• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Trussing and Tube welding the 20

MomoJeep

Basic User
City
Seattle
State
WA
Not settled in on a rear axle yet, but currently running my AMC20(1pc). Before I invest in re-gearing and lockers, I want something solid. I know there are other options, but I want to keep it in Jeep family... either build the 20 or find a 44. But for the 20, who has experience with trussing and welding tubes? Would love to hear you story!

(1) Welding tubes. Can a MIG do it, or does it need to be High-nickel stick welding for the cast-iron pumpkin?
(2a) Trusses - are there any bolt-on options? Or do they really not work?
(2b) Truss - I'd probably have a shop do it to ensure no warping of axle. Unless someone tells me it's not that hard to pre-heat, etc, etc. (?)

By the way, I don't plan on jumping the Jeep or hitting the gas hard over rocks. But I do carry loads on moderate trails (think Moab with 33"s), and just want something that I don't have to worry about...
 
If I were in your position I'd take it to a shop and have them weld the tubes, go through it and call it done. Sometimes this is best left to those that do it all day everyday. Well worth the piece of mind in my opinion.
 
I have heard the 20 is just as strong as the 44, so no real point in changing for a 44. Once single piece axles are installed, next weakness it tube strength.

Searchers Off-road for the truss.

Searchers
 
A bit more spendy and not Jeep, but I've got Dana 60 East Coast Gear Supply axles with Eaton E lockers and could not be happier. I'm at a point in my life where my time is worth more to me than hunting for parts. I bolted my axles in over a weekend and they were perfect: no fabricating, no parts hunting, no trial and error. Fantastic. Hook up the brake lines and go.

The company is very pleasant to deal with as an added bonus.
 
Their yard is gone now. The original owner sold and retired. But they repair shop is re-opened and running..!
Wow...that’s a bummer. I remember many years ago applying for a job there. They actually had heard of me from some of my internet posts building my Jeepster. I loved that place- sort of disorganized, 80’s hard rock on the radio, junkyard out back- remember a Scrambler or 2 back there. I didn’t take the job because of the expense of relocating. Always regretted that decision.
 
Yeah, After 20+ years of going there, I showed up one day and it was gone. Twilight Zone! But it seems one of the employees, Aaron, reopened it as a 4x4 repair shop. I think someone bought the land that the yard was on. I'm really glad they're still there... Not many people know CJ's that well anymore. Before they were "Olympic" they were called "Mr. Jeep"..
 
A little late to the game, but here's what my 20 had when I bought it: ( sorry for the poor pics)DSC00644.JPGDSC00641.JPGDSC00640.JPG

A simple "brace" welded to the tubes so I guess it could be called a type of truss. The tubes have been welded to the center section. I don't know who did this work but it looks good to me.
 
I may be wrong but they made the focal point where the pipe meets the axle tube. That's where the pressure would be instead of at the diff. Don't know how much stronger the axle tube is there. Wouldn't it be stronger spreading the force along the majority of the axle tube. Then having a bracket that runs over the diff and welded to the top of the diff?
 
jammer1-
"I may be wrong but they made the focal point where the pipe meets the axle tube. That's where the pressure would be instead of at the diff. Don't know how much stronger the axle tube is there. Wouldn't it be stronger spreading the force along the majority of the axle tube. Then having a bracket that runs over the diff and welded to the top of the diff?"

I'm sure it would be. I think whoever did this was more concerned with keeping the tubes securely in the housing than trying to make the entire axle a lot stronger. So far that part seems to work ok. They had probably heard of the tubes coming loose and twisting in the housing. They did weld the tubes to the center housing and looks like a decent job was done. It wouldn't be to much harder to extend the bracing further out on the tubes to add a bit more rigidity to the entire axle assembly. I think if I ever went to something larger than the 35" tires that are on it I would want a Dana 60 or something equivalent back there.
 
jammer1-
"I may be wrong but they made the focal point where the pipe meets the axle tube. That's where the pressure would be instead of at the diff. Don't know how much stronger the axle tube is there. Wouldn't it be stronger spreading the force along the majority of the axle tube. Then having a bracket that runs over the diff and welded to the top of the diff?"

I'm sure it would be. I think whoever did this was more concerned with keeping the tubes securely in the housing than trying to make the entire axle a lot stronger. So far that part seems to work ok. They had probably heard of the tubes coming loose and twisting in the housing. They did weld the tubes to the center housing and looks like a decent job was done. It wouldn't be to much harder to extend the bracing further out on the tubes to add a bit more rigidity to the entire axle assembly. I think if I ever went to something larger than the 35" tires that are on it I would want a Dana 60 or something equivalent back there.

Yeah, I wonder about that simple truss design as well.. Especially since I saw it here:

https://www.fourwheeler.com/how-to/transmission-drivetrain/1901-build-a-stronger-model-20-axle/

I think the idea is that the tubes bend near the diff(?). With this "pipe/tube" truss in place, that center part of the axle is stronger. The furher you go out towards the wheels, the less likely it is to bend... But personally I'd still prefer more of a truss that covers from the springs to the pumpkin.
 
Yes! Classic hat. I used to see their spare tire covers around as well.. ."Drive Hard". I'm not necessarily living up to that slogan. I try to "not" use the gas pedal to solve problems. I did try to to explain other interpretations of this slogan to my girlfriend. That didn't work so well... haha
 
Back
Top