I have suggested to new members elsewhere to have one thread for all their exploits which is easy to maintain update etc. rightly or wrongly. I think that works better than thirty threads from one person. I could be wrong.
Sent from my iPhone
Ultimately, folks can do whatever they want, but in terms of following along on a particular fix/issue/build and given the way the notification system works (if you take advantage of it), multiple people talking about an unlimited number of topics in one thread leads to confusion ("Are you talking to me?") and missed posts. At best, it's an incoherent series of posts that don't follow any particular topic, even if you can and want to sort them all out.
A thread by someone on one topic can easily be understood (assuming it stays on topic) no matter how many people chime in on the one topic.
A thread started by someone on "all their exploits" is at least somewhat coherent in that it should only really have substantial updates from that one person, but if they work on 20 different aspects of their Jeep at different times, it can become jumbled and potentially confusing. That said, some of the coolest threads on here are people's "build threads" where they show the entire process and that's why we started a subforum specific for those build threads.
These threads, however, essentially started by no one (whoever first notices it's a new month) and not on any topic, are just a mess of things and, like this little conversation, end up with side discussions that can be problematic. And I realize I'm contributing to that by continuing this discussion, but I think it's worth it and I'm the damn admin so I'll do what I want
The other way that I think about it is from the point of view of someone who comes back later and is searching for information. The single biggest value that this forum has is the MASSIVE amount of existing information on virtually every topic on Scramblers. For that person, search is next to useless if the threads returned to them in their search are 40 pages long and rambling/not specific. Yes, there are ways to get specific in searches and to search posts vs threads, but a lot of folks don't know about doing that and will throw up their hands.
If a one thread/one topic approach is used, search results, by default, will be be much cleaner.
The post Speedpin made on the simple spring fix for the shifter rattle is a perfect example. As a single (and yes, short, but who cares?) thread in the Drivetrain forum, someone looking for "shifter rattle" would get a thread that's returned with a title something like "Simple shifter rattle fix". Now, with it in here, that person get's a 75 post long thread titled "What did you do with..."
At LEAST we went to monthly versions of these so that there's not a single 7500 post long thread, as was getting going there for a while.
Not trying to be an PITA or call anyone out, but I've definitely noticed a downturn in the quantity of quality of information the specific forums after these threads started because "it's so easy" to drop something in the jumble here when it would be an awesome and useful thread elsewhere (like Speedpin's nice shifter fix post).