SCWorm said:
In my opinion, the winner of this game has as much claim to the national championship as either LSU or Ohio St. Nothing personal against LSU, but how many mulligans does one team get? Kansas and VT both have only lost one game, each to quality opponents.
If we going to go on records then Hawaii should be number 1 - they have not lost a game (and I don't believe they are). I think this season just further supports the need for a playoff system. Winning your conference and have no losses (or only 1 or 2) is a function of conference strength for that year and how tough your schedule is (also for that year). I believe there should be a playoff for the top 12 teams. No team not in the top 10 deserves to be number one at the end of the season and this would give you 12 teams.
All emotions and loyalties aside VT does not deserve to be racked above LSU even though they have had one less loss. VT played LSU at lost by over 40 points; that's big at this level of football. The Southeastern Conference is a strong conference and this year more than any other i can remember. Georgia, Florida, Auburn, Tennessee, Kentucky, Arkansas, South Carolina and even Vanderbilt were very good teams this year. Unfortunately, they had to play each other. LSU was beaten by two SEC teams - both losses in triple overtimes. Auburn had them beat until the last play of the game and Alabama fumbled on their own 3 yard line with less than 2 minutes left in the game.
Is LSU the best team in the U.S.? No; because they are not the same team they were in September. With the strong teams they have played they are too banged up and injured. If Ohio State beats them the loss will be more a result of their current condition than Ohio States abilities.
Personally, I think Georgia is the best team right now followed by perhaps Oklahoma (didn't say I liked either). That is the match-up I would like to have seen or perhaps VT vs. Georgia and Ohio State vs. Oklahoma.
Ah, but we did not do the bowl team selections, so, if Hawaii beats Georgia (don't think they will) then Hawaii deserves #1, hands down.
