Finally have an update, I posted this same thing in another thread but incase someone was searching for insurance in the future, I figured I would close the loop here.
After several weeks and 4 body shops later, I landed at Collins Brothers. They were super helpful and assured me that once they started digging into it that you/I would never be able to tell that there was ever any damage done. In the first meeting he said that the repairs were going to start at $10k minimum and likely be closer to $15k. Well, that worried me because the jeep was going to be totaled at $12,800, 80% of the stated value with insurance, and that's not what I wanted, but knew I was out of options getting anyone to work on it. Fortunately the estimate from collins brothers came back at $8,100 after they did a thorough inspection and and put the pricing on paper. The next hurdle was getting insurance to pay nearly double the amount of what they initially valued the repair cost at, which was $4,500. Kevin from Collins Brothers handled all of the communication with my insurance company and 5 days later, insurance approved all the additional cost. Yay! Finally getting somewhere after nearly three months of dealing with incompetent body shops. Collins Brothers has already started work and expects to be finished within 3- 4 weeks. I now wish I had put a little more effort of getting in touch with collins brothers from the beginning and I probably would have had my jeep back months ago.
At the end of the day, I am super happy with the way Americans Collectors Insurance handled the claim. They never gave me any grief, they were very helpful in answering questions over the phone and ultimately paid nearly double what they originally estimated without any fuss. From my experience they are very reasonable people and offer insurance at an affordable cost while providing great customer service. I highly recommend them.
Thank you again to everyone for all of the great advice. I'll post pictures once all the work is done and the jeep is back home.
You can see my explanation for the gate malfunction here...
https://www.cj-8.com/forum/showthread.php?37037-Cowl-and-WIndshield-Base-Need-Help-Sourcing/page2