• Notice for iPhone users: DO NOT use the image size reduction option when uploading photos to the forum. This causes portrait images to post as landscape. We have added a warning to the image insert pop-up as well.

I-4, I-6 or V-8???

artie

Legacy Registered User
City
By the lake
State
Fl
I looking to put a power plant in my Jeep. Anyone with pros and cons to eng size please let me hear your thoughts. Oops, this should be in the engine threads!
 
Last edited:
More info required.

I'm sure you can get all sorts of help here for helping choose. What you need to do is sketch out some rough details.
Budget
Desired end result (stock power, performance, etc..)
Driving habits
Mechanical ability
Etc...etc...etc.
The more info you give the more focused your replies will be. Otherwise you'll have people like me suggesting "go diesel!" :)
 
I'm sure you can get all sorts of help here for helping choose. What you need to do is sketch out some rough details.
Budget
Desired end result (stock power, performance, etc..)
Driving habits
Mechanical ability
Etc...etc...etc.
The more info you give the more focused your replies will be. Otherwise you'll have people like me suggesting "go diesel!" :)

well said!
 
if you dont care about stock, V8 fuel injection. More power, better gas milage, reliability. Only down side is cost.
 
V8 or be late.

Oh, wait. I have a 258 with Howell fuel injection. Perfectly adequate for a near stocker, mostly on road. Not too good in the sand. I don't like mud.

Anything will work with the proper gearing, but remember, there is no replacement for displacement. 5.3 Chebby seems to be the sweet spot. Several here have done them.
 
I have had both an AMC 150 and 258 in a CJ. Honestly, not much difference in mileage...but a HUGE difference in useable power.
 
258 with Mopar/Hesco MPI. Good power, great throttle response, not too taxing on the rest of the drive train, no expensive adapters/modifications required, and good mileage (relatively speaking):twocents::thumbsup:
 
I have an AMC 401 which absolutely eats fuel. That being said, the power is awesome. 258 though is a nice torque-y engine that is cheap, simple and bulletproof. If going with a 258, I prefer the 258 without its 1980s era engine control systems personally. Either modify it to get rid of that stuff or get an engine out of a 70s era CJ/AMC vehicle. Just step away from the 4cyl.
 
My CJ5 had a 258 for my first 12 years of ownership. It was bulletproof and never failed me. I even drove it from Utah to Connecticut without a single issue. I got the horsepower bug in 2002 and dropped in a chevy 350 that I built. the power is insane but now the gas mileage is down to 10-12mpg compared to 16-18mpg with the six. Hindsight? I would keep the 258 because I find myself not driving the CJ nearly as much as I used to. Everytime I get in it I know $25 worth of gas will fly out the tail pipe. My Scrambler build is going to be the original 258 with a T5 because this one I plan in daily driving all summer and I want the mileage to be at least as good as my Toyota Tacoma.
 
I put in a vortec 6.0 with auto overdrive (4l60E) and I am getting 17-18 mpg if I keep my foot out of it (10 if I drive stupid)
 
You stated I4 I6 or V8. If you're gonna use an I 4 it needs to be a stout one.

I have a 181ci Mercruiser(Chevy I4 from the 153 181 194 230 250,292 class) in my CJ5 and it has around 180 hp with FI. It does not have enough power. It moves the jeep just fine however even with FI 9-11 MPG is about all it will do. You just have to run it too hard. That Jeep weighs 3200 lbs. If it was a flatty at 2600lbs it would be great.

As far as 6's go a Hesco 258 stroker motor with FI would be a very nice Jeep motor. I don't know the full displacement on those engines but I think you can get close to 300 inches. A real torque monster, but again not a gas economy special.

V8's are most popular and a Chevy truck motor out of a mid 90's truck with FI makes a nice jeep engine. it will also get the ebst fuel mileage as you don't have to run them very hard to go down the road.

Speaking of I4's I have a 4BT Cummins Turbo Diesel in my current project Scrambler and whereas I haven't driven it yet I'm pretty sure it will work out well. When the gearing is finalized we are Expecting 25+ mpg.

The easiest route to success is with the Chevy V8 but make sure you include fuel injection, without it they are just as problematic as any other carburated vehicle on the trail. Nothing more exciting that starting up a serious hill only to have it quit half way up and not want to restart. With FI it will run upside down!

Randy
 
Dito on above reply. Chevy V8 with FI is great. Also 700r automatic is good also. Has a low 1st gear
 
Same here efi ramjet 350 chev, makes 400ftlb torque from 1750rpm all the way to around 5000rpm, with a th700r a great combo, low 1st gear & great overdrive


Sent from
yetiboy01's iPhone
 
5.3 with the overdrive trans. I get 20mpg on the highway (and that was a 4* day, 3500' altitude), and can roast the tires at will. Of course, tire roasting only gets about 10MPG....
 
5.3 with the overdrive trans. I get 20mpg on the highway (and that was a 4* day, 3500' altitude), and can roast the tires at will. Of course, tire roasting only gets about 10MPG....

where is the "like" button??? :D
 
I really like the classic sound of the Jeep six and it's all around reliability.... but there's nothing like the lope of the 8 at idle with the right tuning set up. Then goose the throttle and feel the Jeep torque to the side a tad. The 8's just drink gas and that's the way it is. From here on out though the Jeep will be the weekend or sunny day ride so the gas expense will be part of the feel good factor. And as far as that goes some race fuel always adds that nice aroma to the mix. ;)
 
I'm sure you can get all sorts of help here for helping choose. What you need to do is sketch out some rough details.
Budget
Desired end result (stock power, performance, etc..)
Driving habits
Mechanical ability
Etc...etc...etc.
The more info you give the more focused your replies will be. Otherwise you'll have people like me suggesting "go diesel!" :)

3x as jeepdreamer said... ?? Helps to know end results that you are looking for artie... thx

z :ZZZ:
 
I really like the classic sound of the Jeep six and it's all around reliability.... but there's nothing like the lope of the 8 at idle with the right tuning set up. Then goose the throttle and feel the Jeep torque to the side a tad. The 8's just drink gas and that's the way it is. From here on out though the Jeep will be the weekend or sunny day ride so the gas expense will be part of the feel good factor. And as far as that goes some race fuel always adds that nice aroma to the mix. ;)

I like the way you think. I have the 258 w/ Howell in the Scrambler and it does pretty well. But, I had to give the Waggy a little love and drove it to work this morning. There is no sound as sweet as an AMC V8. It just has that distinctive burble missing from other engines. Jeep pimped my ride straight from the factory.
 
But, I had to give the Waggy a little love and drove it to work this morning. There is no sound as sweet as an AMC V8. It just has that distinctive burble missing from other engines. Jeep pimped my ride straight from the factory.

I couldnt agree with you more!!! :thumbsup:

My completely stock 1978 Waggy with 360 and a stock muffler (no cat in 1978) burbles and I wouldnt trade that sound for anything. My friends say it sounds like an inboard boat engine at idle with the water in the exhaust. But thats what a burble is!

But back to the thread, IMHO, best overall is the 258, with fuel injection for overall use, based on cost, ease of install (or upgrade) and mix of fuel economy and performance. So is a direct swapped High Output 4.0 from an XJ or TJ. But the sky is the limit and the options are immense when it comes to engines...to each their own :cheers:
 
There is no sound as sweet as an AMC V8. It just has that distinctive burble missing from other engines.

I couldnt agree with you more!!! :thumbsup:

My completely stock 1978 Waggy with 360 and a stock muffler (no cat in 1978) burbles and I wouldnt trade that sound for anything. My friends say it sounds like an inboard boat engine at idle with the water in the exhaust. But thats what a burble is!:

^^^I agree with these guys^^^ Nothing sounds as good and unique as an AMC V8! The only other sound I enjoy as much as an AMC V8 is my 24 Valve Cummins w/ a 5" straight pipe!
 
Back
Top