• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Miller vs. Hobart for a MIG Welder

John N

Addicted....Ex-SOA VP
Lifetime Member
SOA Member
City
Rockville
State
VA
I've been using (or attempting to use, if you've seen my work) a loaned welder for years. The real owner finally decided he wanted it back, so I want to get my own. I'm looking at the Miller 180 or 211 and the 2 Hobarts that are close to that. It seems that I'd have to pay $200 to $300 more to get the Miller. Is it worth it?

This is occational work in my shop, I don't use it to make a living. Someone told me these are made on the same production line.

Thanks...
 
Miller makes both, go with the hobart and save some money. I was looking at hobart mig welder and last month I ran across a CL ad on a Lincoln 220v Pro180 HD new in the box at half price. I couldnt pass it up so I bought it $325. Only to find out that my garage has a 230v 30amp plug! BOO!!! So now I get to drop a new wall socket in the garage. Will probably do it after x-mas.
 
Go with the biggest your garage and pocket book will support. I have a Miller 135 I bought 14 yars ago. Great for bodywork and small jobs. Wish I had larger.
 
I have a miller 210 that I have probably run 1000 lbs of wire thru. I love it. Never used a Hobart..prolly good too
 
I have the the Miller 180 and love it. I have had the Hobart 175 (gave to my dad) and 140 (sold), both were also good machines. I never had a minutes problem out of the Hobarts, but side by side, some of the drive components are cast aluminum on the Miller/plastic on the comparable Hobart. The only other thing that stood out was that the welding amperage is variable on the Miller and at fixed set points on the Hobart dial, not an issue, but an observation.
 
I had a Hobart 135 and now a Lincoln 216. I really liked the Hobart and had no troubles but realisticly you can only weld 3/16. I would go with Hobart 175 for up to 5/16.
 
Back
Top