land use issues and legislative activities.
Email: landuse@sfwda.orgc

The SFWDA has done a massive amount of trail work at Tellico over the past year and I was very impressed with some of the issues they were working toward to fix. From what I gathered from Stefan Roth's speech on the subject is a lot of the funding that would normally go to the trail maintenance will have to go toward legal cost making the 4wd community look bad in not being able to do the maintenance and or attempting to bankrupt SFWDA with legal fees.

The only bad thing is on our side is that we need to police our selves more.
While riding Friday with a group of about 14 other jeeps just about every place we stopped and in other areas had multiple beer cans (not even allowed in the HOV area and should have not been there) and other trash. I left the trail with a small trash bag full and did not get every thing I saw. Sad to say I was the only one in our group that I saw pick up any of this. Heard a few talk about it but that was about it. In another area, for those that know Fains Ford, the SFWDA did a lot of maintenance here to prevent silt run off into the stream. One was to put up barricades to discourage people from trying to climb one of the banks adding to the erosion and sediment issues. There were several that decided to skirt the barricades and try the climb digging out more soil adding to the erosion and silting problems.

We have to remember that it's not just the "Greenies" there are those that participate in our recreational activities that are just as big if not bigger barriers to keeping areas like Tellico open. It only takes that one discarded beer can or that one jeep going off the trails to make us all look bad.
 
ditto to what john said. They have already been working with Carla from UFWDA and will eventually need the expert opinion and witness part. Contact her from the UFWDA website or John has it and I'm sure she would love to hear from you.

Just in your initial findings, they are right on the money. From what everyone is saying, there is no definitive, quantitative data to back what trout unlimited is saying. from the sounds of it, the forestry commission is just throwing up their hands and the whole deal and not putting up much fight.
 
Suggest you contact Mr Crawford as he is local and a Scrambler owner. He would probably be interested in helping out and may already know the rangers. If someone can provide contact, it would be helpful, if not, suggest you go through Crawford's campground.
 
kudos for stepping up Bill, I, too have been an environmental professional and one thing I've learned, agency data that drives these decisions can be very hard to get hold of, usually because it doesn't exist. They also tend to accept non peer reviewed papers from special interests (magazine articles in Sierra Club or TU membership magazines) as though they were legitimate, I can tell you several instances here in NM where agenda drives 'science' and despite fatal flaws in the data quality it is accepted, and presented, over legitimatly collected and analyzed results, IF those data don't support the agenda.

Carla will be right on top of the situation, as will David Borum, I encourage you to talk to both, especially Carla as she may have several places where you can help. I'll also suggest talking to Todd Ockert (?) he's the UFWDA Dir of Env Affairs and can be esily reached via the United website or the united forums (which would benefit from your participation.

I hope you've become aquainted with Tom Mandera of the MT4x4 assn, he can use you too, he's a scout guy though so he's a little off plumb (lol)
 
Thanks for all the replies! I will send out a few emails today. Also feel free to have them contact me directly at william_rehe(at)yahoo(dot)com.
 
Here is all I could find: http://www.southernenvironment.org/cases/tellico_orv/index.htm

There is nothing on either TU website about Tellico. I am starting to get the feeling this is just a case of lawyers needing something to do to justify their jobs. All they have is biases comments on their website and subjective pictures. It really makes me mad when so called environmentalist ruin things for everyone. I am "greener" than most, but it seems there is no science behind this legal fight. I for one feel that it is important to protect OUR natural resource for future generations and I have spent a lot of time working with brook trout but I don't see how this is getting anything done.

This is very frustrating!
 
Hello...maybe I can help

Hey y'all. My name is Heather Spivey and I am with SFWDA. I am a Toyota girl so I haven't been over to your forum until today, but don't hold that against me!

I am an environmental consultant and am the author of all those form letters and posts on the other forums. I joined your forum and am here to answer your questions about what it going on. I found your forum through an email sent to SFWDA by Bill.

Bill, I have the data that TU is relying on for their conclusions, and it does not hold water (pardon the pun). We do need additional help with the science of what is going on out there. So far we have me, another stream specialist, and it sounds like you! I am the person on the Rescue Tellico team that is the "science" person, so I am building a team to help Carla and the BlueRibbon lawyer (Paul) when they need us.

We can always use the help. So ask away and I'll try to answer your questions as best I can. In the mean time, visit these threads and read up on what's going on.

http://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=170857
http://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=179475

Good to meet y'all!

Heather
 
Welcome Heather!


Glad to hear from you. I would love to help with this. Send me whatever data you have. Do you have any connections with the Forest Service? I would like to see what their fisheries people have to say.

I also have a few ideas that I think might help Tellico, but I would rather not plaster them all over cyberspace. If you have time, please contact me directly. My email is william_rehe@yahoo.com

Thanks!

Bill
 
The word greenies is derogatory; they may save something for your child to enjoy.
Blanket labels like that should be avoided

I mean, hey, not all republicans are jerks.. I may even have a republican friend

(go ahead & get upset at my analogy, it's ok :D , just trying to make a point )
 
Back
Top