• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

Warn 8274 question

Polarfire

Jeep Aficionado
Lifetime Member
City
Columbia
State
MO
I have a line on a Warn 8274 but I've never owned one so I have a few questions. The guy selling it says it currently dosen't work but only needs "wiring work" done. I realize that is pretty vague. Worst case is I have to rebuild the entire winch. What would that cost (ball park)? I'm trying to figure out what a good/fair offer would be for the winch and winch mounting plate. I will try to get more info on what is wrong with it. I know these are $1200+ new and anywhere from $400 - $650 for older used ones in operating condition. What are your thoughts?
 
Last edited:
Boy, this is a tough one. Can be a simple fix or a can of worms. Google Warn 8274 Winch Rebuild - there a quite a few postings you can review to see what you are getting into. Also, go to E-Bay and see what parts are going for.
 
When I asked for more info on what exactly was wrong with the winch this was the reply I got:

I certainly wouldn't expect you to take me at my word, but the person I bought it from told me that it worked fine prior to needing the wires replaced. He could have been full of crap when he sold it to me, but I took him at his word. It was someone I knew pretty well at the time. That said, I haven't personally seen the winch work so I can't offer any additional reassurances unfortunately. That is the best background I can give on this piece of equipment.

I have not seen the winch in person but here is the best pic I have of it and the winch plate:
attachment.php


I was thinking of somewhere in the $250 - $350 range for the whole setup but I don't want to offend him either. However, the winch isn't working and from the sound of it, he dosen't know what is really wrong with it. Is there anything that I should check to make sure it is not all locked up? Do the 8274's have a "free spool" option to pull the line out or does it have to be powered out?
 
Last edited:
Hm....bumper candy. IMHO I say offer your gut here. Split the 250-350 difference and offer him $300. If he is offended, then he does not want to sell his unknown and untested winch very badly. His ignorance to its history, issues and condition in addition to a 30 foot camera view warrants your low ball. The Winch is a simple enough piece of gear, and I believe in my heart you wont get burned at this price, but then again....what do I know? I don't have a whole lot of history and experience to share except that 10 years ago, mine needed a solenoid (I remember there being 4) and it was not a big deal. not many wires or complex electronics to be afraid of.
 
You may want to contact cj8lvr on this site (Jake White, the Scrambler Owners Association president). I THINK he rebuilt one recently, but I can't remember exactly how much he did to his.

and yes, there is a freespool on them...there is a little "T" handle that you pull out on the top left hand side (when looking at the winch).
 
Well, he turned down my offer of $300. I think I will let this one go. I don't really need it at this time but figured if I could get a good deal on it I would go for it.
 
I bought a working one for $250, and see them quite often in the 3-500 range, working.
 
Up here $500 is the going price in any condition.
Most need new selenoids and a good cleaning.

I picked mine up in 'Unknown working condition' as well, $500. It works, but needs a complete going thru to make it work 'right'

Even at that, I feel that I did well.

I would have been suprised if he had sold it so low.
 
Speaking from experience, these winches can be very costly to rebuild. I will qualify that by saying that any winch is probably expensive to rebuild, just not too many actually worth rebuilding when good winches can be bought new for $600-$700.

The 8274 being such an iconic accessory (for vintage OHVs like CJs and Land Rovers) and one that performs well to boot is definitely worth rebuilding. The parts however are not cheap. I've bought at least $400 in new parts thusfar, including an updated solenoid pack from Redding four wheel drive and I'll probably buy a 4.6 HP motor soon. These winches work great. They're fast and strong when they really are working correctly, which isn't usually the case with many peoples' older 8274's.

If you really wheel your jeep seriously, spend the money on a new one. If you are looking for one to be more of a vintagy accessory, spend whatever you are comfortable with on a used one and tinker with it. I wish I had followed my own advice, advice which I give confidently now that I've had the 20/20 vision that comes with already experiencing what you are going through now.

Best of luck.
 
Thanks for the advise, it really helps. At this time I already have a Warn XD8000 and I used to have a Warn XD9000i but I really want the vintage look and the performance of the 8274. In all my time wheeling I've only needed my winch twice but I really did need it those two times. For the Scrambler though, it will be more of an accessory rather than a true tool. I don't plan on wheeling the "8" as hard as my previous two Wranglers.
 
I will play devils advocate here:evil:

I do like the way the Warn 8274's look, however ,and this is my personal experience, I am sure others will chime in differently, I have yet to see one perform so well that it blew my socks off compared to other winches:shrug:

Several people in our local jeep club have 8274's, several of my friends outside the jeep club have had 8274's, and I have owned an 8274. In my experience, in well over 50% of the times we needed to use a winch, the 8274 would not work. Now, granted, this could be down to misuse, age etc, but the biggest problem we have with them is the electronics. The solenoid boxes are not sealed, so rain water, car wash water, plus atmospheric moisture seep inside the solenoid boxes, corrode wires, and cause the solenoid's to fail:angry: You usually find out the winch isn't working when you need it the most:banghead: I have never seen a gear train failure, mainly just electronic failures.:shrug:

You can maybe pick up a used one for good money, but if you buy new parts from Warn to rebuild it, not gear train parts, just small parts, you will spend some money. I rebuilt one for one of my friends, no major parts were replaced, just seals, bearings, brake parts, and small misc. parts. Those parts were around $350. New cable was $150. 4 new solenoids and a new solenoid box (to replace rusty, corroded ones for the above mentioned reasons) was another $250. Basically, he spent $300 for the winch PLUS $750 in new parts to rebuild it EQUALS $1050 for a rebuilt winch:eek:

I do love the way the 8274's look, especially on the front of a vintage 4x4 (Jeep, early Bronco, Land Cruiser, Land Rover, etc). But personally, since I use my stuff and have to rely on it, I don't think I will ever have another 8274 UNLESS they design a new solenoid box/solenoid pack to prevent all the failures I have experienced.

On my current project, I will most probably buy another new Warn 9.5ti. I had one before, worked perfectly, it went with my trail jeep that I sold. And, in a real world test against a new 8274, it out pulled it and pulled faster. They also weigh less and block less air flow to the radiator. They also pull more weight (9500lbs vs 8000lbs) using less amp draw;)

Just my :twocents:

Let the flaming begin:D
 
Up here $500 is the going price in any condition.
Most need new selenoids and a good cleaning.

I picked mine up in 'Unknown working condition' as well, $500. It works, but needs a complete going thru to make it work 'right'

Even at that, I feel that I did well.

I would have been suprised if he had sold it so low.

well, i think ive done the best so far out of anyone lol a buddy of mine in pensacola had one on his tj, which he rear-ended a guy on the trail, taking out the upper housing. it was then stolen in a parking lot, and he was going to throw the rest away, and i jumped on it. about 3 weeks later, i found a jeep special equipment upper housing with motor, but no soleniod pack.. and was able to persuade my mom into winning it on ebay for $200. I then asked for the rest of the parts for my bday and xmas from grandma, which i got the winch plate, and all the wiring except the soleniod pack.. so just gotta buy the solenoid pack now, which is 320 shipped to me from warn. so in all, i'll be into an 8274 for the 320 for the solenoid pack lol.
 
well, i think ive done the best so far out of anyone lol a buddy of mine in pensacola had one on his tj, which he rear-ended a guy on the trail, taking out the upper housing. it was then stolen in a parking lot, and he was going to throw the rest away, and i jumped on it. about 3 weeks later, i found a jeep special equipment upper housing with motor, but no soleniod pack.. and was able to persuade my mom into winning it on ebay for $200. I then asked for the rest of the parts for my bday and xmas from grandma, which i got the winch plate, and all the wiring except the soleniod pack.. so just gotta buy the solenoid pack now, which is 320 shipped to me from warn. so in all, i'll be into an 8274 for the 320 for the solenoid pack lol.

you did good ,but ,i bought an old jeep for $500,removed the winch and the alum slots and
re-sold the jeep for $500 ,then sold the alum slots for $200
So,as of now ,i am i have negitive $200 in this winch

attachment.php

attachment.php

attachment.php

attachment.php

attachment.php
 
Is that an early M38A1? What is up with the square headlight bezels and turn signals?
 
Is that an early M38A1? What is up with the square headlight bezels and turn signals?

YEP,THE OLD MAN WHO OWNED IT DID THAT,TOOK ME AWHILE TO FIGURE OUT WHAT IT WAS , FOUND ALOT OF BONDO WHERE THE ORIG LIGHTS WHERE
HE EVEN CHAGED THE GUAGE CLUSTER !! NEAT HUH!! AND IT HAD A CHEVY 283 IN IT
attachment.php

\
attachment.php

attachment.php
 
I bought the 8274, sold my 9000, bought a reseal kit, and am in the process of rebuilding/refinishing it. That said, I am really rethinking my choice. I was planning on cutting my front crossmember so I could recess the winch between the front frame rails. I'm beginning to wonder if that isn't a whole lot of work for no gain. I'm currently considering either selling the 8274, or trying to see if there's anyone who would want to trade for another 9000.:banghead:
 
Why do you want to do that?

For the probably misguided attempt to lower the winch and allow more airflow to the radiator, and to do something "cool and different". However, I am realizing that if I were to do every "cool and different" thing that passed through my head, I'll never get to drive this thing. I'm at the point of trying to "fast-track" my build, so I can be driving this summer.

Seriously considering trading or selling my 8274. I think it will block too much airflow, especially with the 5.3, an A/C condenser, and a trans cooler.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top