• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

I need Spring Over real life opinions.

ineedajeep

Scrambler Junkie
Lifetime Member
SOA Member
City
Lake Charles
State
LA
Let me start by saying this is my daily driver. I have converted my Scrambler to spring over axle. I am running 35"x12"x15" MT tires and used "Rocky road outfitters" for the "SOA" kit. I am also running aftermarket Wrangler springs (Crown) and "MORE" shackle reversal. My Scrambler feels undersprung, as in porpoises at the least inclination. I was under the assumption that Wrangler springs would ride better than stock. NOT, The ride is definitely worse. I feel like at this time I have a couple of alternatives. One would be to add leaves to the Wrangler springs, or go to an arched spring such as "Rubicon Express" 1.5" SOA springs for the built in caster of an arched spring. I would like to only do this once more. Does someone have an opinion or explanation? I am leaning towards the "RE" SOA springs but don't really want any more lift. I do understand that you can't always have your cake and eat it too, but I sure thought the end result would ride better.
Peter
PS. Looking forward to meeting everyone at the Nationals.
 
I personally don't know anything from experience about the SOA, but Alcan makes springs to fit most custom applications from what I have heard. I know The Pres Scott Mine has a "Big Boy" custom 8 and lives right down here in Broussard that uses the SOA and Alcan springs up front. Maybe shoot him a PM to see what he has to say about details for what you may want now and in the future.
Duff
 
I have the RE springs on my SOA and like them. The only thing I have to compare though is the stock springs I first used and they were old and saggy.

Truck
 
My first set of springs was a set of stock springs that I used two spring packs and combined into one. It was undersprung also. It felt like a sprint car in sharp corners like it was going to lift the front inside wheel if you were on the gas. If you were on the brakes on a sharp corner it was like a fourwheeler wanting to lift the the back inside wheel. Had lots of wheel hop if there was alot of traction, front or rear. Any kind of side hilling was a very uneasy feeling where you couldnt tell where the limit of tipping was. I since installed a set of BDS 2.5 inch springs. Better, but not a done deal. A rear traction bar helped with the springwrap but hurt the flex. The front I have tossed around the idea of a currie swaybar. As a side note everything was magnified with the 36" swamperTSL/SX's compared to 33" bfg mudders.
 
When I did the SOA/SRS, I used the JC Whitney CJ 7-leaf springs on all four corners. So far I'm very happy with them. Can ramp about 750 yet don't get a lot of body roll on the road or on side hills. I do get some nose dive on braking but believe tha has more to do with the spring angle than the springs or SRS. Since the nose dive is smooth and predictable, I don't have any complaints with it.

cj8-040222c.jpg
 
scott anderson said:
i have done several..what are ur specific questions

I am looking for a more controlled ride, not necessarily stiffer. To be honest I rarely use my Scrambler for anything other than daily driving, so you see it's ride is important. Can I get a more controlled ride? Or does this suspension limit the results? Before I went SOA it didn't porpoise like it does now, and it's ride was acceptable, I am just trying to get close to that. I don't have the experience with Jeeps to know the best rout to go. Everybody you talk to on the phone has the best product, according to them so it makes it hard to figure out what to do. That's why I was looking for information from here as some of you ride SOA lifted Scramblers, I do understand that ya'll use your Scramblers more for off roading than I do, but I think ya'll can help me figure out what to do.
 
Did you do it in a way that SUA is still an option? I don't have experience with SOA other than seeing them and reading about it, but for what you're talking about doing with this one as a DD, an RE 4.5" SUA kit (w/swaybar and disconnects) and 1" body lift (if needed, I'd try the suspension first) would be a perfect ticket.

I personally think you're in a spot where you'll be experimenting and tying things without ever being completely happy with the results for a DD. I hope I'm wrong, but every Jeep is different and what anyone else has done might not be the answer for yours (that's true to some extent too with my suggestion, but it's a standard aftermarket bolt-on product that has a TON of people who can recommend, how you did your SOA may not be comparable to how someone else did theirs).

Best of luck with whatever you end up trying, but I felt it was worth posting this option.
 
My original SOA set up was Wrangler springs and Rancho 5000 shocks. I didn't like that so I took another set of Wrangler springs, cut them up and made eight and nine leaf packs. Still didn’t work too well, so I bought custom Alcan springs (http://www.alcanspring.com/) with 1” lift. When I ordered the springs, Charles (company owner) mentioned that the shock used was crucial. Long story short, I ended up with Bilstein 5125’s and a traction bar. On the street, it now rides and drives the same (with sway bar attached) as it did with SUA/33’s/2.5” SoftRides.

Later, Ken
 
I was just setting mine up SOA, but ended up going SUA- ordered RE 4.5" springs. My Scrambler still isn't driveable, but I could tell that the SOA setup wouldn't be good on the street. Aside from leaning 1" when I sat in it, it was so soft/flexy that I could rock it 3" side to side and bounce the front 4" just by jumping on it. It would have been awesome for a trail-only rig, but, like you, I want it to be my daily driver again.

I did alot of research- I didn't find anyone unhappy with the RE Extreme springs.
 
I you are looking for soa with being too high..i recommend the Rancho 1" lift springs...they are stiffer without giving too much lift....as far as being a daily driver...i had soa and 37's and routinely took it 150 miles down the interstate at 75 mph. If done right it is streetable...remember chevy trucks are soa...so that alone is not an issue
 
The bouncing and leaning will be cost by soft springs, not SOA. SOA doesn't require soft springs.

The shocks may have a lot to do with purposing as they will retard the action of the vehicle. What type are you running and are you sure they are good?

The SRS could have something to do with it, but the general only consequence of the SRS is nose dive on braking.
 
ibscrmbln said:
My original SOA set up was Wrangler springs and Rancho 5000 shocks. I didn't like that so I took another set of Wrangler springs, cut them up and made eight and nine leaf packs. Still didn’t work too well, so I bought custom Alcan springs (http://www.alcanspring.com/) with 1” lift. When I ordered the springs, Charles (company owner) mentioned that the shock used was crucial. Long story short, I ended up with Bilstein 5125’s and a traction bar. On the street, it now rides and drives the same (with sway bar attached) as it did with SUA/33’s/2.5” SoftRides.

Later, Ken

Ditto on what Ken did for me.
 
I had the RE 4.5 SUA and changed to the RE 1.5 SOA. The ride is much better in my opinion. Did the high steer and reverse shackle, no sway bar and is my daily driver. Works fine for me now but I might add sway bar.
 
I do appreciate everyone's responses. I will be talking to "Alcan" to see if they can build springs to my needs. Otherwise I will be purchasing the "RE" SOA springs. Going back to SUA isn't an option. I would probably go to a coil sprung suspension first. Thanks everyone for your help and I will see ya'll in Clayton with my Scrambler. In case anyone's wondering, I do really enjoy using my Scrambler as my daily driver.
 
I run the RE SOA leaf packs and love em, I went through 2 sets of Stock Wrangler springs (turned them into "S" shapes after one trip to the woods), you must have found that "John Nutter" article we all seem to base our SOA lifts upon, I don't think he wheels :) or drives his rigs on road.

Anyways, I ended up putting the RE springs on and a Ladder bar in the rear.
The only thing I'd suggest is getting the 6 leaf pack for the front and 5 leaf pack for the rear, I went 6 leaf all around and ended up pulling a leaf out so my rear axle would move on it's own. I'm running 60s front and rear.

No Nose diving, and the anti-wrap or "ladder bar" in the rear helped alot to control the excess wrap.
 
Mine rode best with the stock springs. I later changed axles and added some leafs and it was still fine. Then changed to F-150 springs and reverse shackles and it was what I would call dangerous. Then I gave up.
 
I've tried a variety of springs over the years on a SOA on my jeep. Current and longest use has been 2" rancho CJ-7 rears front and rear. Best thing is that if they sag, they are warrantied. I have tried YJ fronts, YJ rears, stock, and Rubicon RE's with the reverse eye. The RE's didn't work because of the rear revolver shackle. On the topic of drivablility, I would recommend keeping your sway bar set up. If you don't have one, find one. It will fex and ride nice but in cornering, you may feel less secure.

Funny thing is I am running the exact same spring on my wifes jeep, SOA D44fr/D60rr on 35's and it corners completely different (better). This is due to the spring sitting 2" further out and less leverage on the spring.
 
Back
Top