• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

What's the best repro tub and why?

What's the best repro tub?

  • Aluminum

    Votes: 50 36.8%
  • Steel

    Votes: 74 54.4%
  • Fiberglass

    Votes: 9 6.6%
  • Kevlar

    Votes: 3 2.2%

  • Total voters
    136
Phil at Matkins barely answered the phone when business was good!

It took at least 9 months to get my tub and frame and there were still issues.

Im thinking the repli-tub thing is pretty much a gimmick at this point. He (Jay) has a jig made that helps him ck the body mounts and I'd speculate it used to serve a purpose.

I bet the new tubs from anywhere are pretty well made correctly.

One dissapointment I recall on the replitub was there being no welded nut for the front fenders to attach to. Thinking there might be the same issue for the seats.

I think he might add something for the e-brake but come on! :)

The metal of the new tubs seems thinner. Also, the front floorpan has a weld from side to side where they put the front floor pan together.

The rear structure of the wheel hump on the underside just isn't right...It's weaker than originals.

The last I checked, W-O's pricing was competitve though and I would reccomend whenever you buy an aftermarket tub to buy it thru a shop that is willing to return it for you or go to bat if it shows up hurt in shipping. W-O has tubs in stock. I'd make the drive to pick my own out instead of having one shipped if I could.

For instance I always buy my sheet metal from Trailquest which is local to me because they will let you inspect whatever you've ordered at their shop and if you don't like it...get you another!

http://www.trailquest.com/

Very cool.

Just my .02
 
WO repli Tub is a gimmick in my eyes, I purchased a cj3a tub from them waited 10 weeks for it and then nothing was right, they advertise that they make them fit right, when in fact the only thing they do is jig the body mount holes and move them where needed. After many fitment issues and two trips back to them to swap fenders that were jigged wrong, and several calls I was very unhappy and not even a sorry for the waste of gas and time or offer to ship the stuff to me!! When asked about fitment they said well of course you are going to have to cut and weld its not factory, and I thought i was buying the stuff they advertise(the only bolt replacement tub),If I did it again I would buy factory and spend $3000.00 for someone to fix it, rather than spending all the money on replacement and then painting.
Most places don't tell you that you should strip the finish on the steel tubs before you paint them, because they use what ever primer is available so they don't rust by the time you get them.
You will spend alot of time on fitment issues of little things on any steel replacement tub, just be aware of that before you buy.

if money was no issue and you had alot of experience with how a jeep is put together I would go aluminum
If you have a fixable steel tub I would spend my money on a good body man and bring it home and bolt everything back on!!
Even if you spend $3500 on new steel replacement you still need to spend alot of money on paint materials even to do ot yourself!
Fiberglass I have no experience with but it takes extra wiring knowledge to run dedicated grounds to everything!
Just my .02
 
My biggest problem with glass tubs was how they connected to the frame. Apparently, you bolted down an angle bracket to the frame then drove lag bolts through the angle bracket into wood cores in the tub. It didn't seem very sturdy to me.

After calling around to all the places I could find who deal with fiberglass tubs (4wd, Shell Valley, and Kentrol), apparently, Kentrol uses steel plates that are threaded and accept a bolt just like the steel tubs.

If I only had the extra $$$ it would take to buy one...
 
I saw today that 4wd.com has free truck freight on the WO replitubs.
 
bigwalton said:
I saw today that 4wd.com has free truck freight on the WO replitubs.

It seems that 4wd.com jacked-up the price for the deal. Last time I checked 4wd.com was near Trailquest. Trailquest still is listing their tub at 3,638.00 + 325.00 shipping. So that's 3963 compared to 4054 at 4wd.com.

I'm wondering if the price of the aluminum tub will drop with the Canadian dollar falling?
 
i waited and waited and waited and then found a tub about 5 hours away, it was in very good shape,im glad i did, now i can fix it as i go along...
just my opinion.
 
old thread,
but I would not go aluminum. If you damaged it you would need a tig.
And aluminum might not "rust" per say but in time it will Oxidize! Which is
just as bad!

Rust: is a general term for a series of iron oxides, usually red oxides, formed by the reaction of iron and oxygen in the presence of water or air moisture. Several forms of rust are distinguishable visually and by spectroscopy, and form under different circumstances.[1] Rust consists of hydrated iron(III) oxides Fe2O3·nH2O and iron(III) oxide-hydroxide (FeO(OH), Fe(OH)3). Rusting is the common term for corrosion of iron and its alloys, such as steel. Other metals undergo equivalent corrosion, but the resulting oxides are not commonly called rust. Given sufficient time, oxygen, and water, any iron mass eventually converts entirely to rust and disintegrates. The corrosion of aluminium is extremely slow because the resulting aluminium oxide forms a conformal coating, which protects the remaining aluminium. This process is known as passivation.
 
This thread showed a bump with a new post today, but then no actual new post. Either way, it prompted me to look at it and read through it.

I think I voted steel in the poll, but the question was "what is the best repro tub?" Steel tubs come ready for paint and you can bolt them in. If you want a stock replacement tub, steel is the only option. You could hypothetically replace your tub with a steel tub with just a few days of work and a buddy (assuming you have fastners and nothing breaks or needs other attention). For a true reproduction, steel is closest: all the holes are pre-cut, all the nut-serts are ready, and your parts will easily bolt in.

However, it's still going to be steel, and you'll be dealing with traditional steel benefits and limitations. I see those limitations as primarily being rust.

I went with aluminum for my build because I know it's not going to be stock, and I don't want to deal with rust. As has been previously mentioned, this tub came with no holes and few markings. I've spent hours and hours measuring, marking, drilling, and tapping.

The Aqualu tub is very, very stout. When I was at KOH I talked to a guy with a CJ-2ish buggy using an Aqualu tub. He'd rolled it three times down a rock face, pounded out the one dent in the tub, sanded/polished it out, and from 10 feet away you couldn't even see the gouges that couldn't be sanded out. With the thickness, I'm also hoping that it will be a little warmer in the winter.

My concerns have been electrolysis and corrosion. I'm dealing with electrolysis by running seperate grounds down to the frame or back to the battery. I'm doing my best to electrically isolate the tub and pretend it's fiberglass. That being said, Land Rovers have been grounding through aluminum bodies with few ill effects for many many years. Grounding through aluminum bellhousings, heads, transfercases, and transmissions has also been going on for many, many years. Even if I do get a little bit of current running through the tub, I think I'll be OK. I still plan on having independant grounding sources set up behind my dash and in my center console. That being said, the people I've spoken with who built with Aqualu tubs went ahead and just grounded through the tub with no ill results.

As for corrosion, unpainted aluminum boats run around up here all the time. I'm going to go ahead and coat areas that won't receive regular attention with Rhino Liner and paint. I found shops that have successfully put these coatings on aluminum. The exterior I am going to polish using an aircraft polishing system. Unpainted (old) aluminum airplanes are still canvassing our skies. If I decide I don't like it, I can still paint the exterior at a later time.

Being in Alaska surrounded by aluminum boats also gives me confidence that if I should ever need a major repair done, I can find somebody to do it, or I'll just learn how to weld aluminum. Aluminum can be MIG welded (I did it in high school, albeit poorly).

I intend on leaving this a tail-dragger, so bobbing isn't a concern. If I wanted a bobbed-8, I would have ordered the bobbed tub and frame.

I have no regrets whatsoever about going aluminum!
 
I have an aluminum tub that I got from AFW, after they finished a year in the rocks with it.

Had it setting on the ground in direct contact for better than 3 years. No issues with corrosion. Try that with steel. There are several deep dents that will be hard to get out. But would have same issue with steel, probably have to cut out and replace if I wanted perfect.

But for durability I would go aluminum. However it will not look factory, neither will composites like fiberglass.



Carl
 
Sorry, didn't realize it was 7 years old, my eyes saw a 2009, not a 2004... too many hours at this machine!

cb
 
the problem with aluminum is that most fasteners (bolts) have dissimilar potentials. This sets up Galvanic corrosion. It is best to choose bolts with similiar potential to aluminum. Mild steel is not bad...DO NOT USE STAINLESS BOLTS as the anodic index for SS is .5 with aluminum being .75. Mild steel is .85 which is much closer.

Metal Index (V)
Most Cathodic
Gold, solid and plated, Gold-platinum alloy 0.00
Rhodium plated on silver-plated copper 0.05
Silver, solid or plated; monel metal. High nickel-copper alloys 0.15
Nickel, solid or plated, titanium an s alloys, Monel 0.30
Copper, solid or plated; low brasses or bronzes; silver solder; German silvery high copper-nickel alloys; nickel-chromium alloys 0.35
Brass and bronzes 0.40
High brasses and bronzes 0.45
18% chromium type corrosion-resistant steels 0.50
Chromium plated; tin plated; 12% chromium type corrosion-resistant steels 0.60
Tin-plate; tin-lead solder 0.65
Lead, solid or plated; high lead alloys 0.70
2000 series wrought aluminum 0.75
Iron, wrought, gray or malleable, plain carbon and low alloy steels 0.85
Aluminum, wrought alloys other than 2000 series aluminum, cast alloys of the silicon type 0.90
Aluminum, cast alloys other than silicon type, cadmium, plated and chromate 0.95
Hot-dip-zinc plate; galvanized steel 1.20
Zinc, wrought; zinc-base die-casting alloys; zinc plated 1.25
Magnesium & magnesium-base alloys, cast or wrought 1.75
Beryllium 1.85
 
the problem with aluminum is that most fasteners (bolts) have dissimilar potentials. This sets up Galvanic corrosion. It is best to choose bolts with similiar potential to aluminum. Mild steel is not bad...DO NOT USE STAINLESS BOLTS as the anodic index for SS is .5 with aluminum being .75. Mild steel is .85 which is much closer.

I've also gone back-and-forth on this issue. Aqualu actually recommends using stainless, but they also say that the micro-vibrations from stainless hinges, etc., will rub a hole through the aluminum simply because the steel is harder, and to back all the stainless hinges with thin sheets of rubber/neoprene. I have a sheet of neoprene to do this, but with the Rhino Lining coatings, I think I'll be mostly protected. For the hinges, I'm going to wait and see (and pray) that they don't vibrate through the aluminum. I'm not excited about how all the stainless hinges will look sticking out 1/16" with a black backing.

But back to the galvanic corrosion/fastner issue: I'm using a combination of stainless hardware and grade 5 & 8 bolts. I'm applying liberal amounts of anti-seize to EVERY fastener. Anti-seize seems to coat fairly well (including my fingers, tools, gloves, coveralls, garage floor, and trash can), and is not electrically conductive.

What's more significant for galvanic corrosion is that it requires 1) dissimilar metals being in contact, 2) electricity passing between them, and 3) immersion in an electrolyte.

I'm fighting all three of these: 1) paint/powdercoat/insulate all steel body panels; stainless steel hinges will have a coating of antiseize underneath; all fasteners will have a coating of antiseize; 2) the body will NOT be used as a ground; and 3) we don't use on the roads in the winter due to it being too cold for salt to effectively melt the ice/snow; the CJ will primarily be used in the summer; the CJ will never be put away "wet"; I'm not going to drive it in the ocean; the CJ will be stored primarly in the garage.

If I see even the slightest sign of corrosion, I'm going to install a sacraficial annode. And again, I defer to the fishing/boating industry in Alaska, merrily running around in unprotected 5052 aluminum boats. 5052, also referred to as "marine grade" aluminum, which is what the Aqualu tub is made from, has particularly good corrosion resistance, even when immersed in salt water.
 
I bet that if round over the sharp edges of the Stainless hinges and plates that should help keep from cutting the aluminum. Just use a file to break the sharp edge and that should help.

If you wanted to avoid the gasket look, you could get something like roll on Duraback and just coat the back side of the hinge or plates that will be in contact with the aluminum. Then you can clean up any that you get on the front or visible portion of the Stainless.


Carl
 
Just a thought on a gasket type material on the hinges. There is a mylar protective film used for paint protection. It is about as thick as a sticker, yet extremely durable, and adhesive backed. I'll bet that would make a great insulator for hinge to body contact.

There's links to all the different products in the column at the left, but the Aeroguard aerospace film looks like a good candidate...
http://www.clearmask.com/aerogard.php
 
Any thoughts or experience with these??

http://www.willysoverland.com/index.php/WO/replitub/

Says all the holes are already and properly cut..

I have had unpleasant experience with the overpriced WO tub

WO repli Tub is a gimmick in my eyes, I purchased a cj3a tub from them waited 10 weeks for it and then nothing was right, they advertise that they make them fit right, when in fact the only thing they do is jig the body mount holes and move them where needed. After many fitment issues and two trips back to them to swap fenders that were jigged wrong, and several calls I was very unhappy and not even a sorry for the waste of gas and time or offer to ship the stuff to me!! When asked about fitment they said well of course you are going to have to cut and weld its not factory, and I thought i was buying the stuff they advertise(the only bolt replacement tub),If I did it again I would buy factory and spend $3000.00 for someone to fix it, rather than spending all the money on replacement and then painting.
Most places don't tell you that you should strip the finish on the steel tubs before you paint them, because they use what ever primer is available so they don't rust by the time you get them.
You will spend alot of time on fitment issues of little things on any steel replacement tub, just be aware of that before you buy.

if money was no issue and you had alot of experience with how a jeep is put together I would go aluminum
If you have a fixable steel tub I would spend my money on a good body man and bring it home and bolt everything back on!!
Even if you spend $3500 on new steel replacement you still need to spend alot of money on paint materials even to do ot yourself!
Fiberglass I have no experience with but it takes extra wiring knowledge to run dedicated grounds to everything!
Just my .02

I would spend my money anywhere but there! Do your research on steel tubs, they are all made in the Phillipines and do NOT fit like factory tubs, the last Scrambler I put together came with a replacement steel tub and there was many fitment issues. such as:
Trans tunnel didnt line up
There were no nutserts (threaded fittings) for the fender or the dash bolts..
Drivers door and passenger door opening were 3/8" differant in height
The rear wheel well openings were not centered with each other
these were just a few of the issues , hope it helps
 
Last edited:
Just a thought on a gasket type material on the hinges. There is a mylar protective film used for paint protection. It is about as thick as a sticker, yet extremely durable, and adhesive backed. I'll bet that would make a great insulator for hinge to body contact.

That is exactly what I had planned on doing with my black stainless parts on my newly painted tub.
Finally just went to a local sign shop and got vinyl lettering material scrap pieces. Planned on buying them, but they just gave them to me.
 
Last edited:
Has anyone had any experience with Shell Valley tubs? I know fiberglass isnt ideal but the price is. Are all the wholes pre drilled? Do they go on well?
Thank You
 
Back
Top