• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Jeff's 2010 Project...

jscherb

CJ-8 Member
City
Elmira
State
NY
So now it's time to decide what I do next; I've got about a month of stuff to keep me busy but in January I'm sure I'll be bored and looking to start a next project. Here are a few possibilities I'm considering, but I probably won't make a final decision until sometime in January. These aren't in any particular order.

Option 1: Finish the Gaucho. I could change my mind and decide to finish it myself instead of selling it. I'd need to find a donor CJ-7 to provide all the bits necessary, and I'd need to decide what engine/transmission I'd like it to have. Color would probably be Chrome Yellow, or possibly one of the TJ or YJ yellow colors. Two weeks ago I would have told you there would be zero chance of me doing this, but now that the Gaucho is finished, I'm having second thoughts. The Gaucho has exceeded my expectations in many ways, and could easily be finished into a show-quality truck. Considering how much work it's taken me to get it to this point, building it the rest of the way seems pretty easy.

FinishGaucho-1.jpg


Option 2: Build one or more "Jeep tub" trailers. When I was picking up parts for the Gaucho project, I bought two Chevy pickup beds that had been converted to trailers - a longbed and a shortbed. Both of these were on decent trailer frames. I've also got the back half of the LJ tub from the Retro, and the back half of the YJ tub from the Gaucho, and a bunch of other tub parts, like top rails, so I've got most of the major pieces required to build both shortbed and longbed tub trailers. Here are some concept drawings, and some photos of the tubs, and the short- and long-bed frames I've got cluttering up my back yard. One of these days I have to do something with these parts, can't just let them sit here forever...

Trailer1-1.jpg


Option 3: I've always thought that Jeep factory hardtops look like upside-down bathtubs, so I've always wanted to build a completely custom hardtop with a little more style. If you've read some of my other threads, you've seen the modular design I've come up with for a hardtop system - using a series of common components, custom hardtops could be assembled for everything from Jeep pickups like the Gaucho to standard length CJ/YJ/TJ tops, all the way to LJ and Scrambler tops. The longer tops, like the LJ and Scrambler, could have a normal or an extended-height roof. I've figured out the engineering so the same parts could build a top for a CJ/YJ or for a TJ, dealing with the different methods of windshield top attachment. Rear door would be a swing-up hatch for the CJ series tops, but for the YJ and TJ series tops, the rear door would consist of a "half upper" that attaches to the stock tailgate, similar in concept to how a hard half-upper attaches to a half-door. I've worked out all the design and engineering issues for this project, and done detailed drawings for most of the components, here are just a few concept drawings...

Safari1-1.jpg


Option 3a: Once the top molds were built, there would be any number of custom projects I could build with these tops. For my own use, I'd like to build a full-length Safari top with the extended-height roof for a 2005/2006 Wrangler Unlimited.

Or, Option 3b, if I decided to build another custom Jeep, I could build a long-wheelbase YJ with a Safari top in either pickup length or the full-length extended roof version, for example...

LWBYJ-1.jpg


If I do the Safari top project, I'd start by building a pickup cab first, it would be easiest to do a smaller top first, plus that would give me all of the complicated modules I'd need to build the full-length top as the second phase of the project.

Option 4: Of course there's always the Mahindra Marshall 4-door idea, I would have my friends in India buy me a Marshall, disassemble it and send me the complete body. Over here, I'd build it onto a 2004/2006 Wrangler Unlimited chassis, so it could be a DOT-legal vehicle in this country and have all the benefits of the proven TJ mechanicals. But I think I'll hold off on this idea for some year in the future.

MahindraMarshall-1.jpg


I'll be pondering this decision through the holiday season with the idea that I'd probably start whatever new project I decide on in mid-January. As always, your thoughtful input is welcome. :)
 
Last edited:
I'm sure anything you decide on will come out great! You've got the "midas" touch! :smokin:

In the meantime, would you like to prototype the 1/24 scale World Cab, since you have a 1:1 for reference? ;)
 
This is a very hard question to answer without

D. All of the above.

Jeff youve put the time and work into building the best looking Jeep pickup of all time. The Jtrucks are cool , Scramblers arent really trucks and you brought the Gaucho into proportional correctness. If you dont get a "I must sell it now" price , finish it yourself. I think your bonding with it. ;)

Next Id like a trailer if you promise to sell it. I want one.

Im not much of a hardtop kinda guy but I know with your skills Id want one anyway.

So basically Im back to

D: All of the above.

Atleast I put mine in order. ;)
 
Think how cool it'd be for you and your son to come to a show with both the Retro and the Gaucho...
 
I'd say take a break from the Gaucho and build the trailer, if the Gaucho doesn't sell and you still feel like you want to finish it, then go back at it. My selfish hope is that you do that, end up finishing the Gaucho and I win the lottery to get them both off of you.

Mainly though, I agree with John.
 
I really think you should finish the Gaucho, but that's a big commitment not to mention $$ and time.

Sounds like the trailer project is not an "if" but a "when".

I think the hardtop would be the most challenging, but possibly the most rewarding in terms of having a unique product. I know I'd love to have one of those tops for my Scrambler.

I guess my vote is to finish the Gaucho first.
 
i agree with big walton... build a trailer or try the hard top thing. put an add out for Gaucho, if it sells, it sells, if it doesnt finish it.
 
Jeff, great work on the Gaucho. As always, I'm impressed with the craftsmanship and design. I would encourage you to finish this project. Mainly for my selfish reasons. I always check the progress first when I log on to this site. Whatever you decide, I'm sure it will be a great build. Keep up the good work.
 
Jeff, great work on the Gaucho. As always, I'm impressed with the craftsmanship and design. I would encourage you to finish this project. Mainly for my selfish reasons. I always check the progress first when I log on to this site. Whatever you decide, I'm sure it will be a great build. Keep up the good work.

Thank you.

I've been thinking about what it would take to finish the Gaucho. Seems like the best path forward might be to pick up a 91-95 EFI Wrangler, and use that as the donor vehicle. Then either adapt the YJ axles to the CJ frame and use the NP231 from the YJ, or find some good CJ axles and a Dana 300 and adapt the Dana 300 to the AX15.

But I still haven't decided if I want to finish it, just thinking about it...

I'm undecided between the hardtop project and the Gaucho project; maybe put the Gaucho on hold for a few months while I do the first hardtop and search for a good donor YJ, then do the Gaucho after the hardtop.
 
Last edited:
Go the CJ axle route.

It is very easy to adapt the AX-15 to the Dana 300. All you need is a 1/2 extra plate in addition to a clocking ring. I have been talking with Bezerk, about making those on his plazma machine. If we had a couple of folks who wanted them we could get them pushed up towards the top of the list of what he is making.

With that spacer to maintain proper spline engagement you do not even need to add a seal saver to it.

www.cjoffroad.com also sells the clocking and spacer kit.

I thought that you already had good axles for the Goucho? I got several sets of Dana 44's that can be adapted if you want. I can probably even come up with a Dana 300 if you need.



Carl
 
Go the CJ axle route.

It is very easy to adapt the AX-15 to the Dana 300. All you need is a 1/2 extra plate in addition to a clocking ring. I have been talking with Bezerk, about making those on his plazma machine. If we had a couple of folks who wanted them we could get them pushed up towards the top of the list of what he is making.

With that spacer to maintain proper spline engagement you do not even need to add a seal saver to it.

www.cjoffroad.com also sells the clocking and spacer kit.

I thought that you already had good axles for the Goucho? I got several sets of Dana 44's that can be adapted if you want. I can probably even come up with a Dana 300 if you need.

Carl

Carl,
I agree, the CJ axle/Dana 300 would probably be the easiest option.

The axles The Gaucho is sitting on now aren't worth the trouble. The would need to be completely gone through, the seals leak badly, they're so rusty they've be hard to disassemble, and on top of that, they've got 2.73 gears.

I would need to find a set of CJ WT axles in decent shape with the right gears, say 3.54's or maybe 3.73's. And of course a Dana 300. Anyone got parts they want to get rid of?

Jeff

PS: I'm experimenting with a YJ front axle this morning, it's a junker too, but I'm measuring and cutting on it to see if the perches could be narrowed to CJ width. I believe they could be, my measurements seem to be working, but I'm struggling to remove the old perches. Don't have a cutting torch so it's a very tough job. Seems like too much trouble though, the CJ axle route sounds much more appealing.
 
A 231 in this just seems all wrong to me. The shifter will look completely out of place IMHO.

Also, a YJ rear axle be a C-clip D35, right? *shiver*

I'll throw out my take... With the level of detail that went into this to this point, my opinion is that nothing short of a WT CJ30/44 combo is fitting, with a D300, preferably twin sticked. Given that it's CJ-based, I'm not sure how I feel about a 4.0, I think a nice, bone stock 360 would be ideal.

Basically, I feel like it should be the way Jeep would have built it back when the original Gaucho was made. Unlike the Retro, which is modern with retro touches, this is actually retro. If that makes sense.
 
A 231 in this just seems all wrong to me. The shifter will look completely out of place IMHO.

Also, a YJ rear axle be a C-clip D35, right? *shiver*

I'll throw out my take... With the level of detail that went into this to this point, my opinion is that nothing short of a WT CJ30/44 combo is fitting, with a D300, preferably twin sticked. Given that it's CJ-based, I'm not sure how I feel about a 4.0, I think a nice, bone stock 360 would be ideal.

Basically, I feel like it should be the way Jeep would have built it back when the original Gaucho was made. Unlike the Retro, which is modern with retro touches, this is actually retro. If that makes sense.

OK Mr. "4.0/AW4 in a Postal" :) Must be you regret not putting an AMC V8 in yours? :D I'm definitely, positively, not interested in an AMC V8 in any of my Jeeps.

I agree about the D300 twin stick, although I don't mind the 231 shifter on the other side.

If someone's got WT CJ axles, either D30/D44 or D30/AMC20, with 3.54 or 3.73 gears, and they want to get rid of them, let me know.

BTW, about the modern touches, if I end up finishing it, I'd probably ditch the vibration-prone CJ mirrors for actually usable TJ mirrors, and there's probably a few other "updates" I would make along the same lines.
 
Jeff,

I've got a pair of axles under my Jeep I'd like to sell (CJ WT D30/AMC 20), but they're 3.31. I also have a D44 WT rear out of an 86 CJ (also 3.31) that I'd like to sell as I'm going with a D60in the rear and a D44 up front. Email me or give me a ring if you're interested.

Cheers, Charlie
 
OK Mr. "4.0/AW4 in a Postal" :) Must be you regret not putting an AMC V8 in yours? :D

Ah, but if I'd put all the work you put into the Gaucho into putting the Postal back to stock in a restoration of similar quality, I absolutely, positively would not have put in a 4.0!

That's why I mentioned my opinion of the difference between the Retro and Gaucho.

If no v8, I'd be all about a nice, clean 258 with a 2100 and HEI. :evil:
 
Ah, but if I'd put all the work you put into the Gaucho into putting the Postal back to stock in a restoration of similar quality, I absolutely, positively would not have put in a 4.0!

That's why I mentioned my opinion of the difference between the Retro and Gaucho.

If no v8, I'd be all about a nice, clean 258 with a 2100 and HEI. :evil:

I guess here's where we differ - I can't see putting so much work into it and not ending up with a great year-round daily driver, which to me means EFI at the very least. So if it had to be a 258, I'd want to do Howell EFI like on my Scrambler, but as long as I have to buy a donor Jeep anyway for all the parts I'd need to complete the Gaucho, why not buy a YJ and get a H.O. 4.0 and the extra 50 hp (which would make it a much nicer d.d.). Around here, donor Wranglers are about the same price as donor CJ's, and easier to find in decent condition.
 
I suppose this is all pointing out a potential issue if you decide to finish it and then sell it as opposed to selling so a buyer can do it to their taste.

For instance, I would want CJ mirrors to go with the CJ styling and I would not want a D35 rear axle.

Same thing as painting it or not, basically.
 
So pop in an 86 D44, that is what I did, and I love the thing...

SO for your project, wow, lots of good ideas. I love the Indian vehicle, hope I get to see that when/if you ever do that one.

Personally I am a big fan of the hard top that you have considered working on. Would love one of those myself, but heck I doubt I will ever have a jeep that it would fit onto.

Anyhow, good luck with whatever you end up doing. I will be one of the many waiting to see.

Also, as many others have said, thanks again for including us in your builds, and letting us offer input. It has been an honor to think that you actually consider the ideas we put forth.

Good luck, and happy holidays!
 
...Also, as many others have said, thanks again for including us in your builds, and letting us offer input. It has been an honor to think that you actually consider the ideas we put forth.

No, THANK YOU GUYS! The input I get here is really incredible. Even when you guys just ask questions about what I'm doing, it often causes me to rethink my procedures and plans and the result is an improved end product. And even when Eric and I disagree (often :)), that kind of back and forth also makes me really think about what I'm doing. And the fact that I'm documenting every step for you to see means that I can't take any shortcuts, which forces me to build to the highest quality I'm capable of.

My projects wouldn't be what they are without the input, encouragement, oversight and criticism that I get here.

Thanks!
 
Back
Top