I will play devils advocate here
I do like the way the Warn 8274's look, however ,and this is my personal experience, I am sure others will chime in differently, I have yet to see one perform so well that it blew my socks off compared to other winches
Several people in our local jeep club have 8274's, several of my friends outside the jeep club have had 8274's, and I have owned an 8274. In my experience, in well over 50% of the times we needed to use a winch, the 8274 would not work. Now, granted, this could be down to misuse, age etc, but the biggest problem we have with them is the electronics. The solenoid boxes are not sealed, so rain water, car wash water, plus atmospheric moisture seep inside the solenoid boxes, corrode wires, and cause the solenoid's to fail

You usually find out the winch isn't working when you need it the most

I have never seen a gear train failure, mainly just electronic failures.
You can maybe pick up a used one for good money, but if you buy new parts from Warn to rebuild it, not gear train parts, just small parts, you will spend some money. I rebuilt one for one of my friends, no major parts were replaced, just seals, bearings, brake parts, and small misc. parts. Those parts were around $350. New cable was $150. 4 new solenoids and a new solenoid box (to replace rusty, corroded ones for the above mentioned reasons) was another $250. Basically, he spent $300 for the winch PLUS $750 in new parts to rebuild it EQUALS $1050 for a rebuilt winch
I do love the way the 8274's look, especially on the front of a vintage 4x4 (Jeep, early Bronco, Land Cruiser, Land Rover, etc). But personally, since I use my stuff and have to rely on it, I don't think I will ever have another 8274 UNLESS they design a new solenoid box/solenoid pack to prevent all the failures I have experienced.
On my current project, I will most probably buy another new Warn 9.5ti. I had one before, worked perfectly, it went with my trail jeep that I sold. And, in a real world test against a new 8274, it out pulled it and pulled faster. They also weigh less and block less air flow to the radiator. They also pull more weight (9500lbs vs 8000lbs) using less amp draw
Just my
Let the flaming begin
